Galileo’s Letter to the Grand Duchess Christina: Genre, Coherence, and the Structure of Dispute (2019)
This paper proposes a reading of Galileo's "Letter to the Grand Duchess Christina" as analogous to a legal brief submitted to a court en banc. The Letter develops a theory of the general issues underlying the case at hand, but it is organized around advocacy for a particular judgment. I have drawn two architectonic implications from this framework, each of which helps to resolve an issue still standing in the literature. First, the Letter anticipates varying degrees of acquiescence to its general account, and provides hooks for different readers to interpret variously while still converging on the particular judgment. This reading allows for a coherent Galilean interpretation of passages that notoriously concede priority to Scripture, while also explaining their dialectical function. Galileo is neither self-contradictory nor dissimulating here, but strategically leaves the specification of key distinctions for the reader. Second, the Letter, and particularly its apparent shifting of the burden of proof, must be understood in light of the tripartite adversarial-judicial framework that Galileo sets up. The burden of proof is shifted to anti-Copernicans within the Church, not as a rhetorical trick, but because of the benefits of adversarial procedure that will accrue to the Church as the responsible judge.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Luigi Guerrini;
(2004)
Momenti poco noti del dibattito intorno al "Dialogo dei massimi sistemi del mondo"
(/isis/citation/CBB959940502/)
Article
Francesco Beretta;
(2003)
Une deuxième abjuration de Galilée ou l'inaltérable hiérarchie des disciplines
(/isis/citation/CBB537954207/)
Thesis
Sugar, Gabrielle;
(2012)
The New Universe: Conceptions of the Cosmos in the Literary Imagination of Early Modern England
(/isis/citation/CBB001567357/)
Chapter
Ivana Gambaro;
(2016)
Sulla natura dei corpi celesti: Una disputa secentesca nell’ambiente scientifico italiano
(/isis/citation/CBB869829992/)
Book
Maurizio Torrini;
(2021)
Galileo nel Tempo
(/isis/citation/CBB428854625/)
Article
Lucia Bucciarelli;
(2019)
Back to Battle: The Latin Edition of the Dialogue and of the Letter to Christina (1635-1636)
(/isis/citation/CBB276203751/)
Chapter
Natacha Fabbri;
(2018)
Threats to the Christian Cosmos. The Reckless Assault on the Heavens and the Debate over Hell
(/isis/citation/CBB276297939/)
Book
Natacha Fabbri;
Federica Favino;
(2018)
Copernicus Banned: The Entangled Matter of the anti-Copernican Decree of 1616
(/isis/citation/CBB869881150/)
Article
Nunzio Allocca;
(2014)
La luna e il libro della natura. Su Italo Calvino e l’eredità di Galileo
(/isis/citation/CBB365165189/)
Article
Germana Ernst;
(2017)
"Maculae Galilei me perplexum habent". Campanella, le macchie solari e la tentazione pitagorica
(/isis/citation/CBB065561241/)
Article
Stéphane Garcia;
(2003)
L'image de Galilée ou la trajectoire symbolique du portrait de 1635
(/isis/citation/CBB153088007/)
Article
Leonardo Anatrini;
(2020)
The Theologian's Endgame. On the Recently Discovered Censorial Report on Galileo's Dialogue and Related Documents
(/isis/citation/CBB203595316/)
Book
Finocchiaro, Maurice A;
(2010)
Defending Copernicus and Galileo: Critical Reasoning in the Two Affairs
(/isis/citation/CBB001023120/)
Book
Anna De Pace;
(2020)
Galileo lettore di Copernico
(/isis/citation/CBB163414161/)
Article
Manuel Bertolini;
(2016)
La Ruota Armonica: pitagorismo e scienza moderna in Federico Borromeo
(/isis/citation/CBB299301022/)
Chapter
Maurizio Torrini;
(2012)
Il Rinascimento nell'orizzonte della nuova scienza
(/isis/citation/CBB652466176/)
Chapter
Giovanni Pizzorusso;
(2018)
Francesco Ingoli: Knowledge and Curial Service in 17th-century Rome
(/isis/citation/CBB016792772/)
Essay Review
Chiara Protasi;
(2014)
Gli anni dell'incertezza e delle contraddizioni: dal Concilio Vaticano II alla Commissione di Studio Galileiana
(/isis/citation/CBB280989062/)
Essay Review
Franco Giudice;
(2007)
Only a Matter of Credit? Galileo, the Telescopic Discoveries, and the Copernican System
(/isis/citation/CBB386449739/)
Article
Salvatore Ricciardo;
(2020)
The «greate Star-gazer Galileo» in mid-seventeenth-century England: the case of Robert Boyle
(/isis/citation/CBB858495549/)
Be the first to comment!