Lady Lovelace’s Objection: The Turing–Hartree Disputes Over the Meaning of Digital Computers, 1946–1951 (2024)
Gonçalves, Bernardo (Author)
IEEE Annals of the History of Computing
Volume: 46
Issue: 01
Pages: 6-18
Can machines think? Or can they do “whatever we know how to order” them to perform? Should machines be liberated from slavery and given “fair play” to “compete with men in all purely intellectual fields”? Or should this be associated with a fashion that decries “human reason” and a path that “leads straight to Nazism”? In the postwar years, these questions were debated by Alan Turing and Douglas Hartree, who differed in their interpretations of the digital computer as a new piece of science and technology. Hartree emphasized its unprecedented calculation speed and envisioned applications in physics, logistics, energy, and warfare. Turing, who envisioned applications in biology and cognition, emphasized its potential to outperform humans intellectually, including capabilities considered distinctly human, which Hartree downplayed by mobilizing the notes of Ada Lovelace. This article examines the Turing–Hartree disputes and draws a parallel between their positions and their perspectives on postwar Britain.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
B. Jack Copeland;
(2023)
Early AI in Britain: Turing et al.
(/isis/citation/CBB767131455/)
Book
Ethem Alpaydın;
(2021)
Machine Learning
(/isis/citation/CBB513990166/)
Book
Roberto Pieraccini;
(2021)
AI Assistants
(/isis/citation/CBB406160431/)
Book
Mark Coeckelbergh;
(2020)
AI Ethics
(/isis/citation/CBB990965100/)
Thesis
Aaron Louis Mendon-Plasek;
(2022)
Genealogies of Machine Learning, 1950-1995
(/isis/citation/CBB023700499/)
Book
Hodges, Andrew;
(2000)
Alan Turing: the Enigma
(/isis/citation/CBB000110152/)
Article
Copeland, B. Jack;
Proudfoot, Diane;
(2011-2012)
Alan Turing, Father of the Modern Computer
(/isis/citation/CBB001210378/)
Article
Hodges, Andrew;
(2012)
Beyond Turing's Machines
(/isis/citation/CBB001320475/)
Book
Lavington, S. H.;
Campbell-Kelly, Martin;
(2012)
Alan Turing and His Contemporaries: Building the World's First Computers
(/isis/citation/CBB001251446/)
Book
Turing, Sara;
(2012)
Alan M. Turing
(/isis/citation/CBB001251444/)
Book
Copeland, B. Jack;
(2012)
Turing: Pioneer of the Information Age
(/isis/citation/CBB001253045/)
Article
Asaro, Peter;
(2008)
Computer als Modelle des Geistes. Über Simulation und das Gehirn als Modell des Designs von Computern
(/isis/citation/CBB001032251/)
Article
McCullough, Philip Murray;
(2010)
Otto in the Chinese Room
(/isis/citation/CBB001023796/)
Article
Barbara Ainsworth;
(2023)
Trevor Pearcey and the Development of CSIRAC—An Australian First-Generation Computer
(/isis/citation/CBB869994431/)
Article
Alexandra Luccioni;
Yoshua Bengio;
(March 2020)
On the Morality of Artificial Intelligence [Commentary]
(/isis/citation/CBB318875873/)
Article
Peter M. Asaro;
(June 2019)
AI Ethics in Predictive Policing: From Models of Threat to an Ethics of Care
(/isis/citation/CBB655687648/)
Article
Blanco, Jairo Ares;
Puentes, Eduard Aibar;
(2011)
The Evolution of P2P Networks for File Exchange: The Interaction between Social Controversy and Technical Change
(/isis/citation/CBB001212080/)
Book
B. Jack Copeland;
Carl J. Posy;
Oron Shagrir;
(2015)
Computability: Turing, Gödel, Church, and Beyond
(/isis/citation/CBB900019272/)
Book
Daylight, Edgar G.;
Grave, Kurt De;
(2012)
The Dawn of Software Engineering: From Turing to Dijkstra
(/isis/citation/CBB001214448/)
Book
Davis, Martin;
(2000)
The Universal Computer: The Road from Leibniz to Turing
(/isis/citation/CBB000102163/)
Be the first to comment!