Article ID: CBB895974945

Maxwellian Electrodynamics Genesis and Development: Intertheoretic Context (2016)


Key words: rationality, communication, maxwellian revolution, Ampere-Weber research programme, synthesis, Kantian epistemology . Abstract. Why did Maxwell’s programme supersede the Ampere-Weber one? – To answer the question one has to consider the intertheoretic context of maxwellian electrodynamics genesis and development. It is demonstrated that maxwellian electrodynamics was created as a result of the old pre-maxwellian programmes reconciliation: the electrodynamics of Ampere-Weber, the wave theory of Young-Fresnel and Faraday’s programme. The programmes’ meeting led to construction of the hybrid theory at first with an irregular set of theoretical schemes. However, step by step, on revealing and gradual eliminating the contradictions between the programmes involved, the hybrid set is “put into order” (Maxwell’s term).A hierarchy of theoretical schemes starting from the crossbreeds (the displacement current) and up to usual hybrids is set up. And after the displacement current construction the interpenetration of the pre-maxwellian programmes begins that markes the commencement of theoretical schemes of optics and electromagnetism real unification. Maxwell’s programme did supersede the Ampere-Weber one because it did assimilate the ideas of the Ampere-Weber programme, as well as the presuppositions of the programmes of Young-Fresnel and Faraday properly co-ordinating them with each other. But the opposite proposition is not true. Ampere-Weber programme did not assimilate the propositions of the Maxwellian programme. Maxwell’s victory became possible because the core of Maxwell’s unification strategy was formed by Kantian epistemology looked through the prism of William Whewell and such representatives of Scottish Enlightenment as Thomas Reid and William Hamilton. Maxwell did put forward as a basic synthetic principle the idea that radically differed from that of Ampere-Weber approach by its open, flexible and contra-ontological, strictly epistemological, Kantian character. For Maxwell, ether was not the last building block of physical reality, from which all the charges and fields should be constructed. “Action at a distance”, “incompressible fluid”, “molecular vortices” were contrived analogies for Maxwell, capable only to direct the researcher at the “right” mathematical relations. Namely the application of Kantian epistemology enabled Hermann von Helmholtz and his pupil Heinrich Hertz to arrive at such a version of Maxwell’s theory that served a heuristical basis for the radio waves discovery.

Citation URI

Similar Citations

Article Jentschura, U. D.; Nándori, I.; (2014)
Attempts at a Determination of the Fine-Structure Constant from First Principles: A Brief Historical Overview (/isis/citation/CBB001421684/)

Article Vera Hartenstein; Mario Hubert; (2021)
When Fields Are Not Degrees of Freedom (/isis/citation/CBB322806876/)

Book Steinle, Friedrich; (2005)
Explorative Experimente: Ampère, Faraday und die Ursprünge der Elektrodynamik (/isis/citation/CBB001033912/)

Article Cristian Soto; Diego Romero-Maltrana; (2020)
Local Selective Realism: Shifting from Classical to Quantum Electrodynamics (/isis/citation/CBB826372933/)

Article Frisch, Mathias; (2002)
Non-Locality in Classical Electrodynamics (/isis/citation/CBB000200158/)

Chapter Alberto Giovanni Biuso; (2016)
Filosofia teoretica come filosofia del tempo (/isis/citation/CBB812907389/)

Article Achinstein, Peter; (2007)
Atom's Empirical Eve: Methodological Disputes and How to Evaluate Them (/isis/citation/CBB000830786/)

Chapter Nersessian, Nancy J.; (2001)
Concept formation and commensurability (/isis/citation/CBB000102881/)

Article Francesco Nappo; (2021)
The double nature of Maxwell's physical analogies (/isis/citation/CBB554615043/)

Article Cat, Jordi; (2001)
On Understanding: Maxwell on the Methods of Illustration and Scientific Metaphor (/isis/citation/CBB000100733/)

Article Hona, Giora; Goldstein, Bernard R.; (2012)
Maxwell's Contrived Analogy: An Early Version of the Methodology of Modeling (/isis/citation/CBB001211045/)

Article Lazaroff-Puck, Cameron; (2015)
Gearing up for Lagrangian Dynamics: The Flywheel Analogy in Maxwell's 1865 Paper on Electrodynamics (/isis/citation/CBB001553278/)

Article Olivier Darrigol; (2019)
The magic of Feynman’s QED: from field-less electrodynamics to the Feynman diagrams (/isis/citation/CBB271562020/)

Article Joan Lisa Bromberg; (2016)
Explaining the Laser’s Light: Classical Versus Quantum Electrodynamics in the 1960s (/isis/citation/CBB828432899/)

Article Kaiser, David; (2005)
Physics and Feynman's Diagrams (/isis/citation/CBB001021587/)

Article Tazzioli, Rossana; (2001)
Green's Function in Some Contributions of 19th Century Mathematicians (/isis/citation/CBB000100594/)

Article Galison, Peter; (2008)
The Discovery of the Muon and the Failed Revolution against Quantum Electrodynamics (/isis/citation/CBB000850461/)

Authors & Contributors
Frisch, Mathias
Hubert, Mario
Alberto Giovanni Biuso
Francesco Nappo
Hartenstein, Vera
Romero-Maltrana, Diego
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics
Perspectives on Science
European Physical Journal H
British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
Archive for History of Exact Sciences
Theoria (0495-4548)
Oxford University Press
Philosophy of science
Quantum mechanics
Maxwell, James Clerk
Sommerfeld, Arnold Johannes Wilhelm
Ostwald, Friedrich Wilhelm
Lorentz, Hendrik Antoon
Feynman, Richard Phillips
Faraday, Michael
Time Periods
19th century
20th century
20th century, early
21st century
20th century, late
Great Britain
United States
School of Milan

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment