Is an Archaeological Contribution to the Theory of Social Science Possible?. Archaeological Data and Concepts in the Dispute Between Jean-Claude Gardin and Jean-Claude Passeron (2017)
Plutniak, Sébastien (Author)
Palethnologie: Archéologie et sciences humaines
Issue: 9
Publication date: 2017
Language: English
The issue of the definition and position of archaeology as a discipline is examined in relation to the dispute which took place from 1980 to 2009 between the archaeologist Jean-Claude Gardin and the sociologist Jean-Claude Passeron. This case study enables us to explore the actual conceptual relationships between archaeology and the other sciences (as opposed to those wished for or prescribed). The contrasts between the positions declared by the two researchers and the rooting of their arguments in their disciplines are examined: where the sociologist makes use of his philosophical training, the archaeologist relies mainly on his work on semiology and informatics. Archaeology ultimately plays a minor role in the arguments proposed. This dispute therefore cannot be considered as evidence for the movement of concepts between archaeology and the social sciences. A blind spot in the debate, relating to the ontological specificities of archaeological objects, nevertheless presents itself as a possible way of implementing this movement.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Sébastien Plutniak;
(2018)
Aux prémices des humanités numériques? La première analyse automatisée d'un réseau économique ancien (Gardin Garelli, 1961). Réalisation, conceptualisation, réception
(/p/isis/citation/CBB631225558/)
Article
Sébastien Plutniak;
(2017)
L'innovation méthodologique, entre bifurcation personnelle et formation des disciplines : Les entrées en archéologie de Georges Laplace et de Jean-Claude Gardin
(/p/isis/citation/CBB334786432/)
Article
Sébastien Plutniak;
(2021)
Assyrian merchants meet nuclear physicists: History of the early contributions from social sciences to computer science. The case of automatic pattern detection in graphs (1950s–1970s)
(/p/isis/citation/CBB594091280/)
Article
Philippe Fontaine;
(2020)
Calling the Social Sciences Names
(/p/isis/citation/CBB117012073/)
Book
Adela Hîncu;
Viktor Karády;
(2018)
Social sciences in the "Other Europe" since 1945
(/p/isis/citation/CBB840332647/)
Book
Mark Solovey;
Christian Dayé;
(2021)
Cold War Social Science: Transnational Entanglements
(/p/isis/citation/CBB237888537/)
Article
Turner, Charles;
(2015)
Travels without a Donkey: The Adventures of Bruno Latour
(/p/isis/citation/CBB001551408/)
Article
Aleksei Lokhmatov;
(2020)
Auf dem Weg zur „Einheit“: Józef Chałasiński und die Suche nach einer „erlaubten“ Genealogie der Soziologie im Nachkriegspolen (1945–1951)
(/p/isis/citation/CBB018534008/)
Article
Breslau, Daniel;
(December 2013)
Designing a market-like entity: Economics in the politics of market formation
(/p/isis/citation/CBB008203841/)
Book
Pittenger, Mark;
(2012)
Class Unknown: Undercover Investigations of American Work and Poverty from the Progressive Era to the Present
(/p/isis/citation/CBB001214618/)
Book
Giovanni Carrosio;
Alessandra Landi;
(2023)
Spazio, ambiente, territorio. Teorie, metodi e prospettive di ricerca in sociologia
(/p/isis/citation/CBB971929401/)
Book
Dirlik, Arif;
Li, Guannan;
Yen, Hsiao-pei;
(2012)
Sociology and Anthropology in Twentieth-Century China: Between Universalism and Indigenism
(/p/isis/citation/CBB001202153/)
Book
Haney, David Paul;
(2008)
The Americanization of Social Science: Intellectuals and Public Responsibility in the Postwar United States
(/p/isis/citation/CBB000830872/)
Book
Backhouse, Roger E.;
Fontaine, Philippe;
(2010)
The History of the Social Sciences since 1945
(/p/isis/citation/CBB001023182/)
Article
Rohde, Joy;
(2009)
Gray Matters: Social Scientists, Military Patronage, and Democracy in the Cold War
(/p/isis/citation/CBB001030366/)
Chapter
Åsa Andersson;
(2013)
Successful Ageing in Modern Social Gerontology: A Historical Perspective on Theories of Activity and Disengagement
(/p/isis/citation/CBB248923854/)
Article
Leonidas Tsilipakos;
(2022)
The idea of an ethically committed social science
(/p/isis/citation/CBB097648298/)
Book
Latham, Michael E.;
(2000)
Modernization as Ideology: American Social Science and “Nation Building” in the Kennedy Era
(/p/isis/citation/CBB000330839/)
Article
Cassata, Francesco;
(2005)
Un'internazionale di destra: l'Institut International de Sociologie (1950--1970)
(/p/isis/citation/CBB000660074/)
Thesis
Tal Arbel;
(2016)
'The American Soldier' in Jerusalem: How Social Science and Social Scientists Travel
(/p/isis/citation/CBB203612881/)
Be the first to comment!