Developmental Landmarks and the Warnock Report: A Sociological Account of Biological Translation (2019)
Franklin, Sarah Brooks (Author)
Comparative Studies in Society and History
Volume: 61
Issue: 4
Pages: 743-773
At a crucial meeting during their proceedings, on 9 November 1983, the sixteen members of Britain's influential Warnock Inquiry into Human Fertilisation and Embryology reached a key decision on how to base proposals for comprehensive legislation governing this largely uncharted territory. Famously, they chose the formation of the “primitive streak” in the early embryo as the basis for the fourteen-day rule that has now served as the global benchmark for experimental research in this area for nearly thirty years. Based on newly available archival material and interviews, this article offers a sociological account of the ways in which a specific translation of biological facts became the basis for an enduring social contract governing controversial bioinnovation in the UK. In particular, the combined roles of Committee Chair Mary Warnock and biologist Anne McLaren are examined in terms of how a decision, or “iterative settlement,” was reached as to “where to draw the line” using specific “developmental landmarks” to establish a basis for legal regulation. Drawing from this analysis, I offer a broader argument concerning the sociology of biological translation and biogovernance that is germane to ongoing debates such that over how to limit CRISPR-Cas 9 gene editing. I contend also that we have yet to fully grasp the historical and sociological lessons to be drawn from the early histories of establishing governance over new forms of technological assistance to human reproduction, and in particular the formation of the “Warnock Consensus.”
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Wilson, Duncan;
(2011)
Creating the “Ethics Industry”: Mary Warnock, in vitro Fertilization and the History of Bioethics in Britain
(/isis/citation/CBB001036118/)
Book
Erin Heidt-Forsythe;
(2018)
Between Families and Frankenstein: The Politics of Egg Donation in the United States
(/isis/citation/CBB151853995/)
Thesis
Levy, Jean Elizabeth;
(2007)
Controlling the Course of Scientific Advance: The Case of Human Embryology
(/isis/citation/CBB001560939/)
Article
Cowan, Ruth Schwartz;
(2009)
Moving up the Slippery Slope: Mandated Genetic Screening on Cyprus
(/isis/citation/CBB001024128/)
Book
Banchoff, Thomas F.;
(2011)
Embryo Politics: Ethics and Policy in Atlantic Democracies
(/isis/citation/CBB001212716/)
Thesis
Hurlbut, James Benjamin;
(2010)
Experiments in Democracy: The Science, Politics and Ethics of Human Embryo Research in the United States, 1978--2007
(/isis/citation/CBB001561039/)
Thesis
Mignin, Erin N.;
(2012)
Embryonic Policies: Reproductive Technology and Federal Regulation
(/isis/citation/CBB001567404/)
Book
Tim Lewens;
(2015)
The Biological Foundations of Bioethics
(/isis/citation/CBB452000216/)
Article
Maurizio Balistreri;
(2018)
La ricerca sugli embrioni umani alla luce dei nuovi scenari riproduttivi: considerazioni sull’individualità dell’embrione e sui limiti alla sperimentazione
(/isis/citation/CBB886964637/)
Book
Ploeg, Irma van der;
(2002)
Prosthetic Bodies: The Construction of the Fetus and the Couple as Patients in Reproductive Technologies
(/isis/citation/CBB000302033/)
Article
Svendsen, Mette N.;
Koch, Lene;
(2008)
Unpacking the “Spare Embryo”: Facilitating Stem Cell Research in a Moral Landscape
(/isis/citation/CBB000953483/)
Book
Crockin, Susan L.;
Jones, Howard Wilbur;
(2010)
Legal Conceptions: The Evolving Law and Policy of Assisted Reproductive Technologies
(/isis/citation/CBB001031398/)
Book
Murphy, Michelle;
(2012)
Seizing the Means of Reproduction: Entanglements of Feminism, Health, and Technoscience
(/isis/citation/CBB001214591/)
Book
Sandra Bärnreuther;
(2021)
Substantial Relations: Making Global Reproductive Medicine in Postcolonial India
(/isis/citation/CBB296718154/)
Book
Roberts, Elizabeth F. S.;
(2012)
God's Laboratory: Assisted Reproduction in the Andes
(/isis/citation/CBB001213115/)
Book
Franklin, Sarah;
(2013)
Biological Relatives: IVF, Stem Cells, and the Future of Kinship
(/isis/citation/CBB001422164/)
Article
Thomas Erslev;
(2018)
A brain worth keeping? Waste, value and time in contemporary brain banking
(/isis/citation/CBB481072702/)
Article
Weingart, Peter;
Salzmann, Christian;
Wörmann, Stefan;
(2008)
The Social Embedding of Biomedicine: An Analysis of German Media Debates 1995--2004
(/isis/citation/CBB000930612/)
Book
O'Neill, Onora;
(2002)
Autonomy and Trust in Bioethics
(/isis/citation/CBB000771273/)
Article
Hedgecoe, Adam M.;
(2006)
Context, Ethics and Pharmacogenetics
(/isis/citation/CBB000770742/)
Be the first to comment!