This essay investigates censorial responses to Jean Bodin's Methodus (1566) in Counter-Reformation Italy, using evidence from Italian libraries and archives to shed new light on the process that led to the inclusion of the work in the Roman Expurgatory Index of 1607. By examining the diverse, and sometimes conflicting, opinions that Catholic censors expressed on Bodin's text and the ‘errors’ it contained, the essay shows that even a relatively cohesive ‘reading community’ such as that of Counter-Reformation censors could nurture fundamental disagreement in evaluating the content and dangerousness of a book, as well as in devising appropriate countermeasures. Censors often made sense of the same texts in utterly different ways, based not only on their own intellectual interests and backgrounds, but also on the different interpretive strategies that they adopted. In light of this fact, the article suggests that early modern censorship should be seen less as a purely repressive practice than as a peculiar type of readership, characterised (as are all forms of readership) by instability, controversy and active ‘meaning-making’.
...More
Book
Michelson, Emily;
(2013)
The Pulpit and the Press in Reformation Italy
(/isis/citation/CBB001550011/)
Article
Tarrant, Neil;
(2014)
Censoring Science in Sixteenth-Century Italy: Recent (and Not-So-Recent) Research
(/isis/citation/CBB001420237/)
Article
Hannah Marcus;
(2018)
The Mind of the Censor: Girolamo Rossi, a Physician and Censor for the Congregation of the Index
(/isis/citation/CBB714530916/)
Article
Laura Simoni Varanini;
(2003)
La "Dissertatio cum Nuncio Sidereo" fra Galileo e Bruno
(/isis/citation/CBB554864820/)
Chapter
Franco Motta;
(2018)
Nature, Faith and the Judge of Faith. Some Considerations on the Historical-Political Context of Copernicus’ Condemnation
(/isis/citation/CBB955853430/)
Book
Natacha Fabbri;
Federica Favino;
(2018)
Copernicus Banned: The Entangled Matter of the anti-Copernican Decree of 1616
(/isis/citation/CBB869881150/)
Book
Gennaro Cassiani;
(2022)
Tommaso Bozio. I saperi scientifici e i libri “lincei” (1548-1610)
(/isis/citation/CBB199056166/)
Book
Dániel Margócsy;
Somos, Márk;
Joffe, Stephen N.;
(2018)
The Fabrica of Andreas Vesalius: A Worldwide Descriptive Census, Ownership, and Annotations of the 1543 and 1555 Editions
(/isis/citation/CBB947458283/)
Article
Jonathan R. Olson;
(2016)
‘Newly Amended and Much Enlarged’: Claims of Novelty and Enlargement on the Title Pages of Reprints in the Early Modern English Book Trade
(/isis/citation/CBB897105974/)
Book
Kavey, Allison;
(2007)
Books of Secrets: Natural Philosophy in England, 1550--1600
(/isis/citation/CBB000774266/)
Book
Krämer, Fabian;
(2014)
Ein Zentaur in London: Lektüre und Beobachtung in der frühneuzeitlichen Naturforschung
(/isis/citation/CBB001510178/)
Article
Francisco Malta Romeiras;
(2020)
Putting the Indices into Practice: Censoring Science in Early Modern Portugal
(/isis/citation/CBB223674544/)
Article
Beretta, Francesco;
Lerner, Michel-Pierre;
(2006)
Un édit inédit: autour du placard de mise à l'index de Copernic par le maître du Sacré palais Giacinto Petroni
(/isis/citation/CBB000931271/)
Article
Prete, Ivano Dal;
(2014)
“Being the World Eternal …”: The Age of the Earth in Renaissance Italy
(/isis/citation/CBB001450158/)
Chapter
Dario Generali;
(2016)
Il fondo librario Bartolomeo Corte della Biblioteca Braidense di Milano
(/isis/citation/CBB815421660/)
Article
Luís Campos Ribeiro;
(2020)
The Bounded Heavens: Defining the Limits of Astrological Practice in the Iberian Indices
(/isis/citation/CBB478312733/)
Article
Manuela Bragagnolo;
(2016)
Fisiognomica, astrologia e medicina al tempo di Della Porta : la "Fisionomia naturale" di Giovanni Ingegneri (1606)
(/isis/citation/CBB909015458/)
Chapter
Henninger-Voss, Mary;
(2007)
Comets and Cannonballs: Reading Technology in a Sixteenth-Century Library
(/isis/citation/CBB000774653/)
Book
Hannah Marcus;
(2020)
Forbidden Knowledge: Medicine, Science, and Censorship in Early Modern Italy
(/isis/citation/CBB635940733/)
Article
Leen Spruit;
(2016)
Roman Censorship of Science and Natural Philosophy: 16th–17th Centuries
(/isis/citation/CBB513454885/)
Be the first to comment!