I present a systematic interpretation of the foundational purpose of constructions in ancient Greek geometry. I argue that Greek geometers were committed to an operationalist foundational program, according to which all of mathematics—including its entire ontology and epistemology—is based entirely on concrete physical constructions. On this reading, key foundational aspects of Greek geometry are analogous to core tenets of 20th-century operationalist/positivist/constructivist/intuitionist philosophy of science and mathematics. Operationalism provides coherent answers to a range of traditional philosophical problems regarding classical mathematics, such as the epistemic warrant and generality of diagrammatic reasoning, superposition, and the relation between constructivism and proof by contradiction. Alleged logical flaws in Euclid (implicit diagrammatic reasoning, superposition) can be interpreted as sound operationalist reasoning. Operationalism also provides a compelling philosophical motivation for the otherwise inexplicable Greek obsession with cube duplication, angle trisection, and circle quadrature. Operationalism makes coherent sense of numerous specific choices made in this tradition, and suggests new interpretations of several solutions to these problems. In particular, I argue that: Archytas’s cube duplication was originally a single-motion machine; Diocles’s cissoid was originally traced by a linkage device; Greek conic section theory was thoroughly constructive, based on the conic compass; in a few cases, string-based constructions of conic sections were used instead; pointwise constructions of curves were rejected in foundational contexts by Greek mathematicians, with good reason. Operationalism enables us to view the classical geometrical tradition as a more unified and philosophically aware enterprise than has hitherto been recognised.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Wagner, Roy;
(2009)
For Some Histories of Greek Mathematics
(/isis/citation/CBB000932767/)
Article
Raymond, Dwayne;
(2011)
From a Particular Diagram to a Universal Result: Euclid's Elements, Book I
(/isis/citation/CBB001250013/)
Book
Hyder, David Jalal;
(2009)
The Determinate World: Kant and Helmholtz on the Physical Meaning of Geometry
(/isis/citation/CBB001252396/)
Article
Iwata, Naoya;
(2015)
Plato on Geometrical Hypothesis in the Meno
(/isis/citation/CBB001202190/)
Article
Ladislav Kvasz;
(2020)
Cognitive Unity of Thales’ Mathematics
(/isis/citation/CBB542780608/)
Article
Vincenzo De Risi;
(2021)
Euclid’s Common Notions and the Theory of Equivalence
(/isis/citation/CBB348431913/)
Thesis
Welsh, Whitney Elizabeth;
(2011)
Unthinkable: Mathematics and the Rise of the West
(/isis/citation/CBB001560636/)
Article
Netz, Reviel;
(2009)
Imagination and Layered Ontology in Greek Mathematics
(/isis/citation/CBB001031502/)
Article
Franklin, Lee;
(2012)
Inventing Intermediates: Mathematical Discourse and Its Objects in Republic VII
(/isis/citation/CBB001211017/)
Thesis
Lacey, Duane J.;
(2007)
Euclid's Taxonomy of Irrationals
(/isis/citation/CBB001560851/)
Article
Knorr, Wilbur R.;
(2001)
The Impact of Modern Mathematics on Ancient Mathematics
(/isis/citation/CBB000770904/)
Thesis
Arsen, Hera Sharon;
(2009)
Was Plato a Mathematical Platonist? An Inquiry into the Nature of the Intermediates, Their Effects on Plato's Metaphysics, and Plato's Resulting Mathematical Ontology
(/isis/citation/CBB001562854/)
Chapter
Renato Migliorato;
(2016)
Il paradigma euclideo e la sua eclissi
(/isis/citation/CBB149906738/)
Article
C. K. Raju;
(2017)
Black Thoughts Matter: Decolonized Math, Academic Censorship, and the “Pythagorean” Proposition
(/isis/citation/CBB866727744/)
Book
Archimedes, ;
(2004)
The Works of Archimedes: Translated into English Together with Eutocius' Commentaries, with Commentary and Critical Edition of the Diagrams, Vol. 1
(/isis/citation/CBB000640054/)
Article
Nikolantonakis, Konstantinos;
(2007)
The Treatise “On the Section of a Cylinder” of Serenus of Antinoeia and the Apollonian Tradition
(/isis/citation/CBB000933151/)
Article
Webster, Colin;
(2014)
Euclid's Optics and Geometrical Astronomy
(/isis/citation/CBB001451440/)
Thesis
La Nave, Federica;
(2005)
Belief Without Proof from Ancient Geometry to Renaissance Algebra
(/isis/citation/CBB001560809/)
Book
Apollonius, ;
(2002)
Apollonius's Conics Book IV
(/isis/citation/CBB000203100/)
Book
Euclid, ;
Taisbak, Christian Marinus;
(2003)
Dedomena---Euclid's Data, or, The Importance of Being Given
(/isis/citation/CBB000301663/)
Be the first to comment!