IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB918192388

Paris vs. Prague: A “Suspicion of Fraud”: Ernst Mach Argues over Photographs and Epistemological Prerequisites (2016)

Science in Context
Volume: 29
Issue: 4
Pages: 409-427

URI: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/science-in-context/article/paris-vs-prague-a-suspicion-of-fraud-ernst-mach-argues-over-photographs-and-epistemological-prerequisites/8E55AA89173208CA715CAE47E5086ABC

DOI: 10.1017/S0269889716000156

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Projectile motion Plagiarism Mechanics Physics Controversies and disputes 19th century Mach, Ernst

In spring 1888, an anonymous critic raised severe doubts about Ernst Mach's and Peter Salcher's studies, published one year before, on the processes in the air caused by very rapid projectiles. Paraphrasing the experiments for the French popular science magazine La Nature, the critic insinuated that the photographs upon which Mach and Salcher's argument were ostensibly based must have been of such low quality that they did not allow any well-founded conclusion. The critic did not deny the phenomena Mach and Salcher had presented in their article; he denied that the photographs taken in the course of the experiments could permit any observation of the phenomena. I take the resulting quarrel as a window into the actors’ ideas on the requirements of “good observations” and the role of technical devices in this case. In particular I enquire how the various arguments relate to Lorraine Daston's and Peter Galison's framing of photography as an emblem of “mechanical objectivity.” We will see that in the case under debate, actors considered naked-eye observation, observation by telescope and photography mainly with regard to the challenges of the particular research object.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB918192388/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Chapter Pietro Cerreta; (2017)
Mach, the Principles of Dynamics and Newton’s Bucket (/isis/citation/CBB036183229/)

Chapter Massimo Ferrari; (2018)
“Uno strenuo difensore” di Mach: John Bernhard Stallo (/isis/citation/CBB213065857/)

Article Anders, John; (2013)
Problēmata Mēchanika, the Analytics, and Projectile Motion (/isis/citation/CBB001200188/)

Article van Strien, Marij; (2013)
The Nineteenth Century Conflict between Mechanism and Irreversibility (/isis/citation/CBB001213355/)

Article Assis, Andre K. T.; Zylbersztajn, Arden; (2001)
The Influence of Ernst Mach in the Teaching of Mechanics (/isis/citation/CBB000101869/)

Article Alemañ Berenguer, Rafael Andres; (2008)
Geometría y física: de Hertz a Einstein (/isis/citation/CBB000933114/)

Article Palmieri, Paolo; (2008)
The Empirical Basis of Equilibrium: Mach, Vailati, and the Lever (/isis/citation/CBB000930746/)

Article Pooley, Oliver; Brown, Harvey R.; (2002)
Relationalism Rehabilitated? I: Classical Mechanics (/isis/citation/CBB000200166/)

Article Preston, John; (2008)
Mach and Hertz's Mechanics (/isis/citation/CBB000930751/)

Chapter Heller, Michael; (1988)
Between Newton and Einstein: Mach's reform of the Newtonian mechanics (/isis/citation/CBB000043661/)

Article Mitchell, Sam; (1993)
Mach's mechanics and absolute space and time (/isis/citation/CBB000051965/)

Article Smith, Russell; (2015)
Shining a Light on Harriot and Galileo: On the Mechanics of Reflection and Projectile Motion (/isis/citation/CBB001553624/)

Chapter Marco Buzzoni; (2018)
Ernst Mach interprete di Pierre Duhem. Valore e limiti della sperimentazione mentale (/isis/citation/CBB306281511/)

Chapter Erik C. Banks; (2018)
The Case for Mach's Neutral Monism (/isis/citation/CBB571671358/)

Article Richard Staley; (2021)
Sensory studies, or when physics was psychophysics: Ernst Mach and physics between physiology and psychology, 1860–71 (/isis/citation/CBB206423864/)

Chapter Luca Guidetti; (2018)
Il problema dell'analogia in Ernst Mach (/isis/citation/CBB358140394/)

Book Blackmore, John T.; (2010)
Ernst Mach's Graz (1864--1867): Where Much Science and Philosophy Were Developed (/isis/citation/CBB001024110/)

Book Mach, Ernst; (2001)
Fundamentals of the Theory of Movement Perception (/isis/citation/CBB000101549/)

Article John Henry; Steffen Ducheyne; (2021)
Letter to the Editor (/isis/citation/CBB441829838/)

Book Pietro Gori; (2018)
Ernst Mach: tra scienza e filosofia (/isis/citation/CBB991429309/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}