IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB790328362

No Publication, No Fame: Reassessing Arnold Guyot’s (1807–1884) Pioneering Contributions to the Glacial Theory (2023)

Earth Sciences History: Journal of the History of the Earth Sciences Society
Volume: 42
Issue: 1
Pages: 123-159
Publication date: 2023
Language: English

DOI: 10.17704/1944-6187-42.1.123

URI: https://doi.org/10.17704/1944-6187-42.1.123

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Geology Discovery in science Scientific priority Glaciology Scholarly publishing 19th century United States Switzerland Guyot, Arnold

In the summer of 1838, Arnold Guyot was asked by Louis Agassiz to gather information on Alpine glaciers, with the aim of reporting their findings in September, at the annual gathering of the French Geological Society. Guyot’s observations of the internal structure of the ice and interpretations on glacier movements, reported orally at the conference, were new to science. Unfortunately, because of purported illness, Guyot did not send his manuscript to be published and missed his first opportunity to be recognized as a pioneer in glacier studies.During the years 1841 to 1847, Guyot published a series of notes, detailing results of his field work in tracing erratic blocks in the central Alpine region, in the Alpine foreland and in the Jura Mountains. The level of detail in his work was unprecedented and has not been replicated since. Recognizing that erratic blocks of similar lithology could be followed along organized paths of deposition, Guyot could invalidate those theories that sought to explain their deposition by chaotic means, such as floods, debacles or drifting icebergs loaded with rock debris. Only moraines, composed of material transported by glaciers, could explain the mapped arrangements of erratic blocks.Geological proofs for extensive glaciations in central Europe had just been found, and Guyot could demonstrate them on his hand-drawn map. But, in 1848, a revolution broke out in Neuchâtel. The local academy where Guyot was engaged as a professor shut down and all staff were left without pay. Answering a call from Agassiz who had emigrated to the USA in 1846, Guyot departed Switzerland and joined his friend there in the fall of 1848. In his luggage were all the papers on his unfinished project, including his map, and a full collection of erratic rock specimens. After arrival in the USA, Guyot had to begin a new professional life and could not devote significant attention to the subject of erratic blocks. In 1849, he showed his map of the erratic basins of Switzerland and discussed his results with various members of the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS); he also shared his novel ideas about the climatic conditions required for the formation of large glaciers; however, he did not formally publish the results of his work in the Alps, and he thus lost his second opportunity for wider peer recognition and for driving the acceptance of the glacial theory.Only in 1874, 26 years after his arrival in the USA and a year after Agassiz’s death, did Guyot open his boxes of alpine rock specimens and display his unpublished map in the Museum of the College of New Jersey (later Princeton University), where he was engaged as a professor. In 1883, at age 77, his memory of the unpublished 1838 report on glaciers was still in his conscience which finally pushed him to submit it for printing at Neuchâtel. It passed largely unnoticed, however, and Guyot died one year later without recognition attached to his name for his original, innovative work.This paper reviews Guyot’s work and analyses his relationship with Agassiz while both were working in Neuchâtel. It seeks to evaluate his pioneering work on glaciers and on erratic blocks. It includes a copy of Guyot’s map of the erratic basins of Switzerland, kept to this day in the archives of Princeton University.

...More

Citation URI

data.isiscb.org/p/isis/citation/CBB790328362

This citation is part of the Isis database.

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Laura Elizabeth Smith; E. Allen Driggers; (2023)
‘Ex Pede Herculem’: Sloths, Slavery, and Southern Fossil Collection in The Nineteenth Century (/p/isis/citation/CBB397135024/)

Article John van Wyhe; (2016)
The impact of A. R. Wallace's Sarawak Law paper reassessed (/p/isis/citation/CBB120840296/)

Chapter Mary Virginia Orna; Marco Fontani; Carmen J. Giunta; Vera V. Mainz; Gregory S. Girolami; (2021)
Discovery of Three Elements Predicted by Mendeleev’s Table: Gallium, Scandium, and Germanium (/p/isis/citation/CBB197646237/)

Article Roland Jackson; (2020)
Eunice Foote, John Tyndall and a question of priority (/p/isis/citation/CBB580452378/)

Chapter Carmen J. Giunta; Vera V. Mainz; Julianna Poole-Sawyer; Gregory S. Girolami; (2021)
Periodicity in Britain: The Periodic Tables of Odling and Newlands (/p/isis/citation/CBB055966538/)

Thesis Shane Patrick Avery; (2019)
Popular Geography Writing in America, 1783–1888 (/p/isis/citation/CBB130772253/)

Article José Ángel Roldán Casas; (2021)
El reconocimiento del mérito científico a través de la historia de algunos de los epónimos estadísticos más relevantes: ¿Se verifica la ley de Stigler? (/p/isis/citation/CBB844603043/)

Article Yoshiteru Maeno; Yoji Hisamatsu; Kazuhiro Egashira; (2023)
Kenji Yoshihara (1929-2022): Shedding Light on the Work of Masataka Ogawa on His Discovery of the Element "Nipponium." An Obituary-Tribute (/p/isis/citation/CBB410779174/)

Article Luca Guzzardi; (2014)
Sharing Discoveries. Boscovich's Network and the Discovery of Uranus (/p/isis/citation/CBB002254070/)

Article Jerzy Sawicki; (2018)
Kleist vs. Musschenbroek – a difficult way to truth (/p/isis/citation/CBB490328457/)

Chapter Kit Chapman; Carmen J. Giunta; Vera V. Mainz; Gregory S. Girolami; (2021)
Element Discovery and the Birth of the Atomic Age (/p/isis/citation/CBB590479782/)

Article Sachtleben, Peter; (1994)
Hat Goethe die Eiszeit entdeckt? (/p/isis/citation/CBB000058123/)

Book Cruikshank, Julie; (2005)
Do Glaciers Listen? Local Knowledge, Colonial Encounters, and Social Imagination (/p/isis/citation/CBB000740952/)

Article Brice, William R.; Figueirôa, Silvia F. de M.; (2001)
Charles Hartt, Louis Agassiz, and the Controversy over Pleistocene Glaciation in Brazil (/p/isis/citation/CBB000102220/)

Article Oreskes, Naomi; (2013)
Earth Science: How Plate Techtonics Clicked (/p/isis/citation/CBB001320428/)

Article Heitzmann, Peter; (2008)
Die ersten geologischen Karten der Schweiz, 1752--1853 (/p/isis/citation/CBB001024659/)

Article Westermann, Andrea; (2009)
Inherited Territories: The Glarus Alps, Knowledge Validation, and the Genealogical Organization of Nineteenth-Century Swiss Alpine Geognosy (/p/isis/citation/CBB000932763/)

Article Heinrich Hartmann; (2015)
Von der Geomorphologie des Aargau zu den militärischen Pathologien Europas. Das Militär als Schnittpunkt anthropologischer Krisendiskurse, 1860–1900 (/p/isis/citation/CBB251595010/)

Article Coen, Deborah R.; (2012)
The Tongues of Seismology in Nineteenth-Century Switzerland (/p/isis/citation/CBB001230586/)

Article Anita Hollier; John Hollier; (2019)
A visit to Louis-Albert Necker on the Isle of Skye, 1852 (/p/isis/citation/CBB652536443/)