This article examines the relation between commercial activity and knowledge-making, looking at hatmakers in order to open up a more general question about the overlap between the knowledge practices of 19th-century science and those of everyday commercial culture of the time. Phrenology also claims attention here, since it can be said to have occupied an intermediate position between science and commerce. From time to time during the first half of the century, phrenologists attended to hatmakers in the hope of gleaning knowledge from their commercial experience, but after about 1860, scientific craniometers took a very different view. Physical anthropologists like Paul Broca believed that the skull was the key source of data on which to build a scientific anthropology of race or ethnicity. Observers drew the attention of Broca and his colleagues to the existence of a commercial device called the conformateur des chapeliers, used by hatters to determine head shape. But Broca was far less inclined to welcome hatmakers into the domain of craniology than the phrenologists had been. Whereas phrenologists had found validation in common sense, any widely available understanding of racial types was considered by Broca to be a distraction from the work of science and a potential distortion of its data. Far from the welcoming curiosity shown by London-based phrenologists, the anthropological enterprise led by Broca defined itself as scientific in part by the strictness with which it considered and dismissed such approximate and informal ways of knowing.
...MoreArticle Peter Cryle; Elizabeth Stephens (2021) Normality: A Collection of Essays. History of the Human Sciences (pp. 3-8).
Similar Citations
Article
Christie-Robin, Julia;
Orzada, Belinda T.;
López-Gydosh, Dilia;
(2012)
From Bustles to Bloomers: Exploring the Bicycle's Influence on American Women's Fashion, 1880--1914
(/isis/citation/CBB001202120/)
Article
Peter Cryle;
Elizabeth Stephens;
(2021)
Normality: A Collection of Essays
(/isis/citation/CBB959369497/)
Article
Alberto Zanatta;
Giuliano Scattolin;
Gaetano Thiene;
Fabio Zampieri;
(2016)
Phrenology between anthropology and neurology in a nineteenth-century collection of skulls
(/isis/citation/CBB513838346/)
Article
Stanley Finger;
Paul Eling;
(2022)
Phrenology’s frontal sinus problem: An insurmountable obstruction?
(/isis/citation/CBB298422709/)
Article
Carla Bittel;
(2021)
Cranial Compatibility: Phrenology, Measurement, and Marriage Assessment
(/isis/citation/CBB827397197/)
Article
Trevor Engel;
(2024)
A “Most Remarkable Trait”: “Flathead” Skulls, Indigenous Pathologization, and Transinstitutionalization
(/isis/citation/CBB295873867/)
Thesis
Courtney Elizabeth Thompson;
(2015)
Criminal Minds: Medicine, Law, and the Phrenological Impulse in America, 1830-1890
(/isis/citation/CBB595020617/)
Article
Lebina, Natalia;
(2009)
Plus the Chemicalization of the Entire Wardrobe
(/isis/citation/CBB001030524/)
Book
Anneke van Mosseveld;
(2018)
The Australian Army Uniform and the Government Clothing Factory: Innovation in the Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB277094985/)
Article
Panek, Tracey;
(2018)
The global blue jeans transformation
(/isis/citation/CBB220656926/)
Article
Ricardo Roque;
(2021)
The Logic of Skull Writing: Bone Inscriptions and the Science of Race
(/isis/citation/CBB967795853/)
Article
Jonathan Michael Kaplan;
Massimo Pigliucci;
Joshua Alexander Banta;
(2015)
Gould on Morton, Redux: What can the debate reveal about the limits of data?
(/isis/citation/CBB554093002/)
Book
Fabian, Ann;
(2010)
The Skull Collectors: Race, Science, and America's Unburied Dead
(/isis/citation/CBB001033349/)
Article
Laurens de Rooy;
(2023)
The Shelf Life of Skulls: Anthropology and ‘race’ in the Vrolik Craniological Collection
(/isis/citation/CBB102434808/)
Thesis
Juzda, E;
(cited 2011)
The Rise and Fall of British Craniometry, 1860--1939
(/isis/citation/CBB001567345/)
Book
James Poskett;
(2019)
Materials of the Mind: Phrenology, Race, and the Global History of Science, 1815-1920
(/isis/citation/CBB218438079/)
Article
Catherine E. Storey;
(2020)
The Promotion of Phrenology in New South Wales, 1830–1850, at the Sydney Mechanics School of Arts
(/isis/citation/CBB824297123/)
Chapter
Fabian, Ann;
(2008)
A Native among the Headhunters
(/isis/citation/CBB001035381/)
Article
Wagner, Kim A.;
(2010)
Confessions of a Skull: Phrenology and Colonial Knowledge in Early Nineteenth-Century India
(/isis/citation/CBB001032337/)
Article
Meyer, Susan;
(2003)
Craniometry, Race, and the Artist in Willa Cather
(/isis/citation/CBB000330039/)
Be the first to comment!