IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB945769590

But Is It a Basin? Science, Controversy, and Conspiracy in the Fight for Mirador, Guatemala (2015)

Rahder, Micha (Author)

Science as Culture
Volume: 24
Issue: 3
Pages: 299-324

DOI: 10.1080/09505431.2015.1007034

URI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09505431.2015.1007034

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Landscape; landscapes Conspiracy theories Conservation biology Conservation and restoration Geology Science and politics Mayan civilization Controversies and disputes 21st century Guatemala

The ancient Maya city of Mirador, located in the northeastern corner of Guatemala's Maya Biosphere Reserve, is at the heart of a raging scientific and political controversy. On the surface, the conflict centers around the geological definition of a ‘basin’ surrounding the magnificent site. One side uses the existence of a basin—backed up by satellite images and analyses—to push for redrawing the boundaries of the reserve, arguing that the feature naturally delineates key archaeological and ecological sites and that current reserve management is failing the forests. The other side insists that there is no geological basin—a contention also backed by satellite images and analyses—and that redrawing the lines would undermine more than 20 years of conservation efforts. On both sides of the fight, rumors abound about secret agendas, manipulated data, backroom political deals, and other shady business. These conspiracy stories reveal how paranoid thought is simultaneously a powerful epistemology and a practical political strategy, both of which shape the production and interpretation of scientific facts. Rather than contrasting irrational political rumor with logical scientific fact, or considering the former as simply context for the latter, the case of Mirador demonstrates how the two are deeply entangled ways of acting on and making sense of a complex landscape.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB945769590/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Hindmarsh, Richard; (2014)
Hot Air Ablowin! “Media-Speak”, Social Conflict, and the Australian “Decoupled” Wind Farm Controversy (/isis/citation/CBB001421171/)

Article Petter Wulff; (2020)
The Climate Legacy of Svante Arrhenius (/isis/citation/CBB059026094/)

Book Marco Armiero; Roberta Biasillo; Wilko Graf von Hardenberg; (2022)
Mussolini's Nature: An Environmental History of Italian Fascism (/isis/citation/CBB022333357/)

Article Margaret H. Friedel; Stephen R. Morton; Gary N. Bastin; Jocelyn Davies; D. Mark Stafford Smith; (2022)
A history of CSIRO’s Central Australian Laboratory 2, 1980–2018: Interdisciplinary land research (/isis/citation/CBB854591588/)

Article Whitney, Kristoffer; (2014)
Domesticating Nature? Surveillance and Conservation of Migratory Shorebirds in the “Atlantic Flyway” (/isis/citation/CBB001420087/)

Thesis Whitney, Kristoffer Jon; (2012)
A Knot in Common: Science, Values, and Conservation in the Atlantic Flyway (/isis/citation/CBB001560601/)

Article Saturno, William A.; Stuart, David; Aveni, Anthony F.; Rossi, Franco; (2012)
Ancient Maya Astronomical Tables from Xultun, Guatemala (/isis/citation/CBB001320477/)

Article Few, Martha; (2010)
Circulating Smallpox Knowledge: Guatemalan Doctors, Maya Indians and Designing Spain's Smallpox Vaccination Expedition, 1780--1803 (/isis/citation/CBB001023052/)

Article S. Iwaniszewski; (2016)
Another Look At The Lunar Series At Dos Pilas, Guatemala (/isis/citation/CBB698572984/)

Article Stanisław Iwaniszewski; (2018)
The Observations of the Moon at Naranjo – New Facts and Interpretations (/isis/citation/CBB671523487/)

Article Zralka, Jarosolaw; Koszkul, Wieslaw; (2015)
Archaeological evidence for ancient Maya water management: The case of Nakum, Petén, Guatemala (/isis/citation/CBB001422591/)

Thesis Aldana, Gerardo Villalobos; (2001)
Oracular science: Uncertainty in the history of Maya astronomy, 500--1600 (/isis/citation/CBB001560795/)

Book Alfonso De Nardo; (2018)
Uomini e boschi: il bosco e le aree interne nella questione meriodionale (/isis/citation/CBB327786623/)

Book Miller, Char; (2013)
On the Edge: Water, Immigration, and Politics in the Southwest (/isis/citation/CBB001422402/)

Article Joseph T. Hannibal; (2022)
The Newberry-Whittlesey controversy and its protagonists: background, arguments, and outcome of a bitter feud (/isis/citation/CBB844814529/)

Book David G. Havlick; (2018)
Bombs Away: Militarization, Conservation, and Ecological Restoration (/isis/citation/CBB090039689/)

Article Nordlund, Christer; (2001)
“On Going Up in the World”: Nation, Region and the Land Elevation Debate in Sweden (/isis/citation/CBB000100468/)

Book Nattrass, Nicoli; (2012)
The AIDS Conspiracy: Science Fights Back (/isis/citation/CBB001252724/)

Article Varughese, Shiju Sam; (2011)
Media and Science in Disaster Contexts: Deliberations on Earthquakes in the Regional Press in Kerala, India (/isis/citation/CBB001220695/)

Article Taylor, Michael; (2014)
British Conservatism, the Illuminati, and the Conspiracy Theory of the French Revolution, 1797--1802 (/isis/citation/CBB001201792/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}