Changing publication practices and the typification of the journal article in science and technology studies (2022)
Kaltenbrunner, Wolfgang (Author)
Birch, Kean (Author)
Thed van Leeuwen (Author)
Maria Amuchastegui (Author)
Social Studies of Science
Volume: 52
Issue: 5
Pages: 758-782
In this article, we study the development of the STS journal article format since the 1980s. Our analysis is based on quantitative data that suggest that the diversity of various journal publication types has diminished over the past four decades, while the format of research articles has become increasingly typified. We contextualize these historical shifts in qualitative terms, drawing on a set of 76 interviews with STS scholars and other stakeholders in scholarly publishing. Here, we first portray the STS publication culture of the 1980s and early 1990s. We then contrast this with an analysis of publishing practices today, which are characterized by a much more structured research process that is largely organized around the production of typified journal articles. Whereas earlier studies have often emphasized the importance of rhetorical persuasion strategies as drivers in the development of scholarly communication formats, our analysis highlights a complementary and historically novel set of shaping factors, namely, increasingly quantified research (self-)assessment practices in the context of a projectification of academic life. We argue that reliance on a highly structured publication format is a distinct strategy for making STS scholarship ‘doable’ in the sense of facilitating the planning ability and daily conduct of research across a variety of levels – including the writing process, collaboration with peers, attracting funding, and interaction with journals. We conclude by reflecting on the advantages and downsides of the typification of journal articles for STS.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Robert E. Kohler;
Lynn K. Nyhart;
Arnold Thackray;
(2022)
Eloge: Frances Coulborn Kohler (1938–2021)
Article
Dorien Daling;
(2023)
“On the ruins of seriality”: The scientific journal and the nature of the scientific life
Article
Christian Greiffenhagen;
(2024)
Judging Importance before Checking Correctness: Quick Opinions in Mathematical Peer Review
Article
Sara Heidenreich;
(May 2018)
Outreaching, Outsourcing, and Disembedding: How Offshore Wind Scientists Consider Their Engagement with Society
Article
Sampsa Saikkonen;
Esa Väliverronen;
(2022)
The trickle-down of political and economic control: On the organizational suppression of environmental scientists in government science
Article
Luciano Levin;
(2020)
Advising and controling: Science communication at a crossroads
Article
Cynthia Bergmann;
Jens Westemeier;
Dominik Gross;
(2022)
The Editors of Scientific Journals in Dentistry in Nazi Germany and after 1945: A Sociodemographic Study
Article
Aliakbar Akbaritabar;
Flaminio Squazzoni;
(May 2021)
Gender Patterns of Publication in Top Sociological Journals
Article
Pia Vuolanto;
Marjo Kolehmainen;
(July 2021)
Gendered Boundary-work within the Finnish Skepticism Movement
Article
Mary Frank Fox;
Diana Roldan Rueda;
Gerhard Sonnert;
Amanda Nabors;
Sarah Bartel;
(2022)
Publications about Women, Science, and Engineering: Use of Sex and Gender in Titles over a Forty-six-year Period
Article
Vladimir Jankovic;
(August 2018)
‘The Sun Without a Permit’: Serbian Solar Politics, Informational Risk Cascades, and the Great Disappearing Act of August 1999
Article
Edward J. Hackett;
(2022)
Introduction: Science, Technology, & Human Values at Fifty
Article
Gijs Mom;
(March 2020)
Trending Transfers: A Decade of New Mobility Studies through the Lens of Transmodality, Transnationalism, and Transdisciplinarity
Article
Daryl E. Chubin;
(2022)
Science, Technology, & Human Values at Fifty: A Deserter Reports
Article
Ulrike Felt;
(2022)
Transitions, Expansions, Engagements: Science, Technology, & Human Values between 2002 and 2007
Article
Geoffrey C. Bowker;
(2022)
Working with Olga Kuchinskaya and Katie Vann
Article
Susan Cozzens;
(2022)
Transitions: Science, Technology, & Human Values in 1986 and Onward
Article
Timothy Neale;
Courtney Addison;
Kari Lancaster;
Matthew Kearnes;
(2022)
A Meeting Point for STS Interventions and Conversations
Article
Edward J. Hackett;
(2022)
Editing as a Vocation
Article
Jerry Gaston;
(2022)
Observations and Confessions: Honoring the Fiftieth Anniversary of Science, Technology, & Human Values Publications
Be the first to comment!