Thesis ID: CBB545212015

Republican Monsters: The Cultural Construction of American Positivist Criminology, 1767-1920 (2019)


This dissertation examines the history of and cultural influences on positivist criminology in the United States. From Benjamin Rush to the present day, the U.S. has produced an extensive corpus of empirical and theoretical studies that seeks to discern an objective, scientifically-grounded basis for criminal behavior. American positivist criminology has drawn on numerous subfields and theories, including rational choice / economic theory, biology, and psychology, but in all cases, maintains that a purely scientific explanation of offending is possible. This study proceeds from the perspective that divisions between scientific and non-scientific thought are untenable. Drawing on scholarship in literary criticism and sociology, I argue that positivist criminology confronts an inherent contradiction in purporting to develop a purely scientific account of phenomena that are defined by the moral and cultural sentiments of a society. I thus hypothesize that positivist criminology is in fact reliant on the irrational and fictive cultural tropes and images of crime that it claims to exorcize. The dissertation proceeds by reviewing the literature on the history of criminology, developing a set of functional types or tropes for character analysis, and then examining four separate periods in the development of scientific criminology: eighteenth century studies of rational action, nineteenth century studies of defective reasoning, early twentieth century studies of race and crime, and the development of scientifically informed criminalistics programs. Each of these cases captures a different period and focus in the development of scientific criminology. In threading continuity between these cases, I show how criminological positivism is consistently reliant on culturally informed tropes and characters to render itself sensible and coherent.

Citation URI

This citation is part of the Isis database.

Similar Citations

Book Livio Sansone; (2022)
La Galassia Lombroso (/p/isis/citation/CBB789501643/) unapi

Book Liliosa Azara; Luca Tedesco; (2019)
La donna delinquente e la prostituta: L’eredità di Lombroso nella cultura e nella società italiane (/p/isis/citation/CBB265080867/) unapi

Chapter Mary Gibson; (2019)
Cesare Lombroso and the Gendered Prison (/p/isis/citation/CBB059362876/) unapi

Chapter Riccardo Cavallo; (2019)
«Sposa affettuosa, madre sublime e donna delinquente». Socialismo giuridico e criminalità femminile (/p/isis/citation/CBB246025070/) unapi

Chapter Liliosa Azara; Luca Tedesco; (2019)
La donna delinquente: teorie lombrosiane e pratiche politico-istituzionali in Italia tra Otto e Novecento (/p/isis/citation/CBB305262674/) unapi

Chapter Annacarla Valeriano; (2019)
«Avide dello scandalo». La devianza femminile in manicomio (/p/isis/citation/CBB606589982/) unapi

Article Rosagemma Ciliberti; (2023)
Experiences from the past. Comparative research between hospital archive sources and human remains (/p/isis/citation/CBB741987012/) unapi

Article Lorenzo Leporiere; (2023)
Lombrosian Creatures: Literary Devices for an Effective Popularisation of Science (/p/isis/citation/CBB180612452/) unapi

Book Paolo Mazzarello; (2019)
L'inferno sulla vetta (/p/isis/citation/CBB428414510/) unapi

Article Silvia Iorio; (2019)
Voices from the Past Defending Criminal Anthropology (/p/isis/citation/CBB894279648/) unapi

Book Pietro Ficarra; (2016)
La modernizzazione in Italia e Lombroso. La svolta autoritaria del progresso (1876-1882) (/p/isis/citation/CBB424815764/) unapi

Article Beirne, Piers; (1987)
Adolphe Quetelet and the origins of positivist criminology (/p/isis/citation/CBB000033495/) unapi

Book Wallach, Jennifer Jensen; (2013)
How America Eats: A Social History of U.S. Food and Culture (/p/isis/citation/CBB001202133/) unapi

Article M'charek, Amade; Hagendijk, Rob; Vries, Wiebe de; (2013)
Equal before the Law: On the Machinery of Sameness in Forensic DNA Practice (/p/isis/citation/CBB001320664/) unapi

Book Essig, Mark Regan; (2003)
Edison and the Electric Chair: A Story of Light and Death (/p/isis/citation/CBB000450004/) unapi

Article Isaac, Joel; (2013)
Donald Davidson and the Analytic Revolution in American Philosophy, 1940--1970 (/p/isis/citation/CBB001201202/) unapi

Authors & Contributors
Tedesco, Luca
Azara, Liliosa
Beirne, Piers
Essig, Mark Regan
Gibson, Mary
Hagendijk, Rob
Medicina nei Secoli - Arte e Scienza
Medicina Historica
American Journal of Sociology
Historical Journal
Science, Technology, and Human Values
Edizioni di Storia e Letteratura
Rowman & Littlefield
Medicine and gender
Science and politics
Lombroso, Cesare
Davidson, Donald
Golgi, Camillo
Quetelet, Lambert Adolphe Jacques
Spallanzani, Lazzaro
Volta, Alessandro
Time Periods
19th century
20th century, early
20th century
20th century, late
18th century
21st century
United States
South America
Università di Pavia

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment