Johns, Adrian (Author)
Cultural Studies
Volume: 20
Pages: 145--164
Publication date: 2006
Language: English
The debate about the patenting of research is perhaps the most passionate now taking place about science and scientific culture. It is widely maintained that the expansion of patenting since about 1980 betrays a scientific tradition to which norms of universalism and common ownership of knowledge were central. This paper goes back to mid-twentieth century debates about science and intellectual property (IP) to argue that many of the norms we take as so central to science were themselves first articulated to critique patenting practices. In particular, it looks at how an economist (Arnold Plant), a scientist/philosopher (Michael Polanyi), and an information theorist (Norbert Wiener) responded to such practices. It especially focuses on the role of intellectual-property concerns in the making of Polanyi's philosophy of science, which it excavates through a reading of his unpublished papers. This reveals that the modern field of 'science studies' is indebted for some of its key concepts to an earlier generation of patent wars - an inheritance that exemplifies some of the strange ways in which the sociopolitical meanings of ideas can change from generation to generation. The point is not that present-day critics of scientific patenting are wrong, but that the very terms of the debate are more deeply-seated in the development of scientific culture than any of us has realized. Keywords: intellectual property; patenting; science studies; Michael Polanyi; Arnold Plant; Norbert Wiener
...MoreDescription “Especially focuses on the role of intellectual-property concerns in the making of Polanyi's philosophy of science.” (from the abstract)
Similar Citations
Article
Scheiding, Tom;
(2009)
Paying for Knowledge One Page at a Time: The Author Fee in Physics in Twentieth-Century America
Book
Boldrin, Michele;
Levine, David K.;
(2008)
Against Intellectual Monopoly
Book
Roberto Berveglieri;
(2020)
«Ingegnosi artificij»: Serenissima Repubblica di Venezia. Trecento anni di storia della scienza, della tecnica e dell’innovazione (1474-1788)
Article
Greene, Jeremy A.;
(2013)
The Materiality of the Brand: Form, Function, and the Pharmaceutical Trademark
Essay Review
Cooper, Carolyn C.;
(2010)
Does Intellectual Property Protection Mean Pursuit of Patent Perpetuity?
Book
Galvez-Behar, Gabriel;
(2008)
La République des inventeurs: Propriété et organisation de l'innovation en France (1791--1922)
Article
Mead, Walter B.;
(2011)
A Symposium on the Relevance of Michael Polanyi's Insights to a Reformulated Understanding of Science, Technology, and Society
Book
B. Zorina Khan;
(2020)
Inventing ideas : patents, prizes, and the knowledge economy
Book
Mowery, David C.;
(2004)
Ivory Tower and Industrial Innovation: University-Industry Technology before and after the Bayh-Dole Act in the United States
Article
Adi Sapir;
Amalya L. Oliver;
(February 2017)
From academic laboratory to the market: Disclosed and undisclosed narratives of commercialization
Chapter
Simone Turchetti;
(2009)
Il brevetto, la bomba atomica e l'FBI : storia del brevetto Fermi sul metodo per la produzione di sostanze radioattive artificiali, 1934-1953
Book
Graeme Gooday;
Wilf, Steven Robert;
(2020)
Patent cultures : diversity and harmonization in historical perspective
Article
Kraemer, Sylvia Katharine;
(2001)
Federal Intellectual Property Policy and the History of Technology: The Case of NASA Patents
Book
Peter H. Christensen;
(2024)
Prior Art: Patents and the Nature of Invention in Architecture
Thesis
Gerardo Con Diaz;
(2016)
Intangible Inventions: A History of Software Patenting in the United States, 1945-1985
Article
Spadavecchia, Anna;
Scott, Peter;
(2019)
Fundamental Patents, National Intellectual Property Regimes, and the Development of New Industries in Britain and America during the Second Industrial Revolution
Article
Barbara Brandl;
Leland L. Glenna;
(July 2017)
Intellectual Property and Agricultural Science and Innovation in Germany and the United States
Article
Antoine Lentacker;
(2016)
The Symbolic Economy of Drugs
Article
Fischer, Frank;
Mandell, Alan;
(2009)
Michael Polanyi's Republic of Science: The Tacit Dimension
Book
Nye, Mary Jo;
(2011)
Michael Polanyi and His Generation: Origins of the Social Construction of Science
Be the first to comment!