IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB920159518

Hydrogeological Knowledge from Below: Water Expertise as a Republican Common in Early-Modern Venice (2022)

Berichte zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte
Volume: 45
Issue: 4
Pages: 538-560

DOI: 10.1002/bewi.202200006

Publication Date: 2022
Edition Details: Special issue: Case Studies in Knowledge from Below: From Historical to Political Epistemology
Language: English

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Expertise Hydrology 17th century Early modern Venice (Italy) Castelli, Benedetto

This essay looks at early-modern Venice hydroculture as a case of episteme from below. The forms of water knowledge it developed were multilayered and collective in their essence and solidly rested on a social experiential basis that was rooted in labour (especially fishing) and practices (especially water surveying and engineering). In accordance with the city's republican esprit (and correspondent political values), its episteme emerged as the encounter and negotiation between various institutions and groups: the fishermen of San Niccolò in Venice, the practitioners of the water magistrature and political authorities. This essay explores the institutional settings of this water culture, seen as an instance of bottom-up epistemic construction. It especially addresses three historical instances: firstly, a seventeenth century program to map public waters in order to block their alienation for private fish farming; secondly, water officers’ interviews with fishermen aimed to assess the state of the lagoon hydromorphology and, thirdly, fishing regulations. Venice communitarian and circular forms of knowledge production are here contrasted to an opposite paradigm, which was embodied by the Galileian mathematician and Rome courtier, Benedetto Castelli. His interactions with the Republic of Venice on water management and his approach to hydraulic problems are revealing of an elitist and abstract understanding of scientific knowledge that guided political decisions from above without taking in any consideration the opinions of the ‘vulgar’. While his science was the expression of a top-down political epistemology, Venetian water knowledge was more egalitarian. It left room for exchange, inclusiveness and bottom-up codification; it valued the gathering of different experiences (including the fishermen's practical knowledge of their waters) and rested on a concrete and systemic (organicist) understanding of natural-anthropic processes.

...More

Associated with

Article Wolfe, Charles T.; Gerardo Ienna (2022) Knowledge from Below: Case Studies in Historical and Political Epistemology. Berichte zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte. unapi

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB920159518/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Pietro Daniel Omodeo; Sebastiano Trevisani; Senthil Babu; (2020)
Benedetto Castelli’s Considerations on the Lagoon of Venice: Mathematical expertise and hydro-geomorphological transformations in seventeenth-century Venice (/isis/citation/CBB552404456/)

Article Etienne S. Benson; (2020)
Random river: Luna Leopold and the promise of chance in fluvial geomorphology (/isis/citation/CBB749260436/)

Book Sabrina Minuzzi; (2016)
Sul filo dei segreti. Farmacopea, libri e pratiche terapeutiche a Venezia in età moderna (/isis/citation/CBB217748554/)

Book Georg Christ; (2020)
Cultures of Empire: Rethinking Venetian Rule, 1400–1700: Essays in honour of Benjamin Arbel (/isis/citation/CBB217881514/)

Book Crawshaw, Jane L. Stevens; (2012)
Plague Hospitals: Public Health for the City in Early Modern Venice (/isis/citation/CBB001200915/)

Article Bartolini, Donatella; (2015)
On the Borders: Surgeons and their Activities in the Venetian State (1540--1640) (/isis/citation/CBB001422194/)

Thesis Sean David Parrish; (2015)
Marketing Nature: Apothecaries, Medicinal Retailing, and Scientific Culture in Early Modern Venice, 1565-1730 (/isis/citation/CBB816033989/)

Thesis Visconti, John Gordon; (2009)
The Secrets of Health; Views on Healing from the Everyday Level to the Printing Presses in Early Modern Venice 1500--1650 (/isis/citation/CBB001562848/)

Article Luca Piccinali; (2019)
La famiglia di Benedetto Castelli: note dalle polizze d'estimo bresciane (1517-1627) (/isis/citation/CBB847321279/)

Article Mercedes Gómez-Ferrer; Yolanda Gil; (2017)
Vincenzo Vincenzi, “Geometer and Engineer to Cardinal Borja” (/isis/citation/CBB773949191/)

Article Ariotti, Piero E.; (1981)
Benedetto Castelli's Discourse on the loadstone (1639-1640): The origin of the notion of elementary magnets similarly aligned (/isis/citation/CBB000009762/)

Article Pier Davide Accendere; (2019)
A proposito di una recente scoperta documentale galileiana (/isis/citation/CBB326719660/)

Book Emilio Filieri; (2021)
Calamo e nuova scienza fra Galileo e Parini (/isis/citation/CBB771803111/)

Chapter Bucciantini, Massimo; (1992)
Atomi geometria e teologia nella filosofia galileiana di Benedetto Castelli (/isis/citation/CBB000048722/)

Article Maffioli, Cesare S.; (2008)
“Acqua premuta”: Benedetto Castelli and the Incompressibility of Water (/isis/citation/CBB000933160/)

Article Franco Giudice; (2020)
Tobie Matthew, Francis Bacon, and Galileo's Letter to Benedetto Castelli (/isis/citation/CBB844150617/)

Article Bucciantini, Massimo; (1983)
Il trattato Della misura dell'acque correnti di Benedetto Castelli: Una discussione “sulle acque” all'interno della scuola Galileiana (/isis/citation/CBB000028460/)

Article Bucciantini, Massimo; (1985)
Gli scritti di Benedetto Castelli sui numeri negativi, 1631-1635 (/isis/citation/CBB000040112/)

Article Longo, Oddone; Campogalliani, Paolo; (1994)
Mattoni al sole: Benedetto Castelli, la luce e il calore (/isis/citation/CBB000050674/)

Article Siebert, Harald; (2005)
The Early Search for Stellar Parallax: Galileo, Castelli, and Ramponi (/isis/citation/CBB000773466/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}