Death and disappearance at border crossings: factualization devices and truth(s) accounts (2022)
Anna Rahel Fischer (Author)
Paola Díaz Lize (Author)
Tapuya: Latin American Science, Technology and Society
Volume: 5
Issue: 1
Publication date: 2022
Language: English
Edition Details: Thematic Cluster: Document, Factualize and Commensurate
Physical Details: Digital journal
In this article, we analyze three forensic and counter-forensic devices that go beyond the strictly medico-legal realm to show which concrete practices and truth-spots contribute to (re)constructing a public account of migrant deaths and disappearances along border zones. Drawing on written documents and semi-structured interviews, we examine operations led by the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) in Europe and Africa, the work of the Pima County Office of the Medical Examiner (PCOME) together with the NGO Colibrí Center for Human Rights in Arizona, and Forensic Oceanography's (FO) open-source investigations of shipwrecks of migrants in the Central Mediterranean Sea and the structural violence embedded in militarized border regimes. We argue that these practices constitute factualization devices, namely practices that transform lived experience of death and disappearance into an objectified reality that can be visibilized and mobilized in the public sphere as part of a counter-narrative. We demonstrate how these factualization practices are imbricated in valuation practices, i.e. practices that ascribe not only an epistemological but also an ethical, aesthetic and political value to the work of objectification, which inform the production of truth narratives.
...MoreArticle Díaz, Paola; Oriana Bernasconi (2022) Factualize and commensurate human rights violations and organized violence. Tapuya: Latin American Science, Technology and Society.
Similar Citations
Article
Marisol López;
Jefferson Jaramillo;
Oriana Bernasconi;
(2022)
The number of disappearance: trajectories in the tally of victims of forced disappearance in Latin America
Article
Suarez, Andrés Fernando;
(2022)
Figures and responsibilities in contexts of mass violence: limits and risks of quantification in transitional justice in Colombia
Article
Fredy Mora-Gámez;
(2023)
The official record of victims as a bordering technology: Knowledge and (in)visibilities in post-conflict Colombia
Article
Díaz, Paola;
Oriana Bernasconi;
(2022)
Factualize and commensurate human rights violations and organized violence
Book
Jinee Lokaneeta;
(2020)
The Truth Machines: Policing, Violence, and Scientific Interrogations in India
Chapter
Taline Garibian;
Willemijn Ruberg;
Lara Bergers;
Pauline Dirven;
Sara Serrano Martínez;
(2023)
The making of evidence after mass violence: Forensics in the aftermath of the Second World War
Article
Lindsay A. Smith;
(June 2017)
The missing, the martyred and the disappeared: Global networks, technical intensification and the end of human rights genetics
Thesis
Margaret Irene O'Donnell;
(2016)
Bones of Contention: Forensic Science and Human Rights Violations from the Katyn Forest to The Hague
Article
Rita Vanobberghen;
Fred Louckx;
Anne-Marie Depoorter;
Dirk Devroey;
Jan Vandevoorde;
(2019)
The Role of Physicians During Hunger Strikes of Undocumented Migrant Workers in a Non-Custodial Setting
Article
Annalisa Pelizza;
(2020)
Processing Alterity, Enacting Europe: Migrant Registration and Identification as Co-construction of Individuals and Polities
Book
Stephen L. Harp;
(2022)
The Riviera, Exposed: An Ecohistory of Postwar Tourism and North African Labor
Article
Meredith B. Linn;
(2022)
Neither Snake Oils nor Miracle Cures: Interpreting Nineteenth-Century Patent Medicines
Book
Chelsea Rose;
Kennedy, Jonathan Ryan;
(2020)
Chinese diaspora archaeology in North America
Article
Sareeta Amrute;
(2020)
Bored Techies Being Casually Racist: Race as Algorithm
Article
James W. Hunter;
Kieran Hosty;
Rick Bullers;
Irini Malliaros;
Adam Paterson;
Chris Wilson;
Tim Zapor;
Katarina Jerbic;
Wendy van Duivenvoorde;
(2023)
Unearthing South Australia’s Oldest Known Shipwreck: The Bark South Australian (1837)
Book
Matthew C. Reilly;
(2019)
Archaeology below the cliff : Race, class, and Redlegs in Barbadian sugar society
Article
Eric D. Tourigny;
(2020)
Maintaining Traditions: Food and Identity among Early Immigrants to Upper Canada
Article
Ji-Hye Shin;
(2021)
“Insanity Is the Price of Modern Civilization”: The Discourse of Civilization and the Asian Insane in Modern America
Book
Iker Saitua;
(2019)
Basque immigrants and Nevada's sheep industry: geopolitics and the making of an agricultural workforce, 1880-1954
Article
Joe Regan;
(2022)
Irish Canallers and the Second Slavery in the Lower Mississippi Valley
Be the first to comment!