Challenging Custodialism: Families and Eugenic Institutionalization at the Pennsylvania Training School for Feeble-Minded Children at Elwyn (2021)
Historians have described how powerful eugenic ideologies fueled the rapid expansion of custodial institutionalization of the so-called feebleminded in the early twentieth century. Using new sources from the recently opened archive of the Pennsylvania Training School for Feeble-Minded Children at Elwyn, this article argues that in practice, this transition to custodialism was difficult, uneven, and subject to constant compromise. Institutional residents and their families contested expert prognoses and disciplinary methods and maintained relationships across institutional boundaries. Their vernacular ideas about mental impairment, curability, and the purpose of institutional segregation produced a gap between eugenic discourse and institutional life. The challenges that residents and their families levied were neither absolute nor consistent: their force and success depended on their class status, community contexts, and most significantly, the perceived severity of a resident’s impairment. Residents with greater care needs were frequently relegated to the background, not only in psycho-medical professionals’ treatises and administration but in the expectations that families brought to bear on the institution. Decades before institutionalized people and their families formed political advocacy groups that struggled for deinstitutionalization and civil rights, they fought individual battles that pitted their intimate knowledge against expertise. Although their victories were small and statistically rare, they tested the bounds of psycho-medical authority and established the ideological and practical limits of eugenic mass institutionalization.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Lira;
(2021)
Laboratory of Deficiency: Sterilization and confinement in California, 1900–1950s
(/isis/citation/CBB688400608/)
Book
Sarah F. Rose;
(2017)
No Right to Be Idle: The Invention of Disability, 1840s–1930s
(/isis/citation/CBB247390759/)
Article
Julie Anderson;
(2020)
“Homes away from Home” and “Happy Prisoners”: Disabled Veterans, Space, and Masculinity in Britain, 1944–19501
(/isis/citation/CBB250376474/)
Chapter
Morris, Sharon;
(2006)
“Human Dregs at the Bottom of Our National Vats”: The Inter-War Debate on Sterilization of the Mentally Deficient
(/isis/citation/CBB000774649/)
Article
Weinert, Sebastian;
(2011)
Die “Krüppelfürsorge” in der Weimarer Republik. Zwischen eigenem Standpunkt und diskursiver Anschlussfähigkeit an eugenische Argumentationsstrukturen
(/isis/citation/CBB001220452/)
Article
Baynton, Douglas C.;
(2011)
“These Pushful Days”: Time and Disability in the Age of Eugenics
(/isis/citation/CBB001232064/)
Article
Emily Rose Gordon;
(2022)
Wheels of Injustice: How Medical Schools Retained the Power to Discriminate Against Applicants in Wheelchairs in the Era of Disability Rights
(/isis/citation/CBB847604115/)
Book
Claire L. Shaw;
(2017)
Deaf in the USSR: Marginality, Community, and Soviet Identity, 1917-1991
(/isis/citation/CBB205072501/)
Book
Stefanie Hunt-Kennedy;
(2020)
Between Fitness and Death: Disability and Slavery in the Caribbean
(/isis/citation/CBB216430099/)
Thesis
Greenwald, Brian H.;
(2006)
Alexander Graham Bell through the Lens of Eugenics, 1883--1922
(/isis/citation/CBB001561598/)
Book
Catharine Coleborne;
(2015)
Insanity, identity and empire: Immigrants and institutional confinement in Australia and New Zealand, 1873–1910
(/isis/citation/CBB231366413/)
Article
Gillian Allmond;
(2017)
Liberty and the individual: the colony asylum in Scotland and England
(/isis/citation/CBB034575395/)
Book
Sarah Ann Pinto;
(2018)
Lunatic Asylums in Colonial Bombay: Shackled Bodies, Unchained Minds
(/isis/citation/CBB126077328/)
Article
Nana Osei Quarshie;
(2022)
Psychiatry on a Shoestring: West Africa and the Global Movements of Deinstitutionalization
(/isis/citation/CBB157477117/)
Article
Charmaine Robson;
(2020)
Doctors’ Dilemma: Appraising the Rights of New South Wales Leprosy Sufferers, 1890–1950
(/isis/citation/CBB440057912/)
Book
Ryan C. Edwards;
(2021)
A Carceral Ecology: Ushuaia and the History of Landscape and Punishment in Argentina
(/isis/citation/CBB265022827/)
Book
Maria Luísa Sousa;
(2016)
A Mobilidade Automóvel em Portugal, 1920-1950
(/isis/citation/CBB901356486/)
Article
Hilde Dahl;
(2017)
‘Insane criminals’ and the ‘criminally insane’: criminal asylums in Norway, 1895–1940
(/isis/citation/CBB231193752/)
Article
Carlos S. Dimas;
(2022)
In Service and Observation of the State: The Argentine Meteorological Service and the Culture of Weather Observation in Argentina, 1872–1915
(/isis/citation/CBB468672981/)
Article
Jae-Hyung Kim;
(2019)
Death and Survival of Patients with Hansen’s Disease in Colonial Korea
(/isis/citation/CBB744108635/)
Be the first to comment!