‘The Nuclear Siting Controversy’ in 1970s Italy: Historical Perspectives on Geology, Nuclear Power and Radioactive Waste (2024)
Candela, Andrea (Author)
Earth Sciences History: Journal of the History of the Earth Sciences Society
Volume: 42
Issue: 2
Pages: 433-459
For more than half a century, nuclear energy has been among the main issues of public concern, and thus of political, social as well as environmental debate. Nuclear energy has generated a long-standing controversy that began with the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki which comprise one of the most crucial turning points of contemporary history, from WWII up to the present. This paper aims to deal with a shorter period within this long and still controversial history. It focuses on the 1970s, when in Italy—as well as in the United States and Western Europe—the 1973 oil crisis made clear the need to diversify energy supply sources. As a result, national and international interest in nuclear power increased. The transition to a fully-fledged nuclear industry was to be achieved by the end of the century, with the launch of the first fast breeder reactors (FBRs). In Italy, the National Committee for Nuclear Energy (Comitato Nazionale per l’Energia Nucleare - CNEN), in agreement with the National Electricity Board (Ente Nazionale per l’Energia Elettrica - ENEL) and the newly established regional political bodies (Regional Councils), were entrusted with the task of drawing up the national map of sites suitable for nuclear facilities, and especially for nuclear power plants. The paper aims to provide an overview of the main geological issues that fueled the Italian ‘nuclear siting controversy’ during the 1970s. It focuses also on some still unpublished topics, such as those about the ENEL–CNEN Joint Study Commission for the Seismic Problems Associated with the Installation of Nuclear Plants and the drafting of a first national map of areas suitable for radioactive waste repositories. The matters under discussion here are significant because of the link with some key issues still open in contemporary debates on nuclear energy, such as planning and siting of nuclear facilities. It is also worth noting that some current global emergencies (e.g., the war in Ukraine and climate change) have brought the European, and more generally international, debate back to the urgency of energy diversification, including nuclear power in the energy generation mix. Historical analysis, although focused on particular case studies from the past, can help to better understand such a complex issue.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Vincent Ialenti;
(2020)
Deep time reckoning: How future thinking can help Earth now
(/isis/citation/CBB345154320/)
Article
Parker, Beth L.;
Alley, William M.;
Cherry, John A.;
(Spring 2014)
Geologic Disposal of Spent Nuclear Fuel: An Earth Science Perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB430079404/)
Article
Kristoffer Ekberg;
Martin Hultman;
(2023)
A Question of Utter Importance: The Early History of Climate Change and Energy Policy in Sweden, 1974-1983
(/isis/citation/CBB300763136/)
Article
Rosa Nan Leunbach;
Kristian H. Nielsen;
(2019)
Exploring the Dialogical Space of Hybrid Forums: The “Predictably Unpredictable” Case of Radioactive Waste Management in Denmark, 2003-2018
(/isis/citation/CBB878608684/)
Article
Marika Hietala;
(2021)
Safer-than: Making Nuclear Waste Disposal More Familiar
(/isis/citation/CBB181460049/)
Article
Jenkins-Smith, Hank C.;
Silva, Carol L.;
Herron, Kerry G.;
Trousset, Sarah R.;
Rechard, Rob P.;
(Summer 2012)
Enhancing the Acceptability and Credibility of a Repository for Spent Nuclear Fuel
(/isis/citation/CBB654033152/)
Article
Carnesale, Albert;
(Summer 2012)
Recommendations by the Blue Ribbon Commission on America’s Nuclear Future: A Plan for Managing Spent Nuclear Fuel and High-Level Nuclear Waste
(/isis/citation/CBB649666138/)
Article
Bickerstaff, K.;
Lorenzoni, I.;
Pidgeon, N. F.;
Poortinga, W.;
Simmons, P.;
(2008)
Reframing Nuclear Power in the UK Energy Debate: Nuclear Power, Climate Change Mitigation and Radioactive Waste
(/isis/citation/CBB000831216/)
Article
Chieko Kojima;
(2022)
Early History of the Nuclear Fuel Cycle in France: The Honeymoon Era of Radioactive Waste Reprocessing and Fast Breeder Reactors
(/isis/citation/CBB731735499/)
Article
Walker, J. Samuel;
(2006)
An “Atomic Garbage Dump” for Kansas
(/isis/citation/CBB001030770/)
Thesis
Celso, Jr. Baldivieso;
(2016)
Irradiating Eden: The El Verde Experiment and the Atomic Energy Commission's nuclear prospecting in Latin America, 1954-1970
(/isis/citation/CBB898540521/)
Thesis
Durant, Darrin;
(2008)
Burying Nuclear Waste, Exposing Nuclear Authority: Canada's Nuclear Waste Disposal Concept and Expert-Lay Discourse
(/isis/citation/CBB001561143/)
Article
Hamblin, Jacob Darwin;
Linda M. Richards;
(2015)
Beyond the Lucky Dragon: Japanese Scientists and Fallout Discourse in the 1950s
(/isis/citation/CBB661347126/)
Thesis
Jolly, J. Christopher;
(2004)
Thresholds of Uncertainty: Radiation and Responsibility in the Fallout Controversy
(/isis/citation/CBB001561963/)
Article
Mauro Elli;
(2022)
‘Nuclear power is not just economics’: Atomic energy and economic development in the Karachi Nuclear Power Plant Project (Kanupp), 1955–1965
(/isis/citation/CBB400689632/)
Article
Kelly, Dominic;
(2015)
Ideology, Society, and the Origins of Nuclear Power in Japan
(/isis/citation/CBB001551349/)
Article
Antoine Fontaine;
(2021)
Heating France with nuclear power: Alternative heat politics and competing nuclear regimes during the 1970s
(/isis/citation/CBB522732698/)
Thesis
Yang, Chi-Jen;
(2008)
Powered by Technology or Powering Technology?---Belief-Based Decision-Making in Nuclear Power and Synthetic Fuel
(/isis/citation/CBB001561419/)
Book
Dennis Pohl;
(2024)
Building Carbon Europe
(/isis/citation/CBB255708839/)
Book
Alain Bécoulet;
Dennis G. Whyte;
(2023)
Star Power: ITER and the International Quest for Fusion Energy
(/isis/citation/CBB045871589/)
Be the first to comment!