IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB866460053

Frederick Antal and the Marxist challenge to art history (2022)

Jim Berryman (Author)

History of the Human Sciences
Volume: 35
Issue: 2
Pages: 55-76

URI: https://doi.org/10.1177/09526951211003779

DOI: 10.1177/09526951211003779

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

First published in 1948, Frederick Antal’s Florentine Painting and Its Social Background was an important milestone in anglophone art history. Based on European examples, including Max Dvořák, it sought to understand art history’s relationship to social and intellectual history. When Antal, a Hungarian émigré, arrived in Britain in 1933, he encountered an inward-looking discipline preoccupied with formalism and connoisseurship; or, as he phrased it, art historians of ‘the older persuasion’ ignorant of ‘the fruitful achievements of modern historical research’. Despite its considerable scholarship and erudition, Antal’s book was not warmly received, largely because he had used historical materialism to understand the production of art and the development of styles. Antal’s class-based account of the social position of the artist and the role of the patron in determining the emergence of early Renaissance styles was especially controversial. However, although Marxist analysis was used to challenge the assumptions of Anglo art history, it was not Antal’s intention to weaken art history’s disciplinary autonomy. With historical materialism, he sought to place art history on a firmer historical footing. Most importantly, this approach was compatible with the discipline’s Central European tradition, where art-historical scholarship was framed by questions of method and based on broad historical research. Without defending its more deterministic features, this article supports a re-evaluation of Antal’s book, as an important forerunner of interdisciplinary art scholarship. It considers why Antal’s legacy has not endured, despite the ‘social history of art’ enjoying widespread acceptance in English-speaking art history in later decades.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB866460053/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Roberts, Edwin A.; (2005)
From the History of Science to the Science of History: Scientists and Historians in the Shaping of British Marxist Theory (/isis/citation/CBB000740709/)

Article George Steinmetz; (2017)
Field Theory and Interdisciplinarity: History and Sociology in Germany and France during the Twentieth Century (/isis/citation/CBB032197060/)

Article Nolan, Paul; (2006)
Why G. A. Cohen Can't Appeal to Charles Darwin to Help Him Defend Karl Marx (But Why Others Can) (/isis/citation/CBB000670011/)

Article Konstantin A. Tomilin; (2019)
Physicists and Philosophers in Discussions around the Theory of Relativity (/isis/citation/CBB972709839/)

Article John L. Heilbron; (2019)
History of Science or History of Learning (/isis/citation/CBB138652234/)

Article Patrick Gautier Dalché; (2015)
Géographie et histoire à la fin du Moyen Âge: Paulin de Venise et Pietro Ranzano (/isis/citation/CBB794257216/)

Article Roth, Randolph; (2014)
Emotions, Facultative Adaptation, and the History of Homicide (/isis/citation/CBB001452053/)

Book Jennifer Bonnell; Sean Kheraj; (2022)
Traces of the Animal Past: Methodological Challenges in Animal History (/isis/citation/CBB752262749/)

Article Frederica Bowcutt; Tamara Caulkins; (2020)
Co-teaching Botany and History: An Interdisciplinary Model for a More Inclusive Curriculum (/isis/citation/CBB918944672/)

Article Thomas, Julia Adeney; (2014)
History and Biology in the Anthropocene: Problems of Scale, Problems of Value (/isis/citation/CBB001452057/)

Article Giacomo Bonan; (2023)
Hydraulic Engineers and Antiquarians: Political Use of the Past in Nineteenth-Century Venice (/isis/citation/CBB400582508/)

Chapter Ruth Watts; (2018)
Science and Public Understanding: The Role of the Historian of Education (/isis/citation/CBB981243094/)

Article Mark D. Hersey; Jeremy Vetter; (2019)
Shared Ground: Between Environmental History and the History of Science (/isis/citation/CBB491265753/)

Article Deborah R. Coen; Fredrik Albritton Jonsson; (2022)
Between History and Earth System Science (/isis/citation/CBB098579356/)

Article Jan Surman; (2021)
Productive marginalities: The history of science in/about Poland since 1989 (/isis/citation/CBB407601366/)

Book Gierl, Martin; (2012)
Geschichte als präzisierte Wissenschaft: Johann Christoph Gatterer und die Historiographie des 18. Jahrhunderts im ganzen Umfang (/isis/citation/CBB001214209/)

Article Hunt, Lynn; (2014)
The Self and Its History (/isis/citation/CBB001452056/)

Article Scheidel, Walter; (2014)
Evolutionary Psychology and the Historian (/isis/citation/CBB001452055/)

Article Gordin, Michael D.; (2014)
Evidence and the Instability of Biology (/isis/citation/CBB001452059/)

Article Daston, Lorraine J.; Most, Glenn W.; (2015)
History of Science and History of Philologies (/isis/citation/CBB001551437/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}