IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB113445617

Edward Hitchcock, Roderick Murchison, and rejection of the alpine glacial theory (1840-1845) (2018)

Earth Sciences History: Journal of the History of the Earth Sciences Society
Volume: 37
Issue: 2
Pages: 380-402
Publication date: 2018
Language: English

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Earth sciences Controversies and disputes Glaciology Glaciers 19th century Agassiz, Jean Louis Rodolphe Hitchcock, Edward Murchison, Roderick Impey

Massachusetts geologist Edward Hitchcock was among the first of his American colleagues to investigate the glacial theory of Swiss geologist Louis Agassiz. After studying a copy of Agassiz's Études sur les Glaciers 1840, Hitchcock displayed an initial enthusiasm regarding its explanatory powers in the published version of his presidential address before the newly-founded Association of American Geologists, and in his concurrently-published Final Report on the Geology of Massachusetts 1841. But that same year, Hitchcock also undertook a 400-mile journey to the White Mountains of New Hampshire, to test the possible validity of a hypothetico-deductive argument that he had formulated, about whether Alpinestyle glaciers had once descended from their summits. From the lack of supporting field evidence, Hitchcock abruptly retreated into a non-committal stance that merely argued for some combination of ice-and-water that he labeled “glacio-aqueous action.” In the following year, Hitchcock engaged in a brief controversy with British geologist Roderick Murchison, in which the two men accused each other of mis-representing his support for the glacial theory. In reality, both had ended up on exactly the same side of the debate, having independently reached identical conclusions concerning rejection of the Alpine glacial theory. Hitchcock's stance appears to have influenced at least a few of his American colleagues to adopt this line of reasoning. But neither Hitchcock, nor Murchison, was able to extrapolate from the notion of Alpine to continental glaciation, as Agassiz had daringly conjectured, with the result that acceptance of the glacial theory was delayed for the next two decades or more. Ironically, neither man seemed to have realized that they had reached a virtual consensus on this question.

...More

Citation URI

data.isiscb.org/p/isis/citation/CBB113445617

This citation is part of the Isis database.

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Brice, William R.; Figueirôa, Silvia F. de M.; (2001)
Charles Hartt, Louis Agassiz, and the Controversy over Pleistocene Glaciation in Brazil (/p/isis/citation/CBB000102220/)

Article Silliman, Robert H.; (1994)
Agassiz vs. Lyell: Authority in the assessment of the diluvium-drift problem by North American geologists, with particular reference to Edward Hitchcock (/p/isis/citation/CBB000035718/)

Chapter Guglielmina Adele Diolaiuti; (2022)
Quando il ghiaccio glaciale incontra il fuoco del vulcano: dalla geografia alla letteratura (/p/isis/citation/CBB377165446/)

Article David Fedman; Martin Hood; (2019)
Hotly Debated Ice: Scholar Alpinism and the Great Glacier Controversy in Modern Japan (/p/isis/citation/CBB097532171/)

Article Vargas, Milton; (1991)
Louis Agassiz and the story of geological surface formations in Brazil (/p/isis/citation/CBB000046930/)

Article Campbell, Ian; Hutchison, David; (1978)
A question of priorities: Forbes, Agassiz, and their disputes on glacier observations (/p/isis/citation/CBB000015340/)

Article Dexter, Ralph W.; (1989)
Historical aspects of Agassiz's lectures on glacial geology (1860-61) (/p/isis/citation/CBB000064049/)

Chapter Jamie Wood; Janet Wilmshurst; Rewi Newnham; Matt McGlone; (2017)
Evolution and Ecological Change During the New Zealand Quaternary (/p/isis/citation/CBB260017387/)

Article Dania Achermann; (2020)
Vertical Glaciology: The Second Discovery of the Third Dimension in Climate Research (/p/isis/citation/CBB154548016/)

Chapter James Shulmeister; (2017)
Blowing on the West Wind. The Most Recent Quaternary Glaciation of New Zealand (/p/isis/citation/CBB507412215/)

Article Jordan D. II Marché; (2019)
“Giant Birds of Old”: An 1837 poem by James Dwight Dana (?) on the supposed makers of the Connecticut Valley's fossil trackways (/p/isis/citation/CBB796867178/)

Article Robert T. McMaster; (2020)
Edward Hitchkock's geological survey of Massachusetts, 1830-1833 (/p/isis/citation/CBB010072242/)

Article John Hollier; Anita Hollier; (2016)
The Glacier Theory of Louis Rendu (1789–1859) and the Forbes–Tyndall Controversy (/p/isis/citation/CBB397436867/)

Article Nanna Katrine Lüders Kaalund; (2017)
A Frosty Disagreement: John Tyndall, James David Forbes, and the Early Formation of the X-Club (/p/isis/citation/CBB957316210/)

Article Geir Hestmark; (2017)
Tracings of the north of Europe: Robert Chambers in search of the Ice Age (/p/isis/citation/CBB718495801/)

Article Wutzke, Ulrich; (2000)
Deutsche Geologen auf dem Mars---oder: 163 Jahre Glazialtheorie von Agassiz (/p/isis/citation/CBB000340437/)

Article Diemer, John A.; (2008)
Murchison's Research Method: An Example from Southern Norway (/p/isis/citation/CBB000850787/)

Book Collie, Michael; Diemer, John; (2004)
Murchison's Wanderings in Russia: His Geological Exploration of Russia in Europe and the Ural Mountains, 1840 and 1841 (/p/isis/citation/CBB000771625/)

Chapter John A. Diemer; (2018)
Fossil collections and mapping the Silurian: An example from Scandinavia (/p/isis/citation/CBB847383821/)

Article Monson, Charles; (2012)
Louis Agassiz and the Fossil Reefs of Iowa (/p/isis/citation/CBB001251738/)