Goldin, Owen (Author)
Science in Context
Volume: 28, no. 2
Issue: 2
Pages: 171-193
Publication date: 2015
Language: English
At Metaphysics A 5 986a22-b2, Aristotle refers to a Pythagorean table, with two columns of paired opposites. I argue that 1) although Burkert and Zhmud have argued otherwise, there is sufficient textual evidence to indicate that the table, or one much like it, is indeed of Pythagorean origin; 2) research in structural anthropology indicates that the tables are a formalization of arrays of "symbolic classification" which express a pre-scientific world view with social and ethical implications, according to which the presence of a principle on one column of the table will carry with it another principle within the same column; 3) a close analysis of Aristotle's arguments shows that he thought that the table expresses real causal relationships; and 4) Aristotle faults the table of opposites with positing its principles as having universal application and with not distinguishing between those principles that are causally prior and those that are posterior. Aristotle's account of scientific explanation and his own explanations that he developed in accordance with this account are in part the result of his critical encounter with this prescientific Pythagorean table
...MoreSimilar Citations
Chapter
Mueller, Ian;
(2007)
La physique et la philosophie: le tournant conceptuel du IVe siècle
(/p/isis/citation/CBB001022496/)
Book
Jean De Groot;
(2014)
Aristotle's Empiricism: Experience and Mechanics in the 4th Century B.C.
(/p/isis/citation/CBB831868874/)
Book
Jacomien Prins;
Maude Vanhaelen;
(2017)
Sing Aloud Harmonious Spheres: Renaissance Conceptions of Cosmic Harmony
(/p/isis/citation/CBB071701613/)
Book
Marco Cilione;
(2020)
Pythagorica medica: Scienza e sapienza nella tradizione preippocratica
(/p/isis/citation/CBB867692984/)
Article
Gregory, Andrew;
(2012)
Kennedy and Stichometry---Some Methodological Considerations
(/p/isis/citation/CBB001251229/)
Book
Horky, Phillip Sidney;
(2013)
Plato and Pythagoreanism
(/p/isis/citation/CBB001421742/)
Book
Zhmud, Leonid;
Windle, Kevin;
Ireland, Rosh;
(2012)
Pythagoras and the Early Pythagoreans
(/p/isis/citation/CBB001451645/)
Article
Fabio Bellissima;
(2011)
L'anamorfosi logaritmica degli intervalli pitagorici
(/p/isis/citation/CBB342675550/)
Article
Warren, James;
(2015)
The Bloom of Youth
(/p/isis/citation/CBB001552139/)
Thesis
Cirillo, Thomas McCulloch;
(2012)
Categorizing Difference: Classification, Biology, and Politics in Aristotelian Philosophy
(/p/isis/citation/CBB001561021/)
Book
Colette Sirat;
Marc Geoffroy;
(2021)
De la faculté rationnelle: l'original arabe du Grand Commentaire d'Averroès (Šarḥ) au De Anima d'Aristote (III, 4-5, 429a10-432a14)
(/p/isis/citation/CBB675604610/)
Article
Marcella Giulia Lorenzi;
Mauro Francaviglia;
(2010)
Dal cosmo al numero e alla geometria euclidea
(/p/isis/citation/CBB384645759/)
Article
Paolo Bussotti;
(2023)
Parmenides, the Founder of Abstract Geometry: Enriques Interpreter of the Eleatic Thought
(/p/isis/citation/CBB061352570/)
Article
Caleon, Imelda;
Ramanathan, Subramaniam;
(2008)
From Music to Physics: The Undervalued Legacy of Pythagoras
(/p/isis/citation/CBB001032881/)
Article
Nicola Scafetta;
Adriano Mazzarella;
(2019)
The city of the sun and Parthenope: classical astronomy and the planning of Neapolis, Magna Graecia
(/p/isis/citation/CBB189015245/)
Article
Fabio Bellissima;
(2011)
L'antanairesi e la teoria armonica greca
(/p/isis/citation/CBB718056038/)
Article
Manuel Bertolini;
(2017)
Numeri e alterità. L'eco di Pitagora nella Taumatologia di Giovan Battista Della Porta
(/p/isis/citation/CBB784619821/)
Chapter
Bolton, Martha Brandt;
(2013)
Change in the Monad
(/p/isis/citation/CBB001553044/)
Article
Manuel Bertolini;
(2016)
La Ruota Armonica: pitagorismo e scienza moderna in Federico Borromeo
(/p/isis/citation/CBB299301022/)
Chapter
Franco Bacchelli;
(2012)
Appunti sulla prima fortuna basileese e francese dello "Zodiacus vitae" del Palingenio
(/p/isis/citation/CBB655068651/)
Be the first to comment!