Thesis ID: CBB575668376

Light Beyond Modernity's Long Shadow: Social and Medical Science in the Making of the 'State' of Guatemala, 1871-1900 (2020)


Mangraviti, Max (Author)
Gosner, Kevin (Advisor)
Few, Martha (Advisor)

The University of Arizona
Gosner, Kevin
Few, Martha
Publication date: 2020
Language: English

Publication Date: 2020
Physical Details: 355

The present investigation situates late-nineteenth-century Guatemala’s nation-state building project in a broad nexus of Atlantic-World intellectual, medical, and political movements fusing the art of governance to the sciences of nature and humankind; and statesmen, to the ideas, understandings, methodologies, solutions and outcomes they promised. Racial and cultural criteria had long been primary determinants of social status, power, and privilege in colonial and early-Republican Guatemala. However, transnational debates over the meaning behind the concept of race and ever-evolving notions of culture emerged with renewed vigor after mid-century in historical interpretations of the national past, and to serve as a prism for prognosticating the nation’s future. Once combined in a single analysis, they functioned as a meta-language – a discursive bridge connecting disparate phenomena, temporally and spatially. During the processes of analysis and representation, the biases and prejudices of authors originating from within and beyond the national frontier were translated into the language of science in terms of dissimilar states of being human and being in civilization. Biological, and even more so, psychological and sociological diversity, became increasingly associated with fluid ideas surrounding national-level racial and cultural distinctions amongst separate nations in works produced by writers in the United States and Great Britain. Guatemalan authors tended to downplay the significance of race by focusing more intently on reifying the meaning of cultural differences between ‘Indians’ versus ‘Ladinos’ inhabiting the national space. Professional scholars laboring in history, archaeology, anthropology, ethnography, sociology and political science variously associated national-level differences with atomization at a time when contemporary philosophies of governance throughout the Americas and Europe aimed for coalescence, cohesion, and collective collaboration to actualize national-development objectives in the name of the Patria’s best interests. These were not completely new concerns to be sure, yet, the novel order of the nation-state guided by a newer order of modern science and political philosophies then dominant throughout much of Latin America, the United States, and Europe required active forms of intervention for practical reasons, as well as, ideological purposes across the board. Analytical action on the part of individual writers communicated through mutual participation in constructing the laws of human nature and interpreting the meaning of civilization. And as result of collective intellectual movement, these ‘laws’ were embodied in overlapping discursive fields, and concretized as scientific truth through representation of a nationalized racial and cultural ‘self’ and Others in analyses of the historical past and the historicized present. To address these matters, Guatemalan social scientists and reformers in tandem with an international entourage of fellow professionals throughout the Atlantic World appealed to medicine for answers. Medicine, after all, was the science of man in nature; a readily available lens for translating lessons from nature into State strategies of intervention, particularly, in the realms of public health and education. Together, social and medical scientists converted the idea(s) of modernity crafted at home and abroad into government institutions, educational institutes, legislation, and public policy designed to educate and refine the national citizenry through cultivation (culture) of the mind, manners, and through physical biological improvement.

Citation URI

This citation is part of the Isis database.

Similar Citations

Book Chieko Nakajima; (2018)
Body, Society, and Nation – The Creation of Public Health and Urban Culture in Shanghai (/p/isis/citation/CBB681166550/) unapi

Book William Beinart; (2021)
The Scientific Imagination in South Africa (/p/isis/citation/CBB421582004/) unapi

Book Johan Kärnfelt; Karl Grandin; Solveig Jülich; (2018)
Knowledge in Motion: The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences and the Making of Modern Society (/p/isis/citation/CBB297825646/) unapi

Book François Jarrige; Thomas Le Roux; (2021)
The Contamination of the Earth: A History of Pollutions in the Industrial Age (/p/isis/citation/CBB416267621/) unapi

Book Leor Halevi; (2019)
Modern Things on Trial: Islam's global and material reformation in the age of Rida, 1865-1935 (/p/isis/citation/CBB256076447/) unapi

Book Per Wisselgren; (2017)
The Social Scientific Gaze: The Social Question and the Rise of Academic Social Science in Sweden (/p/isis/citation/CBB776388993/) unapi

Book Marta Macedo; Tiago Saraiva; (2019)
Capital Científica: Práticas da Ciência em Lisboa e a História Contemporânea de Portugal (/p/isis/citation/CBB047854671/) unapi

Book Ekmeleddin Ihsanoglu; (2019)
The House of Sciences: The First Modern University in the Muslim World (/p/isis/citation/CBB159129701/) unapi

Multimedia Object Lucas Richert; Monnais, Laurence; (2020)
Laurence Monnais, “The Colonial Life of Pharmaceuticals: Medicines and Modernity in Vietnam” (Cambridge UP, 2019) (/p/isis/citation/CBB981056447/) unapi

Book Biswamoy Pati; Mark Harrison; (2018)
Society, Medicine and Politics in Colonial India (/p/isis/citation/CBB707887835/) unapi

Book Joelle M Abi-Rached; (2020)
ʿAṣfūriyyeh: A History of Madness, Modernity, and War in the Middle East (/p/isis/citation/CBB166333862/) unapi

Thesis Lachlan W. Sands; (2020)
The Emergence of Modernity in the Early Aerospace Industry 1950-1970 (/p/isis/citation/CBB535848896/) unapi

Book William Beinart; Saul Dubow; (2021)
The Scientific Imagination in South Africa: 1700 to the Present (/p/isis/citation/CBB985054539/) unapi

Article Henrique Leitão; Antonio Sánchez; (2017)
Zilsel’s Thesis, Maritime Culture, and Iberian Science in Early Modern Europe (/p/isis/citation/CBB165733981/) unapi

Book Jason Schnittker; (2021)
Unnerved: Anxiety, Social Change, and the Transformation of Modern Mental Health (/p/isis/citation/CBB862882582/) unapi

Book Simon D. Shorvon; (2023)
The Idea of Epilepsy: A Medical and Social History of Epilepsy in the Modern Era (/p/isis/citation/CBB588754214/) unapi

Article Santos, Fabiane Vinente dos; (2007)
Sexualidade e civilização nos trópicos: gênero, medicina e moral na imprensa de Manaus (1895--1915) (/p/isis/citation/CBB000831574/) unapi

Book Jordanova, Ludmilla; (2000)
Defining features: Scientific and medical portraits, 1660-2000 (/p/isis/citation/CBB000110118/) unapi

Authors & Contributors
Beinart, William
Dubow, Saul
Egan, Michael
Grandin, Karl
Halevi, Leor
Harrison, Mark
História, Ciências, Saúde---Manguinhos
Journal of the History of Ideas
New Books Network Podcast
Cambridge University Press
Columbia University Press
MIT Press
Harvard University Press
Oxford University Press
Reaktion Books
Science and society
Medicine and society
Science and politics
Science and technology studies (STS)
Zilsel, Edgar
Time Periods
19th century
20th century
18th century
21st century
Early modern
17th century
South Africa
United States
British Columbia (Canada)
Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment