In this paper, I will present the empirical version of the slippery slope argument (SSA) in the field of genome editing. According to the SSA, if we adopt germline manipulation of embryos we will eventu-ally end up performing or allowing something morally reprehensible, such as a new coercive eugenics. I will investigate the actual possibility of sliding towards eugenics: thus, I will examine enhancement and eugenics both in the classical and liberal versions, through the lens of SSA. In the first part, I will discuss the classical eugenics from a historical perspective and conclude that classical eugenics is morally deplorable; but by currently accepting genome editing I argue that it is not possible to ‘slip’ into classical eugenics. Then, I will analyze liberal eugenics: I will consider Habermas’ and Sandel’s objections to liberal eugenics and genetic human enhancement. Subsequently, I will reply to these arguments affirming that, although it is not possible to refuse any form of genetic enhancement, liberal eugenics would not consider the principles of justice, non-maleficence, and non-instrumentalization; hence, it should be considered not morally acceptable. In addition, I will support the thesis according to which the possibility of relapsing into liberal eugenics is more likely than relapsing into classical eugenics. Then, I will present a strategy that, while avoiding falling into the undesirable scenarios related to SSA, still accepts some application of germline genome editing of embryos and gametes. In such a way, I will show that even if we accept the plausibility of a certain slip into an undesirable scenario, SSA does not offer conclusive reasons to forbid any use of germline genome editing technique in both therapeutic and enhancement fields.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Sebastiano Serafini;
(2019)
La bioetica in Italia: da una storia di battaglie etico-politiche a spiragli di dialogo tra pensiero cattolico e pensiero laico
(/isis/citation/CBB039016702/)
Article
Jamie Milton Freestone;
(2021)
Contemporary Darwinism as a worldview
(/isis/citation/CBB278005969/)
Book
Currell, Susan;
Cogdell, Christina;
(2006)
Popular Eugenics: National Efficiency and American Mass Culture in the 1930s
(/isis/citation/CBB000774027/)
Thesis
Reardon, Jennifer Elaine;
(2002)
Race to the finish: Identity and governance in an age of genetics
(/isis/citation/CBB001560779/)
Book
Amir Teicher;
(2019)
Social Mendelism: Genetics and the Politics of Race in Germany, 1900-1948
(/isis/citation/CBB585433440/)
Article
Clayton, Jay;
(2013)
The Ridicule of Time: Science Fiction, Bioethics, and the Posthuman
(/isis/citation/CBB001200682/)
Article
Michel Morange;
(2017)
Human Germline Editing: A Historical Perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB176490993/)
Book
Green, Ronald M.;
(2007)
Babies by Design: The Ethics of Genetic Choice
(/isis/citation/CBB000953022/)
Book
Sandel, Michael J.;
(2007)
The Case against Perfection: Ethics in the Age of Genetic Engineering
(/isis/citation/CBB000953024/)
Article
Hilvoorde, Ivo van;
Vos, Rein;
Wert, Guido de;
(2007)
Flopping, Klapping and Gene Doping: Dichotomies Between “Natural” and “Artificial ” in Elite Sport
(/isis/citation/CBB000780225/)
Book
Evans, John H.;
(2001)
Playing God? Human Genetic Engineering and the Rationalization of Public Bioethical Debate, 1959-1995
(/isis/citation/CBB000101226/)
Book
Jonathan Anomaly;
(2020)
Creating Future People: The Ethics of Genetic Enhancement
(/isis/citation/CBB786713588/)
Article
Maurizio Esposito;
(2017)
Expectation and futurity: The remarkable success of genetic determinism
(/isis/citation/CBB104627956/)
Article
Andrew J. Hogan;
(2016)
From Precaution to Peril: Public Relations Across Forty Years of Genetic Engineering
(/isis/citation/CBB750225154/)
Article
Hayden, Cori;
(2007)
Taking as Giving: Bioscience, Exchange, and the Politics of Benefit-Sharing
(/isis/citation/CBB000773319/)
Book
Jenny Reardon;
(2017)
The Postgenomic Condition: Ethics, Justice, and Knowledge after the Genome
(/isis/citation/CBB800995116/)
Article
McMillan, John;
(2007)
The Return of the Inseminator: Eutelegenesis in Past and Contemporary Reproductive Ethics
(/isis/citation/CBB000701051/)
Book
Glannon, Walter;
(2001)
Genes and Future People: Philosophical Issues in Human Genetics
(/isis/citation/CBB000101746/)
Article
Jennifer A. Liu;
(2016)
Emerging Science, Emerging Democracy: Stem Cell Research and Policy in Taiwan
(/isis/citation/CBB157938536/)
Book
Giovanni Fornero;
Maurizio Mori;
(2012)
Laici e cattolici in bioetica: storia e teoria di un confronto
(/isis/citation/CBB846992376/)
Social Studies of Science
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science
Perspectives on Science
History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Endeavour: Review of the Progress of Science
Be the first to comment!