Magnetismus und Theamedismus. Eine Fallstudie zur Kenntnis der magnetischen Abstoßung in der Naturkunde der Frühen Neuzeit (2017)
Sander, Christoph (Author)
Sudhoffs Archiv: Zeitschrift fuer Wissenschaftsgeschichte
Volume: 101
Issue: 1
Pages: 42-72
Since antiquity scholars know that magnets attract iron. However, most ancient or medieval scholars were hardly interested in the matter of magnetic repulsion, and if so, repulsion was mostly related to another stone or kind of magnet. In Pliny's Natural History this type of a repulsive magnet was identified as a stone that was considered to repel iron only. Pliny or his source Sotacus called this stone "theamedes". In the sixteenth century this stone became increasingly important in science and was widely discovered, described, discussed and explained. The fact of magnetic bipolarity was accounted for by assuming that a magnet and a "theamedes" were combined in one stone. In Andreas Libavius's alchemy the term "theamedism" was even associated with "magnetism" to refer to antipathy and sympathy in general. Yet, from the later sixteenth century onwards, several authors such as Gerolamo Cardano, Michele Mercati, Leonardo Garzoni, Giambattista della Porta, or William Gilbert denied the very existence of the "theamedes" as they considered all magnets to attract and to repel iron. Tracing back the appearance of the "theamedes" in early-modern sources, which is the subject of the case study at hand, not only enriches the historical understanding of magnetic phenomena. More importantly, this case study urges historians of science to reflect on the historical instability and contingency of notions relating to natural kinds. The magnet's essential features of attraction and repulsion (bipolarity) were hardly or rarely met by the notion of 'magnet' in the early-modern period. In turn, from the modern point of view the "theamedes" does not seem to refer to any mineral at all, and yet is related to a well known physical phenomenon, i.e. magnetic repulsion.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Daniele Monacchini;
(2012)
Plinio: alcune sostanze medicinali da minerali e pietre preziose
(/isis/citation/CBB869872384/)
Book
Christopher Partridge;
(2014)
The Occult World
(/isis/citation/CBB544694972/)
Article
Matteo Martelli;
(2020)
A Syriac epitome of Galens’ On Simple Drugs, books 9-11: text and translation
(/isis/citation/CBB745453779/)
Article
Chiara Ballestrazzi;
(2023)
The colours of gemstones in Pliny the Elder's Natural History, Book 37
(/isis/citation/CBB673159034/)
Book
Thorsten Fögen;
(2009)
Wissen, Kommunikation und Selbstdarstellung: Zur Struktur und Charakteristik römischer Fachtexte der frühen Kaiserzeit
(/isis/citation/CBB412760109/)
Article
Arsenio Ferraces Rodríguez;
(2012)
El texto de Plinio y la tradición indirecta tardoantigua. 1. Recuperación de una lectura auténtica: Suillum (Nat. 28, 130) 2. Dos conjecturas de Detlefsen confirmadas: maxillam (nat. 28, 115), taurinum (nat. 28, 174)
(/isis/citation/CBB607205436/)
Article
Livia Radici;
(2018)
Saliva, porpore e vino in Plinio
(/isis/citation/CBB089021241/)
Article
Isabel Barton;
(2022)
Mining, alchemy, and the changing concept of minerals from antiquity to early modernity
(/isis/citation/CBB224295091/)
Book
Salvatore Califano;
(2015)
Storia dell'alchimia: misticismo ed esoterismo all'origine della chimica moderna
(/isis/citation/CBB559415425/)
Article
Daniela Cavallo;
(2020)
"Trini colores, candidus primo, mox rubens, maturis niger" (Nat. 15, 97). Alberi, colori, medicina: Suggestioni dai libri 15 e 23 della Naturalis Historia di Plinio il Vecchio
(/isis/citation/CBB358631200/)
Article
Agnès Rouveret;
(2023)
Certamen artis ac naturae. Couleurs et matières dans la définition plinienne de la peinture (Histoire naturelle, livre 35)
(/isis/citation/CBB984443082/)
Book
Domenico Carro;
(2021)
Quadriremi vs. Vesuvio. L'operazione navale di soccorso condotta da Plinio nel 79 D.C.
(/isis/citation/CBB212703608/)
Article
Pierre Schneider;
(2012)
Les «climats» de Pline l’Ancien (N.H. 6, 212-220): essais de transcriptions graphiques
(/isis/citation/CBB554032321/)
Article
Klaus Geus;
(2018)
Le misurazioni delle Alpi nell’antichità: l’esempio di Plinio
(/isis/citation/CBB762928153/)
Article
David Leith;
(2019)
Asclepiades’ Therapeutics in the Elder Pliny
(/isis/citation/CBB636462422/)
Article
Klaus-Dietrich Fischer;
(2019)
Einigermassen durchsichtig. Überlegungen zu einer Stelle in Galens Schrift Über die einfachen Heilmittel
(/isis/citation/CBB724005564/)
Book
Soukup, R. Werner;
(2007)
Chemie in Österreich. Von den Anfängen bis zum Ende des 18. Jahrhunderts. Bergbau, Alchemie und frühe Chemie. Geschichte der frühen chemischen Technologie und Alchemie des ostalpinen Raumes unter Berücksichtigung von Entwicklungen in angrenzenden Regionen
(/isis/citation/CBB000850654/)
Article
Francesco Luzzini;
(2020)
Sounding the depths of Providence: Mineral (re)generation and human-environment interaction in the early modern period
(/isis/citation/CBB187063360/)
Book
McHam, Sarah Blake;
(2013)
Pliny and the Artistic Culture of the Italian Renaissance: The Legacy of the “Natural History”
(/isis/citation/CBB001201669/)
Chapter
Enenkel, Karl;
(2014)
Die antike Vorgeschichte der Verankerung der Naturgeschichte in Politik und Religion: Plinius` Zoologie und der römische Imperialismus
(/isis/citation/CBB001552962/)
Be the first to comment!