IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB860929378

Robustness and evidence of mechanisms in early experimental atherosclerosis research (2016)

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Volume: 60
Pages: 44-55

DOI: 10.1016/j.shpsc.2016.09.006

URI: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S136984861630070X

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Philosophy of medicine Public health Evidence Data analysis Causality Fats; oils; lipids Nutrition; dietetics Cardiovascular disease 20th century, early

This article considers the evaluation of experimental evidence for a causal relation between cholesterol and atherosclerosis from the beginning of the 1900s until the late 1950s. It has been argued that the medical community failed to see the implications of this early research, and at first unjustifiably rejected a causal link between cholesterol and atherosclerosis. This article argues to the contrary that the medical community was justified to conclude based on the experimental evidence that cholesterol (dietary or blood) is probably not an effective target for preventive treatment. However, the evidence would have been sufficient to ascribe to cholesterol a contributing causal role in atherosclerotic heart disease. This view is argued for based on a rational reconstruction of the researchers’ evaluation of evidence, specifically, the robustness of evidence for a manipulable dependence between cholesterol and atherosclerosis on the one hand, and the evidence for a mediating mechanism on the other. The case study is used to illustrate that robustness is a feasible methodological principle even when evidence is discordant, and evidence of mechanism should be evaluated on a par with evidence of statistical dependence in establishing causal claims.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB860929378/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Nicolas Rasmussen; (2018)
Group Weight Loss and Multiple Screening: A Tale of Two Heart Disease Programs in Postwar American Public Health (/isis/citation/CBB293285264/)

Book Christopher E. Forth; (2019)
Fat: A Cultural History of the Stuff of Life (/isis/citation/CBB439415836/)

Article La Berge, Ann F.; (2008)
How the Ideology of Low Fat Conquered America (/isis/citation/CBB000774475/)

Thesis Yoder, Cassady J.; (2006)
The Late Medieval Agrarian Crisis and Black Death Plague Epidemic in MedievalDenmark: A Paleopathological and Paleodietary Perspective (/isis/citation/CBB001561342/)

Article Maike Rotzoll; (2021)
Klinische „Erfahrung“ als Evidenzkriterium? Psychiatrische Beiträge zu einer Nachkriegsdebatte um eine „Reform der Medizin“ und die Entwicklung der „verstehenden Anthropologie“ Jürg Zutts (/isis/citation/CBB006650724/)

Book Broadbent, Alex; (2013)
Philosophy of Epidemiology (/isis/citation/CBB001420137/)

Article Hans-Georg Hofer; (2021)
Kausalität, Evidenz und Subjektivität: Paul Martinis Methodenkritik der Psychosomatischen Medizin (/isis/citation/CBB972861746/)

Article Saana Jukola; (2019)
On the evidentiary standards for nutrition advice (/isis/citation/CBB988050961/)

Article Yorgos Dimitriadis; (2020)
History of the opposition between psychogenesis and organogenesis in classic psychiatry: Part 1 (/isis/citation/CBB157647685/)

Book Wolters, Christine; (2011)
Tuberkulose und Menschenversuche im Nationalsozialismus: Das Netzwerk hinter den Tbc-Experimenten im Konzentrationslager Sachsenhausen (/isis/citation/CBB001202027/)

Book Andrew R. Ruis; (2017)
Eating to Learn, Learning to Eat: The Origins of School Lunch in the United States (/isis/citation/CBB039589050/)

Article Sookyeong Hong; (2018)
Scientizing Everyday Life, Rationalizing Eating Habits: The Rise of Nutrition Science in 1910s-1920s Japan (/isis/citation/CBB868771834/)

Article Sen, Srabani; (2005)
Dawn of Nutrition Research in India---Pre-Independence Era (/isis/citation/CBB000600469/)

Article Francisco J. Medina-Albaladejo; Salvador Calatayud; (2020)
Unequal access to food during the nutritional transition: evidence from Mediterranean Spain (/isis/citation/CBB944123660/)

Thesis Levine, Deborah I.; (2008)
Managing American Bodies: Diet, Nutrition, and Obesity in America, 1840--1920 (/isis/citation/CBB001561378/)

Article Ouédraogo, Arouna P.; (2001)
Food and the Purification of Society: Dr. Paul Carton and Vegetarianism in Interwar France (/isis/citation/CBB000770466/)

Book Charles S. Bryan; (2014)
Asylum Doctor: James Woods Babcock and the Red Plague of Pellagra (/isis/citation/CBB182088684/)

Article Anne Meneley; (2020)
The olive and imaginaries of the Mediterranean (/isis/citation/CBB941685489/)

Book Ton van Helvoort; Eric Berkers; Mila Davids; (2017)
Gesmeerde kennis: een halve eeuw geschiedenis van Unilevers Becel (/isis/citation/CBB766154976/)

Article (2000)
Experiment and Conceptual Change: Evidence, Data Generation, and Scientific Practice: Toward a Reliabilist Philosophy of Experiment (/isis/citation/CBB000110595/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}