Bland, Laura E. (Author)
Goulding, Robert (Advisor)
In this dissertation, I analyze a range of epistemological and religious arguments for and against the fear of comets, as articulated in pamphlets and polemics following the comets of 1680–82 in the Spanish and English Empires. These works appeared in England, Spain, North America, and the Viceroyalties of New Spain and Peru. Against recent scholarship, I argue that the religious and political diversity which drove the “vulgarization” of comets in England was less important in other regions than technical disputes over the foundations of astrology, or long-standing religious distinctions between licit and illicit interpretations of wonders. After an introduction, four thematic chapters explore responses to the comets of the 1680s in England, Spain, North America, and Spanish America respectively. In chapter two, I show how the politico-religious appropriation of the comet led to the association of comet-interpretation with vulgar segments of society. In subsequent chapters I show that the political prodigy-mongering found in England was, in the Spanish empire, controlled through censorship of the press and a Catholic tradition of strict separation between miracles and wonders. This shared intellectual tradition led the conversation of the comet to hinge on fairly technical aspects of natural philosophy and astrology, which constrained the possible meanings of the comet. Chapter Four shows that the same division between licit and illicit interpretation of comets operated in the Puritan context of New England. Chapter Five elaborates on the Catholic background established for Spain by showing how broad religious trends intersected with local circumstances of patronage and norms of argument in shaping the debate in Spanish America. Finally, the conclusion reflects on how the diversity of questions at stake in the last debate over the meaning of comets in the 1680s changes our understanding of the decline of prodigies, wonders, and superstition more generally.
...More
Article
Giuseppe Bruno-Chomin;
(2017)
“… Che i matti dicano spropositi”: A Discussion of Cometary Theory and Superstition in Seventeenth Century Italy
(/isis/citation/CBB929657759/)
Article
Avalos, A.;
(2006)
Astrology and Other Occult Sciences in Seventeenth-Century New Spain
(/isis/citation/CBB001023385/)
Article
Gábor Almási;
(2022)
Astrology in the crossfire: the stormy debate after the comet of 1577
(/isis/citation/CBB786602400/)
Article
Carter, Christopher;
(2012)
Meteors, Prodigies, and Signs: The Interpretation of the Unusual in Sixteenth-Century England
(/isis/citation/CBB001200755/)
Chapter
More, Anna;
(2009)
Cosmopolitanism and Scientific Reason in New Spain: Carlos de Sigüenza y Góngora and the Dispute over the 1680 Comet
(/isis/citation/CBB000951586/)
Article
Moreno Corral, Marco Arturo;
Berrón Mena, Tannia;
(2000)
Sigüenza y Góngora: un científico de transición
(/isis/citation/CBB000102467/)
Book
Ovidio Montalbani;
Linda Bisello;
(2017)
Del vento e delle comete: Speculazioni accademiche
(/isis/citation/CBB450320639/)
Article
Johnson, Christopher;
(2004)
“Periwigged Heralds”: Epistemology and Intertextuality in Early American Cometography
(/isis/citation/CBB000500189/)
Book
Doris Gruber;
(2020)
Frühneuzeitlicher Wissenswandel. Kometenerscheinungen in der Druckpublizistik des Heiligen Römischen Reiches
(/isis/citation/CBB272470489/)
Book
Anna Jerratsch;
(2019)
Der Fruhneuzeitliche Kometendiskurs Im Spiegel Deutschsprachiger Flugschriften
(/isis/citation/CBB833184165/)
Thesis
Nancy Marquez;
(2017)
Shifting the Frontiers of Early Modern Science: Astronomers, Botanists, and Engineers in Viceregal New Spain during the Habsburg Era, 1535-1700
(/isis/citation/CBB868569678/)
Book
Cervantes, Fernando;
Redden, Andrew;
(2013)
Angels, Demons, and the New World
(/isis/citation/CBB001202069/)
Article
Valle, Ivonne del;
(2013)
From José de Acosta to the Enlightenment: Barbarians, Climate Change, and (Colonial) Technology as the End of History
(/isis/citation/CBB001201895/)
Book
Hughes, Jonathan;
(2012)
The Rise of Alchemy in Fourteenth-Century England: Plantagenet Kings and the Search for the Philosopher's Stone
(/isis/citation/CBB001214743/)
Article
Forcada, Miquel;
(2004-2005)
Astronomy, Astrology and the Sciences of the Ancients in Early al-Andalus (2nd/8th--3rd/9th centuries)
(/isis/citation/CBB001024021/)
Article
Kerszberg, Pierre;
(2013)
Deduction Versus Discourse: Newton and the Cosmic Phenomena
(/isis/citation/CBB001320867/)
Article
Luís Campos Ribeiro;
(2020)
The Bounded Heavens: Defining the Limits of Astrological Practice in the Iberian Indices
(/isis/citation/CBB478312733/)
Article
Tayra M. C. Lanuza-Navarro;
(2017)
Astrology in Court: The Spanish Inquisition, Authority, and Expertise
(/isis/citation/CBB916769431/)
Article
Kassell, Lauren;
(2014)
Casebooks in Early Modern England: Medicine, Astrology, and Written Records
(/isis/citation/CBB001552355/)
Book
Thierry Belleguic;
(2013)
Ordre et désordre du monde: enquête sur les météores, de la Renaissance à l'âge moderne
(/isis/citation/CBB238470883/)
Be the first to comment!