Article ID: CBB907629635

Introduction to an English Translation, "On the Different Explanations of Certain Cases of Isomerism" by Aleksandr Butlerov (2015)

unapi

Lewis, David E. (Author)


Bulletin for the History of Chemistry
Volume: 40
Issue: 1
Pages: 9-12


Publication Date: 2015
Edition Details: First of a Series: "On the Different Explanations of Certain Cases of Isomerism" by Aleksandr Butlerov
Language: English

This rather lengthy paper by Butlerov sought to bolster the case for the structural theory of organic chemistry by reconciling the apparently diametrically opposed views of Friedrich August Kekulé (1) and Hermann Kolbe (2). In retrospect, despite not being called a classic by the Alembic Club or Ostwald’s Klassiker, this paper really does represent a watershed in the development of organic chemistry because a neutral third party with credibility in both camps served as the referee for the argument. Part of why it did not achieve “forgotten classic” status at the turn of the twentieth century is almost certainly the fact while that papers by the originators of structural theory, Kekulé and Couper, were recognized as classic contributions, Butlerov’s enhancements of the theory, which were critical to its further development and acceptance, were viewed as being a lesser contribution. Butlerov’s claims in this arena were also not helped by the blatant politicization of the history of science in the Soviet Union during the heyday of the cold war (3). However, today, as Butlerov’s contributions are undergoing an impartial re-appraisal (4), it appears to me that this paper actually does deserve the title of “forgotten classic.”

...More
Associated with

Article A. Boutlerow (2015) Primary Documents: "On the Different Explanations of Certain Cases of Isomerism". Bulletin for the History of Chemistry (pp. 13-28). unapi

Article N. Kizhner; Vladislav Sunstsov; David E. Lewis (2015) Primary Documents 27. on the Catalytic Decomposition of Alkylidenehydrazines. (second Part) (abridged). Bulletin for the History of Chemistry (pp. 69-73). unapi

Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB907629635/

Similar Citations

Article A. Boutlerow; (2015)
Primary Documents: "On the Different Explanations of Certain Cases of Isomerism" (/isis/citation/CBB907777361/)

Article David E. Lewis; (2022)
A Future History of Selectivity in Organic Chemistry: Whence, Where, and Whither? (/isis/citation/CBB988568054/)

Article Rocke, A. J.; (1981)
Kekulé, Butlerov, and the historiography of the theory of chemical structure (/isis/citation/CBB000010404/)

Article David E. Lewis; (2019)
1860-1861: Magic years in the development of the structural theory of organic chemistry (/isis/citation/CBB223728585/)

Book Rocke, Alan J.; (2010)
Image and Reality: Kekulé, Kopp, and the Scientific Imagination (/isis/citation/CBB001020050/)

Essay Review Nye, Mary Jo; (2011)
Visual Tools and the Quiet Chemical Revolution (/isis/citation/CBB001566751/)

Article Rocke, Alan J.; (1992-93)
Pride and prejudice in chemistry: Chauvinism and the pursuit of science (/isis/citation/CBB000040975/)

Book Rocke, Alan J.; (1993)
The quiet revolution: Hermann Kolbe and the science of organic chemistry (/isis/citation/CBB000038143/)

Article Rocke, Alan J.; (1983)
Subatomic speculations and the origin of structure theory (/isis/citation/CBB000003691/)

Article Dayan, Anthony D.; (2006)
The Circumstances of Kekule's Molecular Dream in London in 1854 (/isis/citation/CBB000740483/)

Article Markovnikov, Vladimir Vasilevich; (2018)
Primary Documents on the Question on the Mutual Influence of Atoms in Chemical Compounds (/isis/citation/CBB302278273/)

Article Nathan M. Brooks; (2019)
The Kazan School of Chemistry: A Re-interpretation (/isis/citation/CBB445789982/)

Chapter Rocke, Alan J.; (1995)
Pride and prejudice in chemistry: Kolbe, Hofmann, and German antisemitism (/isis/citation/CBB000069028/)

Article Rocke, Alan J.; (1990)
“Between two stools”: Kopp, Kolbe and the history of chemistry (/isis/citation/CBB000048116/)

Article Rocke, Alan J.; (1993)
Group research in German chemistry: Kolbe's Marburg and Leipzig institutes (/isis/citation/CBB000047195/)

Article Brooks, Nathan M.; (1998)
Alexander Butlerov and the professionalization of science in Russia (/isis/citation/CBB000077529/)

Article Kasiwagi, Hazime; (1974 (pub. 1975))
Some marked characteristics of Hermann Kolbe's concept of the chemical constitution (/isis/citation/CBB000022113/)

Authors & Contributors
Rocke, Alan J.
Lewis, David E.
Brooks, Nathan M.
Sunstsov, Vladislav
Kischner, Nikolai Matwejewitsch (Кижнер, Николай Матвеевич)
Boutlerow, A.
Concepts
Organic chemistry
Structural chemistry
Chemistry
Primary literature (historical sources)
Translations
Imagination
Time Periods
19th century
20th century
Places
Russia
Germany
Institutions
Kazan State University (Казанский государственный университет)
Universitet Kazan
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment