Edmund T. Whittaker’s second edition of his A History of the Theories of Aether and Electricity is famous for his treatment of Einstein as an almost irrelevant character in the emergence of what he called “the relativity theory of Poincaré and Lorentz.” Historians of science have given a number of explanations, which include Whittaker’s scientific conservatism as an old classical physicist, his commitment to the ether, the pre-eminent role he attributed to mathematics over physics, and foundational philosophical disagreements, to name a few. And in the background, often more implicit than forthright, the accusation of antisemitism looms over Whittaker. In this paper I intend to shed new light on this controversy by taking into consideration the abundant correspondence between Whittaker and his son preserved in the archives of the Fisher Library, University of Toronto. With it, we will get a more complex and personal view of the context in which his attempt at dethroning Einstein took place. Together with the abovementioned reasons, this correspondence shows that the problematic status quo of general relativity in the early 1950s, a period that has been described as the low-mark of general relativity, was very influential in the historical treatment he gave to Einstein. This is an aspect hardly mentioned in the historical work on this controversy and, from this correspondence, it appears to be central to understanding Whittaker at the time of drafting the new History. His possible antisemitic bias will also be addressed, though with the insufficient information on this subject the matter cannot be settled.
...More
Article
Wazeck, Milena;
(April 2013)
Marginalization Processes in Science: The Controversy About the Theory of Relativity in the 1920s
(/isis/citation/CBB507613424/)
Article
Robert Marc Friedman;
(2022)
The 100th Anniversary of Einstein's Nobel Prize: Facts and Fiction
(/isis/citation/CBB281209604/)
Article
Lalli, Roberto;
(2013)
Anti-Relativity in Action: The Scientific Activity of Herbert E. Ives between 1937 and 1953
(/isis/citation/CBB001252354/)
Article
Dongen, Jeroen van;
(2007)
Reactionaries and Einstein's Fame: “German Scientists for the Preservation of Pure Science,” Relativity, and the Bad Nauheim Meeting
(/isis/citation/CBB000780203/)
Book
Wazeck, Milena;
(2009)
Einsteins Gegner: die öffentliche Kontroverse um die Relativitätstheorie in den 1920er Jahren
(/isis/citation/CBB001022043/)
Article
Santos, Gildo Magalhães;
(2011)
A Debate on Magnetic Current: The Troubled Einstein--Ehrenhaft Correspondence
(/isis/citation/CBB001024707/)
Article
Crelinsten, Jeffrey;
(1980)
Einstein, relativity, and the press: The myth of incomprehensibility
(/isis/citation/CBB000002880/)
Book
Andrew Robinson;
(2015)
Einstein: A Hundred Years of Relativity
(/isis/citation/CBB667142996/)
Book
Bergia, Silvio;
(1978)
Einstein e la relatività
(/isis/citation/CBB000004432/)
Book
Brown, Harvey R.;
(2005)
Physical Relativity: Space-time Structure from a Dynamical Perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB000651411/)
Chapter
Ferdinando Casolaro;
Raffaele Pisano;
(2009)
Riflessioni sulla geometria nella teoria della relatività
(/isis/citation/CBB781324190/)
Article
Sánchez Ron, José M.;
(1982)
Einstein y Lorentz: Del significado de la relatividad especial a la inconmensurabilidad entre paradigmas
(/isis/citation/CBB000020116/)
Book
Ryan, Dennis P.;
(1987)
Einstein and the humanities
(/isis/citation/CBB000030444/)
Article
Ziadat, Adel A.;
(1994)
Early reception of Einstein's relativity in the Arab periodical press
(/isis/citation/CBB000040051/)
Article
Borzeszkowski, Horst-Heino von;
(1992)
Kantscher Raumbegriff und Einsteins Theorie
(/isis/citation/CBB000042057/)
Article
Haas, J.W., Jr.;
(1988)
Relativity and Christian thought: The early response
(/isis/citation/CBB000054300/)
Article
Norton, John;
(1985)
Einstein's struggle with general covariance
(/isis/citation/CBB000035576/)
Article
Barreau, Hervé;
(1980)
Einstein et les concepts d'espace et de temps
(/isis/citation/CBB000012315/)
Article
Kerszberg, Pierre;
(1987)
The relativity of rotation in the early foundations of general relativity
(/isis/citation/CBB000048839/)
Book
Wolters, Gereon;
(1987)
Mach I, Mach II, Einstein und die Relativitätstheorie: Eine Fälschung und ihre Folgen
(/isis/citation/CBB000064366/)
Be the first to comment!