The culture of honour hypothesis offers a compelling example of how human psychology differentially adapts to pastoral and horticultural environments. However, there is disagreement over whether this pattern is best explained by a memetic, evolutionary psychological, dual inheritance, or niche construction model. I argue that this disagreement stems from two shortcomings: lack of clarity about the theoretical commitments of these models and inadequate comparative data for testing them. To resolve the first problem, I offer a theoretical framework for deriving competing predictions from each of the four models. In particular, this involves a novel interpretation of the difference between dual inheritance theory and cultural niche construction. I then illustrate a strategy for testing their predictions using data from the Human Relations Area File. Empirical results suggest that the aggressive psychological phenotype typically associated with honour culture is more common among pastoral societies than among horticultural societies. Theoretical considerations suggest that this pattern is best explained as a case of cultural niche construction.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Eugene Earnshaw-Whyte;
(2018)
Modelling Evolution: A New Dynamic Account
Article
Rasmus Grønfeldt Winther;
Ryan Giordano;
Michael D. Edge;
Rasmus Nielsen;
(2015)
The mind, the lab, and the field: Three kinds of populations in scientific practice
Book
Gintis, Herbert;
(2009)
The Bounds of Reason: Game Theory and the Unification of the Behavioral Sciences
Article
Skyrms, Brian;
(2000)
Stability and Explanatory Significance of Some Simple Evolutionary Models
Article
Taylor, Peter;
(2000)
Socio-Ecological Webs and Sites of Sociality: Levins' Strategy of Model Building Revisited
Thesis
Eugene, Earnshaw-Whyte.;
(2012)
Modeling Evolution
Article
(2000)
Philosophy of Biology, Psychology, and Neuroscience: The Organism in Philosophical Focus
Article
Snait B. Gissis;
(2020)
Transfer of Lamarckisms and emerging ‘scientific’ psychologies: 19th – early 20th centuries Britain and France
Article
Lechtreck, Hans-Jürgen;
(2003)
A History of Some Fruit Models in Wax and Other Materials: Scientific Teaching Aids and Courtly Table Decorations
Essay Review
Sterelny, Kim;
(2000)
Looking after Number One?
Essay Review
Narveson, Jan;
(2000)
Evolutionary Biology, Altruism, and Moral Theory
Book
Patrick Armstrong;
(2019)
Alfred Russel Wallace
Chapter
Gissis, Snait B.;
(2010)
Lamarck on Feelings: From Worms to Humans
Book
Reid, Julia;
(2006)
Robert Louis Stevenson, Science, and the Fin de Siècle
Article
Radick, Gregory;
(2010)
Darwin's Puzzling Expression
Article
Nelson, E. C.;
(2002)
The Drummonds of Forfar---Five Generations of Plantsmen in Scotland, Ireland, North America, Australia, and India
Book
Hew, Choy Sin;
Yam, Tim Wing;
Arditti, Joseph;
(2002)
Biology of Vanda Miss Joaquim
Book
Matthew Holmes;
(2024)
The Graft Hybrid: Challenging Twentieth-Century Genetics
Chapter
Gissis, Snait B.;
(2011)
Lamarckism and the Constitution of Sociology
Article
Collin C. Rice;
(2015)
Factive Scientific Understanding Without Accurate Representation
Be the first to comment!