The Biological Turn on Personal Identity: The Role of Science as a Response to Children’s Appropriation in Argentinian Dictatorship (1976–1983) (2021)
The philosophical problem of personal identity has been widely discussed in contemporary analytic philosophy. The disputes over identity throughout time abound in references to thought experiments, excluding any connection to practical problems or to scientific knowledge and biotechnological practices. Nevertheless, some real cases challenge the pure metaphysical formulation of the problem and also show how science has an indubitable impact on the issue of identity. I will discuss the case of approximately 500 children who were appropriated during the most recent Argentinian dictatorship (1976–1983), as well as their restitution thanks to Abuelas de Plaza de Mayo’s fight and certain genetics outcomes. I will examine an alleged notion of genetic identity thought to have stemmed from the restitution phenomenon; and I will argue against some criticisms to that notion departing from contemporary philosophy of biology and philosophy of science. Particularly, I will discuss if a genetic stance of personal individual identity can be considered as supported by contemporary biological knowledge; and if a pluralistic perspective on scientific practice that appraises the role of values allows us to maintain the reference to DNA regarding identity but overcoming aforementioned criticisms.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Martins, Lilian A.-C. Pereira;
Regner, Anna Carolina K. P.;
Lorenzano, Pablo;
(2006)
Ciências da Vida: Estudos Filosóficos e Históricos
(/isis/citation/CBB000820180/)
Thesis
Bass, Jeffrey D.;
(2000)
In exile from the self: Identity, politics, and psychoanalysis in Buenos Aires
(/isis/citation/CBB001562662/)
Article
Ashley Kerr;
(2017)
From Savagery to Sovereignty: Identity, Politics, and International Expositions of Argentine Anthropology (1878–1892)
(/isis/citation/CBB576404806/)
Chapter
Aronson, Jay D.;
(2012)
Humanitarian DNA Identification in Post-Apartheid South Africa
(/isis/citation/CBB001251797/)
Book
Noah Tamarkin;
(2020)
Genetic Afterlives: Black Jewish Indigeneity in South Africa
(/isis/citation/CBB546086463/)
Thesis
Martin, Aryn;
(2006)
“I contain multitudes”: Chimeras, Cells and the Materialization of Identities
(/isis/citation/CBB001560879/)
Chapter
Braun, Lundy;
Hammonds, Evelynn;
(2012)
The Dilemma of Classification: The Past in the Present
(/isis/citation/CBB001251785/)
Book
Wailoo, Keith;
Nelson, Alondra;
Lee, Catherine Y.;
(2012)
Genetics and the Unsettled Past: The Collision of DNA, Race, and History
(/isis/citation/CBB001251696/)
Article
Pena, Sérgio D. J.;
(2005)
Razões para banir o conceito de raça da medicina brasileira
(/isis/citation/CBB000640195/)
Article
Kreimer, Pablo;
Lugones, Manuel;
(2003)
Pioneers and Victims: The Birth and Death of Argentina's First Molecular Biology Laboratory
(/isis/citation/CBB000300985/)
Article
Kamiel Mobach;
Ulrike Felt;
(2022)
On the Entanglement of Science and Europe at CERN: The Temporal Dynamics of a Coproductive Relationship
(/isis/citation/CBB148934545/)
Book
Diego Aguiar;
Quiroga, Juan Martín,;
Manuel Lugones;
Francisco Aristimuño;
(2018)
Políticas de ciencia, tecnología e innovación en la Argentina de la posdictadura
(/isis/citation/CBB706094630/)
Article
Bekerman, Fabiana;
(2012)
The Scientific Field during Argentina's Latest Military Dictatorship (1976--1983): Contraction of Public Universities and Expansion of the National Council for Scientific and Technological Research (CONICET)
(/isis/citation/CBB001211970/)
Chapter
Chadarevian, Soraya de;
(2013)
Putting Human Genetics on a Solid Basis: Human Chromosome Research, 1950s--1970s
(/isis/citation/CBB001500058/)
Book
Carmen, Ira H.;
(2004)
Politics in the Laboratory: The Constitution of Human Genomics
(/isis/citation/CBB000550766/)
Article
David Robertson;
(2018)
Evaluating the Aboriginal child’s mind: assimilation and cross-cultural psychology in Australia
(/isis/citation/CBB567097528/)
Book
Phillips, Christopher J.;
(2014)
The New Math: A Political History
(/isis/citation/CBB001422025/)
Article
M'charek, Amade;
Schramm, Katharina;
Skinner, David;
(2014)
Topologies of Race: Doing Territory, Population and Identity in Europe
(/isis/citation/CBB001421200/)
Article
Birch, Kean;
(2006)
Introduction: Biofutures/Biopresents
(/isis/citation/CBB000720300/)
Article
Gunnar Babcock;
(2020)
Asexual organisms, identity and vertical gene transfer
(/isis/citation/CBB936643771/)
Minerva: A Review of Science, Learning and Policy
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Science, Technology and Human Values
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
History of Psychiatry
Be the first to comment!