Caldwell, Elizabeth Frances (Author)
Science as Culture
Volume: 26
Issue: 3
Pages: 380-407
Publication date: 2017
Language: English
In response to concerns about the standards of training for non-medically qualified homeopathic practitioners, between 1999 and 2009 a number of UK universities taught Bachelor of Science (BSc) degrees in homeopathy. All the courses were subsequently closed following media coverage of a vigorous campaign from scientists against the degree courses. A boundary-work analysis of 65 articles published in the UK print media reveals the use of metaphors from a number of different fields as rhetorical strategies to malign homeopathy education. As well as the commonly used contrasts of profit versus academic integrity, rationality versus faith and logic versus magic, media reports associated homeopathy with new universities and Mickey Mouse degrees, both of which had been denigrated in the press previously. In the press coverage, much attention was also drawn to the fact that the method of repeatedly diluting homeopathic medicines defies both logic and common sense, and the plausibility argument became a decisive blow in the debate over the legitimacy of teaching homeopathy as a science degree. It seems that the boundary work sought to protect the authority of both science and medicine by expelling homeopathy from higher education. These findings contrast with previous studies that suggest that orthodox medicine has occasionally expanded to incorporate desirable aspects of complementary and alternative therapies. Scientists carry out boundary work not just to demarcate the boundaries of science and directly defend their own interests, but also to protect the authority of other allied professions.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Heydon, Susan;
Duffull, Stephen B.;
(2013)
Pharmacy at Otago: The First 50 Years: The School, the Profession and the People
Article
Silvia Waisse;
Motzi Eklöf;
(2019)
Homeopathy in Sweden and Brazil, 1880–1930: ‘Golden ages’ with radically different implications
Article
Derek Cameron;
(2021)
“Imagine the Perfect Vaccine”: Homeopathic Vaccine Alternatives and Vaccine Discourse in English Canada
Article
Virginia Berridge;
(2022)
The Many Endings of Recent Epidemics: HIV/AIDS, Swine Flu 2009, and Policy
Book
Nattrass, Nicoli;
(2012)
The AIDS Conspiracy: Science Fights Back
Article
Peter Weingart;
(2022)
Trust or attention? Medialization of science revisited
Article
Evensen, Darrick T.;
Clarke, Christopher E.;
(2012)
Efficacy Information in Media Coverage of Infectious Disease Risks: An Ill Predicament?
Article
McKeever, Brooke Weberling;
(2013)
News Framing of Autism: Understanding Media Advocacy and the Combating Autism Act
Book
David J. Kenny;
Shelley McKellar;
(2022)
Transforming Dentistry: The Rise and Near Demise of Dentistry at Western University
Book
Tania M. Jenkins;
(2020)
Doctors' Orders: The Making of Status Hierarchies in an Elite Profession
Book
Kelly, James;
Clark, Fiona;
(2010)
Ireland and Medicine in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries
Thesis
Bevins, Michael B.;
(2004)
The Practice of Medicine
Article
Anderson, Warwick;
(2008)
Teaching “Race” at Medical School: Social Scientists on the Margin
Article
Elena Varotto;
Mauro Vaccarezza;
Roberta Ballestriero;
Domenico Tafuri;
Francesco Galassi;
(2019)
The teaching of anatomy throughout the centuries: from Herophilus to plastination and beyond
Article
Müller, Ruth;
(2014)
Postdoctoral Life Scientists and Supervision Work in the Contemporary University: A Case Study of Changes in the Cultural Norms of Science
Article
Evans, James A.;
(2010)
Industry Collaboration, Scientific Sharing, and the Dissemination of Knowledge
Chapter
Barnett, Ronald;
(2005)
Re-opening Research: New Amateurs or New Professsionals?
Article
Ruiz-Berdún, Dolores;
(2013)
La primera enseñanza reglada de las matronas en España: El Real Colegio de Cirugía de San Carlos de Madrid
Article
McCauley, H. Berton;
(2003)
The First Dental College: Emergence of Dentistry as an Autonomous Profession
Article
Campos, Paulo Fernando de Souza;
(2013)
Memorial de Maria de Lourdes Almeida: história e enfermagem no Brasil pós-1930
Be the first to comment!