“Insanity Is the Price of Modern Civilization”: The Discourse of Civilization and the Asian Insane in Modern America (2021)
Examining debates on the link between civilization and insanity in the late nineteenth and early twentieth-century United States, this essay engages the discourse of civilization to discuss the ways in which insanity among Asian immigrants, in particular Chinese and Japanese, was understood, defined and debated. During the period, insanity was regarded as a disease of civilization, which had been increasing due to the struggles of modern life. While Americans witnessed insanity among the “colored” and Asians, they argued that these groups had lower rates of insanity than white Americans and European immigrants because they belonged to lower positions on the civilization scale. Though not explicitly racialist or even racist, the discourse of civilization ordered the international world and drew a clear color line between white westerners and non-white others. At the same time, American missionaries and medical professionals stationed in China and Japan, who were there to see and learn about insanity in Asia, reaffirmed the existing medical understandings of insanity and offered a knowledge base for American psychiatrists who would encounter the Asian insane at their mental institutions. The alleged rarity of mental troubles for Chinese and Japanese was not considered an asset; the insanity debates confirmed the non-white, non-American status of Asian immigrants, rendering them forever foreign. Moreover, their very distance from western civilization explained why Asians in America seemed to have suffered less from mental disturbances and how they could resist the debilitating effects of civilization and migration.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Todd J. Braje;
(2016)
Shellfish for the Celestial Empire: The Rise and Fall of Commercial Abalone Fishing in California
(/isis/citation/CBB067006555/)
Book
Shah, Nayan;
(2001)
Contagious Divides: Epidemics and Race in San Francisco's Chinatown
(/isis/citation/CBB000101127/)
Book
Chiang, Howard Hsueh-Hao;
(2014)
Psychiatry and Chinese History
(/isis/citation/CBB001422492/)
Article
Segrest, Mab;
(2014)
Exalted on the Ward: “Mary Roberts,” the Georgia State Sanitarium, and the Psychiatric “Speciality” of Race
(/isis/citation/CBB001201824/)
Article
Gambino, Matthew;
(2008)
“These strangers within our gates”: Race, Psychiatry and Mental Illness among Black Americans at St Elizabeths Hospital in Washington, D.C., 1900--40
(/isis/citation/CBB000950375/)
Article
Jo, J.;
(2015)
A Study on the Awareness of Chinese Medicine by Medical Missionaries: Focused on The China Medical Missionary Journal (1887--1932)
(/isis/citation/CBB001422436/)
Article
Summers, Martin;
(2010)
“Suitable Care of the African When Afflicted With Insanity”: Race, Madness, and Social Order in Comparative Perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB001020993/)
Book
Wendy Gonaver;
(2019)
The Peculiar Institution and the Making of Modern Psychiatry, 1840–1880
(/isis/citation/CBB313122849/)
Book
Jeannie N. Shinozuka;
(2022)
Biotic Borders: Transpacific Plant and Insect Migration and the Rise of Anti-Asian Racism in America, 1890–1950
(/isis/citation/CBB310184057/)
Article
Comelles, Josep M.;
(2010)
Forgotten Paths: Culture and Ethnicity in Catalan Mental Health Policies (1900--39)
(/isis/citation/CBB001232231/)
Book
Catharine Coleborne;
(2015)
Insanity, identity and empire: Immigrants and institutional confinement in Australia and New Zealand, 1873–1910
(/isis/citation/CBB231366413/)
Book
Glover, Denise M.;
Harrell, Stevan;
McKhann, Charles F.;
Swain, Margaret Byrne;
(2011)
Explorers and Scientists in China's Borderlands, 1880--1950
(/isis/citation/CBB001214669/)
Article
Heather Murray;
(2022)
Diagnosing the “master mechanism of the universe” in interwar and war-era America
(/isis/citation/CBB559207371/)
Article
Sato, Masahiro;
(2012)
Popularization of Psychiaric Knowledge in Modern Japan at the Turn of the Twentieth Century: Focusing on the Newspaper Coverage of Mental Disorders
(/isis/citation/CBB001214341/)
Article
Yumi Kim;
(2018)
Seeing Cages: Home Confinement in Early Twentieth-Century Japan
(/isis/citation/CBB051332006/)
Article
Akira Hashimoto;
(2019)
‘The present state and statistical observation of mental patients under home custody’, by Kure Shūzō and Kashida Gorō (1918)
(/isis/citation/CBB619204009/)
Article
Matsumura, Janice;
(2004)
State Propaganda and Mental Disorders: The Issue of Psychiatric Casualties among Japanese Soldiers during the Asia-Pacific War
(/isis/citation/CBB000630236/)
Article
Barry, Lorelle;
Coleborne, Catharine;
(2011)
Insanity and Ethnicity in New Zealand: Maori Encounters with the Auckland Mental Hospital, 1860--1900
(/isis/citation/CBB001232208/)
Article
Élodie Grossi;
(2021)
Truth in numbers? Emancipation, race, and federal census statistics in the debates over Black mental health in the United States, 1840–1900
(/isis/citation/CBB819341195/)
Article
Marianna Scarfone;
(2021)
‘Psychosis of civilization’: a colonial-situated diagnosis
(/isis/citation/CBB368791802/)
Be the first to comment!