A geologist and an Egyptologist in conversation: Sir Charles Lyell and Sir John Gardner Wilkinson (2022)
Frost, Robert (Author)
Notes and Records: The Royal Society Journal of the History of Science
Volume: 78
Issue: 1
Pages: 143-166
The history of archaeology, and of Egyptology, has traditionally been written as a linear narrative of progress, with narrow-minded amateurs—the antiquaries—giving way to professional archaeologists. For some, Joseph Hekekyan's excavations (co-directed by Leonard Horner) at Memphis and Heliopolis in the 1850s have been seen as a turning point, when the geological principle of stratigraphy was applied to archaeology, thus giving rise to methodical scientific excavation. This article challenges the existing narrative by showing how critiques of Hekekyan's excavation and Horner's interpretation, by the antiquary and historian Samuel Sharpe, inspired the eminent geologist Charles Lyell to seek the opinion of John Gardner Wilkinson, another leading antiquarian Egyptologist, as to the validity of the excavations. Wilkinson's specialist knowledge of Egypt enabled him to identity the problematic assumptions that underpinned the excavation programme, which other leading scholars had missed. Though Lyell was unsuccessful in obtaining the support he desired, he became aware of the more complex situation on the ground in Egypt. Instead of ushering in an age of scientific Egyptology, the Horner–Hekekyan programme highlights how new methodological techniques were contested by contemporaries, and did not immediately or necessarily translate into improved knowledge: a much-neglected dimension in fieldwork-centred disciplinary histories.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Meira Gold;
(2018)
Ancient Egypt and the Geological Antiquity of Man, 1847–1863
(/isis/citation/CBB995607914/)
Article
Luckhurst, Roger;
(2012)
Science versus Rumour: Artefaction and Counter-Narrative in the Egyptian Rooms of the British Museum
(/isis/citation/CBB001212977/)
Book
Dorothy U. Seyler;
(2015)
The Obelisk and the Englishman: The Pioneering Discoveries of Egyptologist William Bankes
(/isis/citation/CBB583337184/)
Book
Gange, David;
(2013)
Dialogues with the Dead: Egyptology in British Culture and Religion, 1822--1922
(/isis/citation/CBB001450668/)
Book
Kathleen Sheppard;
(2022)
Tea on the terrace: Hotels and Egyptologists’ social networks, 1885–1925
(/isis/citation/CBB937425407/)
Book
Buchwald, Jed Z.;
Josefowicz, Diane Greco;
(2010)
The Zodiac of Paris: How an Improbable Controversy over an Ancient Egyptian Artifact Provoked a Modern Debate between Religion and Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001020608/)
Article
Thomasson, Fredrik;
(2010)
Att läsa egyptiska. J. D. Åkerblad och orientaliska studier under invasion och krig
(/isis/citation/CBB001220306/)
Book
Sheppard, Kathleen L.;
(2013)
The Life of Margaret Alice Murray: A Woman's Work in Archaeology
(/isis/citation/CBB001200996/)
Thesis
Sheppard, Kathleen L.;
(2010)
The Lady and the Looking Glass: Margaret Murray's Life in Archaeology
(/isis/citation/CBB001561051/)
Article
Echlin, Alexander;
(2014)
Dynasty, Archaeology and Conservation: The Bourbon Rediscovery of Pompeii and Herculaneum in Eighteenth-Century Naples
(/isis/citation/CBB001421839/)
Book
Gene Kritsky;
(2015)
The Tears of RE: Beekeeping in Ancient Egypt
(/isis/citation/CBB735293405/)
Chapter
Doyon, Wendy;
(2014)
On Archaeological Labor in Modern Egypt
(/isis/citation/CBB001510042/)
Article
Levitin, Dmitri;
(2015)
Egyptology, the Limits of Antiquarianism, and the Origins of Conjectural History, c. 1680--1740: New Sources and Perspectives
(/isis/citation/CBB001552595/)
Article
Barany, Michael J.;
(2010)
Great Pyramid Metrology and the Material Politics of Basalt
(/isis/citation/CBB001023790/)
Book
Kathleen Sheppard;
(2024)
Women in the Valley of the Kings: The Untold Story of Women Egyptologists in the Gilded Age
(/isis/citation/CBB147611092/)
Article
Marchand, Fabienne;
(2014)
The Archaeological Society and the Development of Epigraphy in Nineteenth-Century Greece
(/isis/citation/CBB001421848/)
Article
Freeman, P.W.M.;
(2014)
Mommsen, Hübner, Haverfield, Watkin and Corpus Inscriptionum Latinarum vol. VII
(/isis/citation/CBB001421849/)
Book
Stefanie Gänger;
(2014)
Relics of the Past: The Collecting and Studying of Pre-Columbian Antiquities in Peru and Chile, 1837 - 1911
(/isis/citation/CBB973705521/)
Book
Pratik Chakrabarti;
(2020)
Inscriptions of Nature: Geology and the Naturalization of Antiquity
(/isis/citation/CBB228017644/)
Book
Nichols, Kate;
(2015)
Greece and Rome at the Crystal Palace: Classical Sculpture and Modern Britain, 1854--1936
(/isis/citation/CBB001422639/)
Be the first to comment!