Taylor, Georgette (Author)
This paper presents an attempt to negotiate the familiar historiographical difficulties of tracing influence in science without fear of accusations of whiggishness. Through a close reading of three papers presented to the Royal Society by Richard Kirwan in the early 1780s on specific gravity, proportions and affinity, it seeks to show that the search for the role of influence in the history of science need not be based on a present-centred value judgement of past science. Prevailing historiography tends to link Kirwan's work to notions of definite combining proportions, settling him firmly on the Proust side of the Berthollet-Proust debate and regarding his work as vaguely precursory to Dalton's atomic theory. My reading suggests, however, that these papers may well have had a surprising level of influence on Berthollet's Chemical Statics and should perhaps be viewed through a somewhat different historical lens. I hope to show that the tracing of historical influence can offer valuable insights to historians of science and that when influence is tracked in small steps only, and forwards rather than backwards, we can legitimately follow it without fear of present-centredness clouding our vision.
...MoreDescription Focuses on the historiographical issues in the examination of Kirwan's science.
Article
Quílez, Juan;
(2006)
The Role of Theories in Early Studies of Chemical Equlibria
(/isis/citation/CBB000741585/)
Article
Newcomb, Sally;
(2012)
Richard Kirwan (1733--1812)
(/isis/citation/CBB001251743/)
Article
Mauskopf, Seymour;
(2002)
Richard Kirwan's Phlogiston Theory: Its Success and Fate
(/isis/citation/CBB000470885/)
Article
Bensaude-Vincent, Bernadette;
(2009)
Le mixte, ou l'affirmation d'une identité de la chimie
(/isis/citation/CBB001021112/)
Article
Boantza, Victor;
(2008)
The Phlogistic Role of Heat in the Chemical Revolution and the Origins of Kirwan's “Ingenious Modifications...Into the Theory of Phlogiston”
(/isis/citation/CBB000774842/)
Book
Kim, Mi Gyung;
(2003)
Affinity, That Elusive Dream: A Genealogy of the Chemical Revolution
(/isis/citation/CBB000301511/)
Article
Rowlinson, J. S.;
(2003)
Le Sage's Essai de chymie méchanique
(/isis/citation/CBB000300272/)
Article
Feng, Xiang;
(2009)
Berthollet's and Kirwan's Phlogiston Theories and Their Fates
(/isis/citation/CBB000952325/)
Article
Akeroyd, F. Michael;
(2008)
Mechanistic Explanation Versus Deductive-Nomological Explanation
(/isis/citation/CBB000930617/)
Article
Kawashima, Keiko;
(2000)
Madame Lavoisier et la traduction française de l'Essay on Phlogiston de Kirwan
(/isis/citation/CBB000110500/)
Article
Taylor, Georgette;
(2008)
Marking Out a Disciplinary Common Ground: The Role of Chemical Pedagogy in Establishing the Doctrine of Affinity at the Heart of British Chemistry
(/isis/citation/CBB000831682/)
Article
Barroux, Gilles;
(2009)
Affinités éclectiques entre chimie et médecine: l'exemple des jeux de renvois dans les articles CHIMIE et MEDECINE de l'Encyclopédie
(/isis/citation/CBB001021114/)
Article
Kim, Mi Gyung;
(2008)
The “Instrumental” Reality of Phlogiston
(/isis/citation/CBB000960289/)
Article
Lehman, Christine;
(2010)
Innovation in Chemistry Courses in France in the Mid-Eighteenth Century: Experiments and Affinities
(/isis/citation/CBB000954578/)
Article
Kawashima, Keiko;
(2003)
Madame Lavoisier et l'Essai sur le phlogistique
(/isis/citation/CBB000470206/)
Chapter
Akeroyd, Michael;
(2003)
The Lavoisier-Kirwan Debate and Approaches to the Evaluation of Theories
(/isis/citation/CBB000600081/)
Article
Kim, Mi Gyung;
(2009)
Entre la physique et la chimie: l'affinité chimique dans l'Encyclopédie
(/isis/citation/CBB001021113/)
Article
Raffa, R. B.;
Tallarida, R. J.;
(2010)
“Affinity”: Historical Development in Chemistry and Pharmacology
(/isis/citation/CBB000954694/)
Chapter
Klein, Ursula;
(2009)
In the Thick of Organic Matter
(/isis/citation/CBB001020634/)
Chapter
Grapí, Pere;
(2011)
The Role of Chemistry Textbooks and Teaching Institutions in France at the Beginning of the Nineteenth Century in the Controversy about Berthollet's Chemical Affinities
(/isis/citation/CBB001024415/)
Be the first to comment!