Quantitative information is one of the means used to interface science with policy. As a consequence, much effort is invested in producing quantitative information for policy and much criticism is directed toward the use of numbers in policy. In this paper, I analyze five approaches drawn from such criticisms and propose alternative uses of quantitative information for governance: (i) valuation of ecosystem services, (ii) social multicriteria evaluation, (iii) quantification of uncertainty through the Numeral, Unit, Spread, Assessment, Pedigree approach, (iv) Quantitative Story-Telling, and (v) the heuristic use of statistics. The analysis shows the varied ways that numbers are conceptualized and how different conceptualizations matter for the science–policy interface. Alternative conceptualizations of numbers are used to challenge the model of science-speaking truth to power. Uncertainty, complexity, pluralism, malpractice, and values are mobilized to redefine the relations between science and policy. Alternative quantification may produce alternative facts, but reflexive approaches that use numbers to discuss the relevance of equity, positionality, and quality in science for policy may offer a remedy.
...More
Article
Cook, Brian R.;
Kesby, Mike;
Fazey, Ioan;
Spray, Chris;
(October 2013)
The persistence of ‘normal’ catchment management despite the participatory turn: Exploring the power effects of competing frames of reference
(/isis/citation/CBB350967664/)
Article
Allain J. Barnett;
Melanie G. Wiber;
(2019)
What Scientists Say about the Changing Risk Calculation in the Marine Environment under the Harper Government of Canada (2006-2015)
(/isis/citation/CBB359628559/)
Article
Leonie Dendler;
Gaby-Fleur Böl;
(July 2021)
Increasing Engagement in Regulatory Science: Reflections from the Field of Risk Assessment
(/isis/citation/CBB423909656/)
Article
Carmen McLeod;
Sarah Hartley;
(July 2018)
Responsibility and Laboratory Animal Research Governance
(/isis/citation/CBB564349730/)
Article
Kristoffer Whitney;
(2019)
It’s about Time: Adaptive Resource Management, Environmental Governance, and Science Studies
(/isis/citation/CBB335286233/)
Article
Lisa Sigl;
(May 2016)
On the Tacit Governance of Research by Uncertainty: How Early Stage Researchers Contribute to the Governance of Life Science Research
(/isis/citation/CBB119230475/)
Article
Hadrien Macq;
Céline Parotte;
Pierre Delvenne;
(2021)
Exploring Frictions of Participatory Innovation between Sites and Scales
(/isis/citation/CBB771835349/)
Article
Hiro Saito;
(January 2021)
The Developmental State and Public Participation: The Case of Energy Policy-making in Post–Fukushima Japan
(/isis/citation/CBB786983437/)
Article
Samuel Ducourant;
(2023)
Science or Ignorance of Animal Welfare? A Case Study: Scientific Reports Published in Preparation for the First European Directive on Animal Welfare (1979-1980)
(/isis/citation/CBB241761697/)
Article
Christopher Lawless;
(2020)
Assembling airspace: The Single European Sky and contested transnationalities of European air traffic management
(/isis/citation/CBB169587089/)
Article
Lauren Richter;
Alissa Cordner;
Phil Brown;
(October 2018)
Non-stick science: Sixty years of research and (in)action on fluorinated compounds
(/isis/citation/CBB792947339/)
Article
Ashlyn Jaeger;
(2019)
(Re)Producing Cyborgs: Biomedicalizing Abortion through the Congressional Debate over Fetal Pain
(/isis/citation/CBB770211028/)
Article
Abraham S. D. Tidwell;
Jessica M. Smith;
(September 2015)
Morals, Materials, and Technoscience: The Energy Security Imaginary in the United States
(/isis/citation/CBB992433257/)
Article
Luciana Landgraf Castelo Branco;
(2023)
Rethinking governance through Samarco’s dam collapse in Brazil: a critique from the STS perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB165051260/)
Article
Luis Reyes-Galindo;
(January 2017)
Molecular Detector (Non)Technology in Mexico
(/isis/citation/CBB757495306/)
Article
Sergio Urueña;
(2022)
Anticipation and modal power: Opening up and closing down the momentum of sociotechnical systems
(/isis/citation/CBB466032431/)
Article
Suarez, Andrés Fernando;
(2022)
Figures and responsibilities in contexts of mass violence: limits and risks of quantification in transitional justice in Colombia
(/isis/citation/CBB216106014/)
Article
DeLaplante, Kevin;
(1999)
Certainty and domain-independence in the sciences of complexity: A critique of James Franklin's account of formal science
(/isis/citation/CBB000110764/)
Article
Amy E. Slaton;
Alice L. Pawley;
(2018)
The Power and Politics of Engineering Education Research Design: Saving the ‘Small N’
(/isis/citation/CBB348947780/)
Article
Papadopoulos, Dimitris;
(April 2011)
Alter-ontologies: Towards a constituent politics in technoscience
(/isis/citation/CBB185760393/)
Be the first to comment!