IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB859295291

‘A woman and now a man’: The legitimation of sex-assignment surgery in the United States (1849–1886) (February 2022)

Maayan Sudai (Author)

Social Studies of Science
Volume: 52
Issue: 1
Pages: 79-105

DOI: 10.1177/03063127211056891

URI: https://doi.org/10.1177/03063127211056891

Outside Links

PubMed

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Law and legislation Surgery of sex organs; circumcision Medicine Technoscience; science and technology studies Gender Authorities; experts Controversies and disputes Sex Co-production Sex assignment surgery 20th century United States

Throughout much of recorded history, societies that assigned rights and duties based on sex were confounded by people with unclear sex. For the sake of maintaining social and legal order in those contexts, legal systems assigned these people to what they figured was the ‘most dominant’ sex. Then, in mid-19th century United States, a new classification mechanism emerged: sex-assignment surgery, which was imagined by some surgeons to ‘fix’ one’s physical and legal sex status permanently. Other surgeons, however, fiercely opposed the new practice. This article traces the controversy around sex-assignment surgery through three high-profile cases published in US medical journals from 1849 to 1886. Its central argument is that the more general effort to transform surgery into a scientific field helped legitimate the practice of sex-assignment surgery. Although such surgery was subject to intense moral criticism because it was thought to breach the laws of men and nature, over time, these concerns were abandoned or transformed into technical or professional disagreements. In a secondary argument, which helps explain that transformation, this article shows that surgeons gradually became comfortable occupying the epistemic role of sex-classifiers and even sex-makers. That is, whereas sex classification was traditionally a legal task, the new ability to surgically construct one’s genitals engendered the notion that sex could be determined and fixed in the clinic in a legally binding manner. Accordingly, I suggest that surgery became an epistemic act of fact-making. This evolution of the consensus around sex-assignment surgery also provides an early origin story for the idea of sex as plastic and malleable by surgeons, thus offering another aspect to the history of plastic sex.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB859295291/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Mary Frank Fox; Diana Roldan Rueda; Gerhard Sonnert; Amanda Nabors; Sarah Bartel; (2022)
Publications about Women, Science, and Engineering: Use of Sex and Gender in Titles over a Forty-six-year Period (/isis/citation/CBB872647702/)

Article Margaret E. MacDonald; (March 2021)
Misoprostol: The Social Life of a Life-saving Drug in Global Maternal Health (/isis/citation/CBB680292467/)

Article Ina Linge; (2021)
The Potency of the Butterfly: The Reception of Richard B. Goldschmidt’s Animal Experiments in German Sexology Around 1920 (/isis/citation/CBB132149292/)

Article Madeleine Pape; (June 2021)
Co-production, multiplied: Enactments of sex as a biological variable in US biomedicine (/isis/citation/CBB034212602/)

Book Forth, Christopher E.; Crozier, Ivan; (2005)
Body Parts: Critical Explorations in Corporeality (/isis/citation/CBB000820036/)

Article Angela N. H. Creager; (September 2021)
To Test or Not to Test: Tools, Rules, and Corporate Data in US Chemicals Regulation (/isis/citation/CBB745420064/)

Article Sarah Bull; (2017)
Managing the "Obscene M.D.": Medical Publishing, the Medical Profession, and the Changing Definition of Obscenity in Mid-Victorian England (/isis/citation/CBB733047362/)

Book stef m shuster; (2021)
Trans Medicine: The Emergence and Practice of Treating Gender (/isis/citation/CBB911591244/)

Article Tiago Moreira; (February 2019)
Devicing future populations: Problematizing the relationship between quantity and quality of life (/isis/citation/CBB372738873/)

Book Richard Cleminson; Francisco Vázquez García; (2018)
Sexo, identidad y hermafroditas en el mundo ibérico, 1500-1800 (/isis/citation/CBB870906851/)

Book Greene, Jeremy A.; Watkins, Elizabeth Siegel; (2012)
Prescribed: Writing, Filling, Using, and Abusing the Prescription in Modern America (/isis/citation/CBB001214574/)

Book Johnson, David A.; Chaudhry, Humayun J.; (2012)
Medical Licensing and Discipline in America: A History of the Federation of State Medical Boards (/isis/citation/CBB001420162/)

Article Peter Mandler; (2019)
The Language of Social Science in Everyday Life (/isis/citation/CBB618184205/)

Article Boel Berner; Maria Björkman; (July 2017)
Modernizing the flow of blood: Biomedical technicians, working knowledge and the transformation of Swedish blood centre practices (/isis/citation/CBB596544906/)

Article Rodriguez, Sarah W.; (2008)
Rethinking the History of Female Circumcision and Clitoridectomy: American Medicine and Female Sexuality in the Late Nineteenth Century (/isis/citation/CBB000930401/)

Article Vivian Yurdakul; (2021)
Ein Scharnier zwischen Eugenik und Recht – der „medizinisch-juristische“ Kommentar im „Dritten Reich“ (/isis/citation/CBB563139806/)

Article Poliak, Daniel B.; (2013)
Ritual Circumcision in the Age of Germ Theory amongst Nineteenth-Century New York Immigrants (/isis/citation/CBB001320604/)

Article Aliakbar Akbaritabar; Flaminio Squazzoni; (May 2021)
Gender Patterns of Publication in Top Sociological Journals (/isis/citation/CBB721191179/)

Article John Carson; (December 2018)
‘Every Expression is Watched’: Mind, Medical Expertise and Display in the Nineteenth-century English Courtroom (/isis/citation/CBB111652964/)

Article Jacqueline H. Wolf; (2021)
“They said her heart was in distress”: The Electronic Fetal Monitor and the Experience of Birth in the U.S.A., 1960s to the Present (/isis/citation/CBB006891858/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}