Thesis ID: CBB951683937

Visual Agency in Euclid's Elements: A Study of the Transmission of Visual Knowledge (2020)


Lee, Eunsoo (Author)
Netz, Reviel (Advisor)
Findlen, Paula (Advisor)
Saito, Ken (Advisor)
Stephens, Susan (Advisor)

Stanford University
Netz, Reviel
Findlen, Paula
Saito, Ken
Stephens, Susan
Publication date: 2020
Language: English

Publication Date: 2020
Physical Details: 615

Through investigation of diagrams in Euclid's Elements, this dissertation aims to study how visual knowledge has been transmitted. In the study of the history of the Elements, there has been an assumption that the text and diagrams in the work were both conveyed together. Upon this conventional assumption, the diagrams were regarded as static or subordinate to the text. This dissertation questions the supposed diagrams' dependence on the text, and argues that we should study the transmission of diagrams as their own process. Visual agency will be explored as an autonomous function of diagram makers to draw according to their discretion. According to the history of the Elements, I classify diagram makers who held visual agency into four groups: scribes, translators, readers, and printing presses. These four types of visual agents interpreted and reinterpreted diagrams over time: 1) scribes corrected diagrams mathematically and systematized them visually; 2) translators filtered the variants of diagrams and invented derivatives of diagrams; 3) readers expanded and proofread mathematical ideas through diagrams; 4) printing presses standardized diagrams and enhanced pedagogical value of them. This analysis of visual agencies leads us to a more comprehensive understanding of the transmission of diagrams. While past scholarship only understood the transmission of diagrams as a perceptual process (conducted through textual instruction and archetype diagrams), this dissertation examines both the perceptual process and the conceptual process (through visual agency). This work reveals the characteristics of the transmission of diagrams as an autonomous and knowledge-conducive process. Indeed, Euclid's diagrams have been the space where the continuous birth of mathematical ideas was invited. The discussion of the visual agency in Euclid's Elements reaches beyond the transmission of mathematical diagrams. The patterns of changes found in the transmission of mathematical diagrams may be compared with those of all sorts of other diagrams such as schematic maps, astronomical diagrams, and theological diagrams. This comparison tells us whether and how mathematical diagrams were different from other diagrams in terms of transmission. In this way the project serves to explore the complex transmission of visual knowledge latent beneath the surface of textual transmission.

Citation URI

This citation is part of the Isis database.

Similar Citations

Article Ken Saito; (2019)
Re-Examination of the Different Origins of the Arithmetical Books of Euclid's Elements (/p/isis/citation/CBB411050920/) unapi

Article De Young, Gregg; (2012)
Mathematical Diagrams from Manuscript to Print: Examples from the Arabic Euclidean Transmission (/p/isis/citation/CBB001211477/) unapi

Article Raynaud, Dominique; (2014)
Building the Stemma Codicum from Geometric Diagrams (/p/isis/citation/CBB001321046/) unapi

Article Geymonat, Mario; (2009)
Arithmetic and Geometry in Ancient Rome: Surveyors, Intellectuals, and Poets (/p/isis/citation/CBB000933728/) unapi

Article De Young, Gregg; (2012)
Further Adventures of the Rome 1594 Arabic Redaction of Euclid's Elements (/p/isis/citation/CBB001232494/) unapi

Article Mateusz Hohol; Marcin Miłkowski; (2019)
Cognitive Artifacts for Geometric Reasoning (/p/isis/citation/CBB220742953/) unapi

Article Saito, Ken; (2012)
Traditions of the Diagram, Tradition of the Text: A Case Study (/p/isis/citation/CBB001211476/) unapi

Article Le Meur, Guy; (2012)
Le rôle des diagrammes dans quelques traités de la Petite astronomie (/p/isis/citation/CBB001211449/) unapi

Article Panza, Marco; (2012)
The Twofold Role of Diagrams in Euclid's Plane Geometry (/p/isis/citation/CBB001211478/) unapi

Article Schemmel, Matthias; (2014)
Medieval Representations of Change and Their Early Modern Application (/p/isis/citation/CBB001201190/) unapi

Article Leeuwen, Joyce van; (2014)
Thinking and Learning from Diagrams in the Aristotelian Mechanics (/p/isis/citation/CBB001450114/) unapi

Book Violet Moller; (2020)
The Map of Knowledge: A Thousand-Year History of How Classical Ideas Were Lost and Found (/p/isis/citation/CBB401001470/) unapi

Article Yang, Zezhong; (2005)
The introduction of the Elements in China (/p/isis/citation/CBB000650784/) unapi

Authors & Contributors
Carman, Christián Carlos
De Young, Gregg
Saito, Ken
Barany, Michael J.
Geymonat, Mario
Leeuwen, Joyce van
Historia Mathematica
Archive for History of Exact Sciences
Centaurus: International Magazine of the History of Mathematics, Science, and Technology
Foundations of Science
Nuncius: Annali di Storia della Scienza
Transmission of texts
Transmission of ideas
Aristarchos of Samos
Time Periods
16th century
Early modern
11th century
15th century
Alexandria (Egypt)
Rome (Italy)
Baghdad (Iraq)

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment