Thesis ID: CBB675465421

Bleeding Nations: Blood Discourses and the Interpretation of Violence in Mid-Nineteenth Century Spanish America (1838-1870) (2020)


Mächler, Alejandro Quintero (Author)
Montaldo, Graciela (Advisor)

Columbia University
Montaldo, Graciela
Publication date: 2020
Language: English

Publication Date: 2020
Physical Details: 527

My dissertation examines how mid-nineteenth century Spanish American letrados in Argentina, Colombia, and Mexico –considered as exemplary case studies–, interpreted the unending violence present in their nations. They did so, I argue, by resorting to what I term “blood discourses”: overdetermined, shared, contested, and unstable textual and visual discourses, wide in connotations but mainly –not solely– coming from an inherited medical and religious tradition. These blood discourses were a direct response to a concrete reality which belied the promises of the independence process: surrounded by civil and international war, political polarization, and “caudillo” authoritarianism, letrados of varied ideological stances made use of and disputed these inherited, ready-made and ready-at-hand “blood discourses” to endow with meaning the national violence that surrounded them and establish foundational narratives. In doing so, they enacted three interconnected intellectual procedures, which I analyze distinctly, in the invigorated public sphere of the time. These three interconnected procedures or operation, in turn, were buttressed by a hemato-centric conception of rhetoric which guaranteed their efficacy: first, letrados developed “circulatory diagnoses”, assuming the role of the nation’s “physician-letrados”, a procedure which will be examined in Juan Manuel de Rosas’s Argentina; second, they engaged in what I term “work on martyrdom”, the elaboration of genealogical martyrdom narratives, as will be shown by analyzing the case of the Archbishop of Bogotá, Manuel José Mosquera; and finally, building upon the first two operations, they effected a “coagulation of memory” which enabled them, in their role as “historian-genealogists”, to construct a representation of national history based and substantiated by the shedding of blood. This last chapter will focus on the Mexican El libro rojo, a landmark work on the nation’s own representation of history. Through a heterogeneous archive of sources belonging to a wide ideological spectrum –newspapers, essays, novels, historical works, images, even monuments– my dissertation contends that these ubiquitous visual and textual discourses on violence lie at the core, as conditions of possibility, of how Spanish American letrados thought, wrote, and visualized the Nation. Additionally, by bringing together religion, political economy, and historiography, it allows blood discourses to bridge distinct realms of the period’s vast intellectual output. Lastly, by adopting an international, continental perspective, it overcomes the disproportionate presence of “national histories” showcasing instead similitudes and differences but also transferences and influences beyond national boundaries. Throughout the dissertation, the productive influence of philosophers, anthropologists, and historians – foremost among them Gil Anidjar, Reinhardt Koselleck, Adriana Cavarero, William Reddy, Hans Blumenberg, Elaine Scarry, Stephen Bann, and Thomas W. Laqueur– helped me frame my concepts and construct my own interpretative schemes. In short, by having an impact on the disciplines of Intellectual History, Religious Studies, and Nation-building, this dissertation hopes to shed new light on how the visual and textual interpretation of violence is inseparable from, and indeed made possible by, what I take to be “blood discourses” and the three intrinsically related operations they gave rise to.

Citation URI

This citation is part of the Isis database.

Similar Citations

Book Marcos Cueto; Eden Medina; Ivan da Costa Marques; Christina Holmes; (2014)
Beyond Imported Magic: Essays on Science, Technology, and Society in Latin America (/p/isis/citation/CBB341148554/) unapi

Book Sean Morey Smith; Christopher Willoughby; (2021)
Medicine and Healing in the Age of Slavery (/p/isis/citation/CBB074773103/) unapi

Article Simón Uribe; (June 2020)
The Trampoline of death: Infrastructural violence in Colombia’s Putumayo frontier (/p/isis/citation/CBB718907690/) unapi

Book Elizabeth Suzanne Kassab; (2019)
Enlightenment on the Eve of Revolution: The Egyptian and Syrian Debates (/p/isis/citation/CBB348340319/) unapi

Thesis Gary Brooten; (2016)
The Very Useful Notion: A Rhetorical History of the Idea of Human-Made Climate Change, 1950-2000 (/p/isis/citation/CBB642785483/) unapi

Thesis Jennifer Edwell; (2020)
Origin Stories: The Rhetorical Ecology of American Birth Medicine (/p/isis/citation/CBB219382625/) unapi

Article Jeffrey Bortz; Marcos Aguila; (Spring-Summer 2017)
Railroad Violence during the Mexican Revolution (/p/isis/citation/CBB338226614/) unapi

Article Gaillard, Jacques; Gaillard, Anne Marie; (1997)
Introduction: The International Mobility of Brains: Exodus or Circulation? (/p/isis/citation/CBB000340252/) unapi

Book Achim, Miruna; Podgorny, Irina; (2013)
Museos al detalle: colecciones, antigüedades e historia natural, 1790--1870 (/p/isis/citation/CBB001500461/) unapi

Book Armus, Diego; (2005)
Avatares de la medicalización en América latina 1870-1970 (/p/isis/citation/CBB000830279/) unapi

Book Hochman, Gilberto; Armus, Diego; (2004)
Cuidar, controlar, curar: ensaios históricos sobre saúde e doença na América Latina e Caribe (/p/isis/citation/CBB000800020/) unapi

Article Bleichmar, Daniela; (2009)
Visible Empire: Scientific Expeditions and Visual Culture in the Hispanic Enlightenment (/p/isis/citation/CBB001022550/) unapi

Article Michael Heath; Max Cooper; (2021)
Wearing the wolf skin: psychiatry and the phenomenon of the berserker in medieval Scandinavia (/p/isis/citation/CBB816628342/) unapi

Article Suárez-Díaz, Edna; (2014)
Indigenous Populations in Mexico: Medical Anthropology in the Work of Ruben Lisker in the 1960s (/p/isis/citation/CBB001421070/) unapi

Article Edna Suárez-Díaz; (2017)
Blood Diseases in the Backyard: Mexican "indígenas" as a Population of Cognition in the Mid-1960s (/p/isis/citation/CBB236322309/) unapi

Authors & Contributors
Armus, Diego C.
Suárez-Díaz, Edna
Achim, Miruna
Bleichmar, Daniela
Conley, Tom
Cueto, Marcos
Hispanic American Historical Review
History of Psychiatry
Medicina nei Secoli - Arte e Scienza
Perspectives on Science
Postcolonial Studies
Railroad History
Harvard University
Columbia University Press
Editora Fiocruz
Louisiana State University Press
Lugar Editorial
MIT Press
Public health
Rhetorical analysis
Science and politics
Mutis, José Celestino
Nuñez Butrón, Manuel
Time Periods
19th century
20th century
18th century
21st century
20th century, late
20th century, early
Latin America
Rockefeller Foundation

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment