What Is the Spatiotemporal Extension of the Universe? Underdetermination according to Kant’s First Antinomy and in Present-Day Cosmology (2022)
In his Critique of Pure Reason, in the chapter on the antinomy of pure reason, Kant not only argues that aprioristic cosmology is doomed to failure; he also implies that empirical knowledge about the universe is impossible. Today, such a negative verdict about the possibility of cosmological knowledge seems implausible because physical cosmology has made substantial progress. In particular, the spatiotemporal extension of the universe now seems a matter of empirical investigation in which models figure centrally. But I think it is worth considering the possibility that Kant got something right and that he offers insights that can help us to better understand problems in present-day cosmology. In this article, I explore a striking coincidence: according to both Kant and current wisdom, cosmology faces a serious underdetermination problem regarding the spatiotemporal extension of the world. As a closer analysis reveals, however, Kant and modern cosmology differ on the reasons why underdetermination arises. In current cosmology, underdetermination follows from laws that are knowable a posteriori, and not only from the very idea of cosmological knowledge, as Kant would have it. This suggests that the current underdetermination problem is not fully a Kantian one.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Gaukroger, Stephen W.;
Dalia Nassar;
(2016)
Introduction: Kant and the Empirical Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB037609114/)
Article
Stephen Howard;
(2022)
From the Boundary of the World to the Boundary of Reason: The First Antinomy and the Development of Kant’s Critical Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB830722956/)
Chapter
Mauro Stenico;
(2015)
Mundus est fabula: la cosmologia e i grandi interrogativi
(/isis/citation/CBB234454455/)
Article
Silvia De Bianchi;
(2022)
Kant’s Functional Cosmology: Teleology, Measurement, and Symbolic Representation in the Critique of Judgment
(/isis/citation/CBB510519330/)
Article
Jurkowitz, Edward;
(2010)
Helmholtz's Early Empiricism and the Erhaltung der Kraft
(/isis/citation/CBB000953438/)
Article
Biagioli, Francesca;
(2014)
Hermann Cohen and Alois Riehl on Geometrical Empiricism
(/isis/citation/CBB001421705/)
Article
Cohen, Alix A.;
(2008)
Kantian Philosophy and the Human Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB000931150/)
Article
Verena Lehmbrock;
(2016)
Zur Geschichte einer Metakategorie: Das ‚Empirische‘ in der deutschen Ökonomischen Aufklärung und frühen Agrarwissenschaft um 1800
(/isis/citation/CBB380540897/)
Article
Andrew Cooper;
(2017)
Kant and Experimental Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB741692479/)
Book
Anja Jauernig;
(2021)
The World According to Kant: Appearances and Things in Themselves in Critical Idealism
(/isis/citation/CBB780921269/)
Article
Guyer, Paul;
(2008)
The Psychology of Kant's Aesthetics
(/isis/citation/CBB000931153/)
Book
Catherine Wilson;
(2022)
Kant and the Naturalistic Turn of 18th Century Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB775333088/)
Article
Frierson, Patrick;
(2008)
Empirical Psychology, Common Sense, and Kant's Empirical Markers for Moral Responsibility
(/isis/citation/CBB000931152/)
Book
Waxman, Wayne;
(2014)
Kant's Anatomy of the Intelligent Mind
(/isis/citation/CBB001421736/)
Article
Schmidt, Claudia M.;
(2008)
Kant's Transcendental and Empirical Psychology of Cognition
(/isis/citation/CBB000931151/)
Article
Sturm, Thomas;
(2008)
Why Did Kant Reject Physiological Explanations in His Anthropology?
(/isis/citation/CBB000931154/)
Article
Gray, Sally Hatch;
(2012)
Kant's Race Theory, Forster's Counter, and the Metaphysics of Color
(/isis/citation/CBB001201887/)
Chapter
Daston, Lorraine;
(2010)
The Empire of Observation, 1600--1800
(/isis/citation/CBB001221449/)
Article
Bednarczyk, A.;
(2006)
Alexander von Humboldt and General Methods of Scientific Cognition
(/isis/citation/CBB000931648/)
Article
Tinca Prunea-Bretonnet;
(2019)
From the Folds of the Rhino to the 'Hand of Nature': Maupertuis's Essay on Cosmology and its Reception in the 1750s
(/isis/citation/CBB952950350/)
Be the first to comment!