This paper examines the underdetermination between the Ptolemaic, Copernican, and the Tychonic theories of planetary motions and its attempted resolution by Kepler. I argue that past philosophical analyses of the problem of the planetary motions have not adequately grasped a method through which the underdetermination might have been resolved. This method involves a procedure of what I characterize as decomposition and identification. I show that this procedure is used by Kepler in the first half of the Astronomia Nova, where he ultimately claims to have refuted the Ptolemaic theory, thus partially overcoming the underdetermination. Finally, I compare this method with other views of scientific inference such as bootstrapping.
...MoreArticle Theodore Arabatzis; Don Howard (2015) Introduction: Integrated History and Philosophy of Science in Practice. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science (pp. 1-3).
Similar Citations
Chapter
Swerdlow, N. M.;
(2010)
Tycho, Longomontanus, and Kepler on Ptolemy's Solar Observations and Theory, Precession of the Equinoxes, and Obliquity of the Ecliptic
(/isis/citation/CBB001021801/)
Article
Goddu, André;
(2006)
Ptolemy, Copernicus, and Kepler on Linear Distances
(/isis/citation/CBB001032174/)
Essay Review
Andrea Gualandi;
(2009)
L'astronomo e il filologo, l'onore e le fonti: Keplero arbitro nella sfida tra Tycho e Ursus
(/isis/citation/CBB347277858/)
Book
Jardine, Nicholas;
Segonds, Alain Philippe;
(2008)
La guerre des astronomes: la querelle au sujet de l'origine du système géo-héliocentrique à la fin du XVIe siècle
(/isis/citation/CBB001021225/)
Article
Christián C. Carman;
Gonzalo L. Recio;
(2022)
Tycho Brahe’s Appendix ad Observationes anni 1593 and the date of Brahe’s theory of Mars, the prototype for Kepler’s vicarious hypothesis
(/isis/citation/CBB080413113/)
Article
Teru Miyake;
(2015)
Underdetermination and Decomposition in Kepler's Astronomia Nova
(/isis/citation/CBB462330933/)
Book
Mehl, Edouard;
Roudet, Nicolas;
(2011)
Kepler: la physique céleste: autour de l'Astronomia Nova, 1609
(/isis/citation/CBB001221139/)
Article
Carolino, Luís Miguel;
(2008)
The Making of a Tychonic Cosmology: Cristoforo Borri and the Development of Tycho Brahe's Astronomical System
(/isis/citation/CBB000930131/)
Chapter
Patrick J. Boner;
(2016)
Written in the Stars: Astronomy and Chronology at the Bavarian Court
(/isis/citation/CBB800473761/)
Article
Laurynas Adomaitis;
(2019)
Equivalence of hypotheses and Galilean censure in Leibniz: A conspiracy or a way to moderate censure?
(/isis/citation/CBB683885385/)
Book
Westman, Robert S.;
(2011)
The Copernican Question: Prognostication, Skepticism, and Celestial Order
(/isis/citation/CBB001251245/)
Book
Finocchiaro, Maurice A;
(2010)
Defending Copernicus and Galileo: Critical Reasoning in the Two Affairs
(/isis/citation/CBB001023120/)
Article
Christián C. Carman;
(2021)
The Tychonic Method for Calculating the Ratio between the Eccentricities of Mars
(/isis/citation/CBB973202474/)
Chapter
Patricia Radelet-de-Grave;
(2015)
La chute des corps, le mouvement des corps célestes et l'unification des mondes
(/isis/citation/CBB951522195/)
Chapter
Barker, Peter;
(2008)
Kepler and Melanchthon on the Biblical Arguments against Copernicanism
(/isis/citation/CBB001031836/)
Chapter
Jardine, Nick;
(2009)
Kepler, God, and the Virtues of Copernican Hypotheses
(/isis/citation/CBB000953697/)
Article
Michel-Pierre Lerner;
(2017)
De Copernic à Galilée: brève histoire d'une condamnation
(/isis/citation/CBB116196191/)
Article
Tredwell, Katherine A.;
Barker, Peter;
(2004)
Copernicus' First Friends: Physical Copernicanism from 1543 to 1610
(/isis/citation/CBB000500061/)
Chapter
Stefano Gattei;
(2015)
The Phoenix and the Architect: The Frontispiece of Kepler's "Tabulae Rudolphinae"
(/isis/citation/CBB809637959/)
Article
Gingerich, Owen;
Voelkel, James R.;
(2005)
Tycho and Kepler: Solid Myth versus Subtle Truth
(/isis/citation/CBB000650658/)
Be the first to comment!