The Intellectual Property Turn in Global Health: From a Property to a Human Rights View of Health (2021)
Laura G. Pedraza-Fariña (Author)
Osiris: A Research Journal Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Volume: 36
Pages: 241-261
International intellectual property (IP) law for pharmaceuticals has fundamentally shifted in the twenty-first century from a property-centric to a human rights view. Scholars tend to explain this transformation in the context of both the power struggle between developing and developed countries, and the influence of a social movement that criticized IP rights as hindering access to essential medicines. Yet, these explanations leave out the central role of two international organizations, the World Trade Organization (WTO) and the World Health Organization (WHO), and particularly their permanent staffs, whose boundary disputes have shaped international IP law at the intersection of trade and global health. Bringing into conversation historical and legal literatures on global health and IP, this article traces how a human rights perspective on IP emerged as a strategy to reconcile the WHO staff’s sociomedical views of health with an increasingly dominant set of global IP rules. It shows how the WHO staff used the language of economics—an analytical frame favored by the WTO—to advance a then unorthodox economic understanding of IP as a type of governmental regulation. This allowed the WHO to argue that states should enjoy regulatory autonomy to curtail IP rights in order to meet broader state objectives, such as human rights protection. Paradoxically, despite their divergent views on the nature of IP, both WTO and WHO engagement with it heralded the emergence of a new technocratic view of global health that focuses on patentable medicines and technologies, and that has ultimately turned away from the WHO’s sociomedical roots.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
João Biehl;
(2021)
The Pharmaceuticalization and Judicialization of Health: On the Interface of Medical Capitalism and Magical Legalism in Brazil
Article
Yun Zhao;
Zhijie Chen;
(August 2022)
Intellectual Property Protection in Outer Space: Conflict in Theory and Application in Practice
Article
Mario Biagioli;
Alain Pottage;
(2021)
Patenting Personalized Medicine: Molecules, Information, and the Body
Chapter
Hayden, Cori;
(2011)
No Patent, No Generic: Pharmaceutical Access and the Politics of the Copy
Book
Marcos Cueto;
Theodore M. Brown;
Elizabeth Fee;
(2019)
The World Health Organization: A History
Article
Bernard Brabin;
Brabin Loretta;
(2024)
The public health role of the World Health Organisation through its postal record
Article
Lisa M. Richards;
(2022)
1945–1964 WHO’s Right to Health?
Article
McKeever, Brooke Weberling;
(2013)
News Framing of Autism: Understanding Media Advocacy and the Combating Autism Act
Thesis
Levy, Jean Elizabeth;
(2007)
Controlling the Course of Scientific Advance: The Case of Human Embryology
Book
Horace A. Bartilow;
(2019)
Drug War Pathologies: Embedded Corporatism and U.S. Drug Enforcement in the Americas
Book
Matthew R. Pembleton;
(2017)
Containing Addiction: The Federal Bureau of Narcotics and the Origins of America's Global Drug War
Thesis
Tovino, Stacey A.;
(2006)
The Visible Brain: Confidentiality and Privacy Implications of Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Article
Plomer, Aurora;
(2013)
The Human Rights Paradox: Intellectual Property Rights and Rights of Access to Science
Article
Helen Tilley;
(2021)
Traditional Medicine Goes Global: Pan-African Precedents, Cultural Decolonization, and Cold War Rights/Properties
Article
Lindemann, Mary;
(2008)
The Body Debated: Bodies and Rights in Seventeenth- and Eighteenth-Century Germany
Book
Giorgio Giulio Santonocito;
(2022)
Storia del diritto alla salute
Chapter
Biehl, Joao;
Petryna, Adriana;
(2013)
Legal Remedies: Therapeutic Markets and the Judicialization of the Right to Health
Book
Woodward, John;
Jütte, Robert;
(2000)
Coping with Sickness: Medicine, Law and Human Rights---Historical Perspectives
Article
Olivier Walusinski;
(2017)
Antoine-Marie Chambeyron (1797–1851): a forgotten disciple of Jean-Etienne Esquirol (1772–1840)
Book
Faunce, Thomas Alured;
(2005)
Pilgrims in Medicine: Conscience, Legalism, and Human Rights: An Allegory of Medical Humanities, Foundational Virtues, Ethical Principles, Law and Human Rights in Medical, Personal, and Professional Development
Be the first to comment!