The dichotomy between ‘typological thinking’ and ‘population thinking’ features in a range of debates in contemporary and historical biology. The origins of this dichotomy are often traced to Ernst Mayr, who is said to have coined it in the 1950s as a rhetorical device that could be used to shield the Modern Synthesis from attacks by the opponents of population biology. In this two-part essay I argue that the origins of the typology/population dichotomy are considerably more complicated and more interesting than is commonly thought. In this first part, I will argue that Mayr's dichotomy was based on two distinct type/population contrasts that had been articulated much earlier by George Gaylord Simpson and Theodosius Dobzhansky. Their distinctions made eminent sense in their own, isolated contexts. In the second part, I will show how Mayr conflated these type/population distinctions and blended in some of his own, unrelated concerns with ‘types’ of a rather different sort. Although Mayr told his early critics that he was merely making “a temporary oversimplification,” he ended up burdening the history and philosophy of biology with a troubled dichotomy.
...More
Article
Joeri Witteveen;
(2016)
“A temporary oversimplification”: Mayr, Simpson, Dobzhansky, and the origins of the typology/population dichotomy (part 2 of 2)
(/isis/citation/CBB755950039/)
Article
Milam, Erika Lorraine;
(2010)
The Equally Wonderful Field: Ernst Mayr and Organismic Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB001022608/)
Article
Mallet, James;
(2010)
Why Was Darwin's View of Species Rejected by Twentieth Century Biologists?
(/isis/citation/CBB001252809/)
Book
Brush, Stephen G.;
(2009)
Choosing Selection: The Revival of Natural Selection in Anglo-American Evolutionary Biology, 1930--1970
(/isis/citation/CBB001020903/)
Article
Magnus, David;
(1996)
Theory, practice, and epistemology in the development of species concepts
(/isis/citation/CBB000072276/)
Chapter
Thompson, Paul;
(2000)
“Organization,” “Population,” and Mayr's Rejection of Essentialism in Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB000410688/)
Article
Cain, Joe;
(2002)
Epistemic and Community Transition in American Evolutionary Studies: The “Committee on Common Problems of Genetics, Paleontology, and Systematics” (1942--1949)
(/isis/citation/CBB000202895/)
Essay Review
Smocovitis, Vassiliki Betty;
(2002)
The Darwin Adventure Continues
(/isis/citation/CBB000203383/)
Article
Delisle, Richard G.;
(2011)
What Was Really Synthesized during the Evolutionary Synthesis? A Historiographic Proposal
(/isis/citation/CBB001023986/)
Book
Ceccarelli, Leah;
(2001)
Shaping Science with Rhetoric: The Cases of Dobzhansky, Schrödinger, and Wilson
(/isis/citation/CBB000330248/)
Article
Cohen, Michael P.;
(2010)
Evolutionary Works and Texts: Reading Dobzhansky in an Age of Genomics
(/isis/citation/CBB001023614/)
Book
Novitski, Edward;
Sturtevant, A. H.;
Dobzhansky, Theodosius Grigorievich;
(2005)
Sturtevant and Dobzhansky, Two Scientists at Odds: With a Student's Recollections
(/isis/citation/CBB000671258/)
Article
Ehud Lamm;
(2015)
Systems Thinking Versus Population Thinking: Genotype Integration and Chromosomal Organization 1930s–1950s
(/isis/citation/CBB251564596/)
Book
Laporte, Léo F.;
(2000)
George Gaylord Simpson. Paleontologist and Evolutionist
(/isis/citation/CBB000100395/)
Article
Junker, Thomas;
(2007)
Ernst Mayr (1904--2005) and the New Philosophy of Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB001230073/)
Article
Li, Jianhui;
(2009)
What Does Evolutionary Science Provide for Contemporary Philosophy? On Ernst Mayr's “New Philosophy of Biology”
(/isis/citation/CBB001024104/)
Article
Glick, Thomas F.;
(2008)
O Programa Brasileiro de genética evolucionária de populações, de Theodosius Dobzhansky
(/isis/citation/CBB001035151/)
Chapter
Burian, Richard M.;
(2007)
“Nothing in Biology Makes Sense Except in the Light of Evolution” (Theodosius Dobzhansky)
(/isis/citation/CBB001022514/)
Essay Review
Smocovitis, Vassiliki Betty;
(1999)
The Tormenting Desire for Unity
(/isis/citation/CBB000110345/)
Book
Kolchinskii, Eduard I.;
(2006)
Ernst Mayr i sovremennyi evoliutzionnyi sintez. Serija: Vydajuscthijesja biologi-evoliutzionisty
(/isis/citation/CBB000800190/)
Be the first to comment!