Amrith, Sunil S. (Advisor)
Subramanian, Ajantha (Advisor)
Yellum, Iris (Author)
Amrith, Sunil S.
Subramanian, Ajantha
Harvard University
Publication date: 2022
Language: English
Physical Details: 175
In the mid-twentieth century, Indian scientists collected wild relatives of the pigeon pea and chickpea, piecing together their traits and useful qualities. Alongside this research and knowledge production, hybrids were created in institutional test fields around India in the hopes of replicating the apparent success of dwarf wheat. As for botanical collection, species were reclassified as knowledge and identification of wild plants expanded. This fractured intellectual history of plants in Indian agricultural and botanical research broadly demonstrates a tension between what I call viability and utility. A division emerges between notions of the unruly plant, often with connections to indigenous communities and traditional remedies, and the economically and biologically viable and standardized plant. Certain subfields among the many specialties in plant sciences emphasized the ecological role of legumes more than others, which continued to focus on inputs and yield in the 1970s. The legume troubles industrial measurements because it takes on multiple roles. The model of dwarf wheat research and commercial hybrid production did not fit onto the unruly legume, which resisted becoming predictable. No one particular hybrid emerged as the clear economical choice for production of commercial pigeon peas, though short duration varieties with a quicker harvest date emerged as promising to agricultural scientists. Because of a widespread perception of a lag in knowledge of legumes, they proved a tantalizing object for improvement and development. In this way, yield and resistance continued to be the goal for agronomists even as the “poor man’s crop” moniker of nonindustrial legumes stuck. The four chapters of the dissertation are organized as Chapter 1: An Intellectual History of Indian Plant Sciences, Chapter 2: The Unpredictable Pulse of the Green Revolution, Chapter 3: The Andaman Islands and Western Ghats in the Botanical Archive, and Chapter 4: Indian Traditional Sciences and Legumes. Chapter 1 argues that while productivism (yield) has been a component of agricultural improvement, it has not been the only element. If utility is a narrow concept which fits wheat, legumes have been part of a broader debate about modern agriculture. Viability is possibility, and legumes in particular seemed to elude the desires of agronomists as they sought to create predictable plants. Chapter 2 argues that no one hybrid emerged as the obvious beneficiary of research and development, rather short duration varieties were the result of multi-faceted efforts in the face of multi-faceted challenges. In the process, ethnographic identifiers were lost, and instead a debate about whether the legume had been modernized emerged, rather than a legume that could match the apparent success of wheat in terms of increased yield. Chapter 3 explains the role of the Andaman Islands and Western Ghats in the formation of Indian plant sciences and suggests they have been used to create and maintain the idea of an agrarian frontier. Chapter 4 argues that certain streams of Indian plant sciences have accommodated various streams of thought and paradigms challenging normative teleologies of scientific progress.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Thesis
Saha, Madhumita;
(2012)
State Policy, Agricultural Research and Transformation of Indian Agriculture with Reference to Basic Food-Crops, 1947--75
Article
Di, Lu;
(2012)
Ancient Chinese People's Knowledge of Macrofungi during the Period from 220 AD to 589 AD
Book
David Gentilcore;
(2024)
Cose rare e ammirande del nuovo mondo. Le piante commestibili americane nell'editoria veneziana tra Cinque e Settecento
Book
Sanford, A. Whitney;
(2012)
Growing Stories from India: Religion and the Fate of Agriculture
Chapter
Reddy, Seetha N.;
(2003)
Food and Fodder: Plant Usage and Changing Sociocultural Landscapes during the Harappan Phase in Gujarat, India
Article
Klanovicz, Jó;
(2010)
Toxicidade e produção de maçãs no sul do Brasil
Book
Winston, Mark L.;
(2002)
Travels in the Genetically Modified Zone
Article
Levidow, Les;
(2002)
Ignorance-Based Risk Assessment? Scientific Controversy over GM Food Safety
Article
Sheldrake, Merlin;
(2012)
Albert Howard and the Mycorrhizal Association
Book
Anja Timmermann;
(2014)
Indigo. Die Analyse eine ökonomischen Wissensbestandes im 18. Jahrhundert
Thesis
Marci Baranski;
(2015)
The Wide Adaptation of Green Revolution Wheat
Article
Berger, Rachel;
(October 2019)
Clarified Commodities: Managing Ghee in Interwar India
Book
Heiko Stoff;
(2015)
Gift in der Nahrung: Zur Genese der Verbraucherpolitik Mitte des 20. Jahrhunderts
Book
Angela N. H. Creager;
Gaudillière, Jean-Paul;
(2021)
Risk on the table : Food production, health, and the environment
Article
Tai Elizabeth Johnson;
(2023)
The Shifting Nature of Subsistence on the Hopi Indian Reservation
Book
Susanne A. Wengle;
(2022)
Black Earth, White Bread: A Technopolitical History of Russian Agriculture and Food
Article
Andrew Urban;
(2023)
Agricultural Public History, Reimagined: Seabrook Farms as a Case Study
Book
Matthew Roth;
(2018)
Magic Bean: The Rise of Soy in America
Book
Swindell, Ken;
Jeng, Alieu;
(2006)
Migrants, Credit and Climate: The Gambian Groundnut Trade, 1834--1934
Article
Diaper, Jeremy;
(2014)
The New English Weekly and the British Organic Husbandry Movement: A Reassessment
Be the first to comment!