Charles Darwin Did Not Mislead Joseph Hooker in Their 1881 Correspondence About Leopold Von Buch and Karl Ernst Von Baer (2020)
Dagg, Joachim (Author)
Derry, J. F. (Author)
Annals of Science: The History of Science and Technology
Volume: 77
Issue: 3
Pages: 349-365
While Joseph Hooker was considering his upcoming presentation on the geographical distribution of species, he asked Charles Darwin for help with some references. During the ensuing exchange of correspondence, Darwin seems to have contradicted himself, regarding his being aware of Leopold von Buch’s observation that distributed varieties become species, prior to writing On the Origin of Species. Literalists and conspiracists have interpreted this apparent self-contradiction as a sign of duplicity and fraud. However, when the correspondence and Hooker’s address are analysed in context, there is a more compelling explanation. Simply that, in response to direct questioning by Hooker, Darwin conflated the two names of Von Baer and Von Buch, and made an honest mistake.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Wyhe, John van;
(2014)
A Delicate Adjustment: Wallace and Bates on the Amazon and “The Problem of the Origin of Species”
Article
Stamos, David N.;
(2002)
Species, Languages, and the Horizontal/Vertical Distinction
Article
Mannouris, Costas;
(2011)
Darwin's “Beloved Barnacles”: Tough Lessons in Variation
Book
Stamos, David N.;
(2007)
Darwin and the Nature of Species
Article
Mallet, James;
(2010)
Why Was Darwin's View of Species Rejected by Twentieth Century Biologists?
Article
Gohau, Gabriel;
(2010)
Darwin the Geologist: Between Lyell and von Buch
Book
Charles Darwin;
Frederick Burkhardt;
James Secord;
The Editors of the Darwin Correspondence Project;
(2015)
The Correspondence of Charles Darwin: Volume 22, 1874
Book
Janet Browne;
(2017)
The Quotable Darwin
Book
Norbert Peeters;
Tessa van Dijk;
(2018)
Darwins engelen. Vrouwelijke geleerden in de tijd van Charles Darwin.
Book
Schwartz, Joel;
(2010)
Darwin's Disciple: George John Romanes, A Life in Letters
Book
Croft, L. R.;
(2012)
Darwin and Lady Hope: The Untold Story
Article
Patrick M. Walsh;
(2021)
Making a French Connection: Darwin, Brown-Séquard and the Epilepsy Studies
Article
Jim Endersby;
(2001)
"From having no Herbarium." Local Knowledge versus Metropolitan Expertise: Joseph Hooker's Australasian Correspondence with William Colenso and Ronald Gunn
Book
James Hector;
Rowan Burns;
Simon Nathan;
Geoscience Society of New Zealand;
(2012)
My Dear Hooker: Transcriptions of Letters from James Hector to Joseph Dalton Hooker Between 1860 and 1898
Book
Sascha Nolden;
Simon Nathan;
Esme Mildenhall;
(2013)
The Correspondence of Julius Haast and Joseph Dalton Hooker, 1861-1886
Book
Michael D. Barton;
Joseph D. Martin;
Gregory Radick;
Roy MacLeod;
(2024)
The Correspondence of John Tyndall, Volume 13: The Correspondence, June 1872–September 1873
Article
Derek Partridge;
(2021)
Mind the step: Did Hooker's judgement clinch Darwin's disenchantment?
Chapter
Camerini, Jane;
(1997)
Remains of the day: Early Victorians in the field
Article
Endersby, Jim;
(2009)
Sympathetic Science: Charles Darwin, Joseph Hooker, and the Passions of Victorian Naturalists
Article
Porter, Duncan M.;
(1993)
On the road to the Origin with Darwin, Hooker, and Gray
Be the first to comment!