Neelakantan, Vivek (Author)
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Volume: 114
Issue: S1
Pages: S419-S446
Edition Details: IsisCB Special Issue: Bibliographic Essays on the History of Pandemics
Language: English
Between 1983 and 2006 there were two distinct sorts of historical writings on Southeast Asian medical history, with quite different emphases. Some historians focused on the history of medicine in national contexts—a practice that resulted in the neglect of larger socioeconomic factors such as migration—that affected the trajectory of pandemics. At the same time, pursuing a different line of thinking, another group of historians focused on the history of specific diseases from a demographic perspective. These two approaches led to very different conclusions about the nature of epidemic disease and pandemics that have beset the region since the nineteenth century. Nevertheless, regional histories of health are neglected in Southeast Asian medical history in favor of either local, national, or global histories. In this essay, I argue that if historians of global health have forsaken the region in favor of the wider world, Southeast Asian historians have neglected the region in favor of the nation. What is missing in Southeast Asian medical history is a regional perspective that would help understand the ways in which pandemic responses are shaped by colonial, Cold War, or national concerns. Beginning 2019, some historians and political analysts trying to understand global pandemics have adopted a regional approach by treating, as a monolithic group, the ASEAN—the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, which is a regional grouping of Southeast Asian member states, established in 1967. By contrast, others explore specific geographic, political, or economic issues that have contributed to either the spread or containment of disease. In this regard, the COVID-19 crisis in Southeast Asia merits historical attention to comprehend the strengths and weaknesses of a regional approach.
...MoreDescription Part of a series of bibliographical essays on the history of pandemics and epidemics in the history of science. The link to the essay takes you to the page with the essay, the bibliography, and the entire set of reviews.
Article Weldon, Stephen P.; Sankaran, Neeraja (2023) Scholarship in the Time of COVID-19: An Introduction to the IsisCB Special Issue on Pandemics. Isis Bibliography of the History of Science (pp. 1-5).
Similar Citations
Chapter
Mary Wilson;
(2014)
Epidemic Disease in Modern and Contemporary Southeast Asia
Chapter
Sunil Amrith;
(2014)
The Internationalization of Health in Southeast Asia
Chapter
Kirsty Walker;
(2014)
The Influenza Pandemic of 1918 in Southeast Asia
Article
Saumitra Basu;
(2023)
Mountains of corpses: the deadliest attack of the 1918–19 influenza pandemic in the city of Calcutta
Article
Heiner Fangerau;
Ulrich Koppitz;
Alfons Labisch;
(2023)
A Survey of Historical Works on Pandemics in the German Language
Article
Maria Conforti;
(2023)
History of Epidemics: A Bibliographical Essay on Secondary Sources in Italian and on Italy
Article
Matheus Alves Duarte Da Silva;
Jules Alexander Skotnes Brown;
(2023)
Emerging Infectious Diseases and Disease Emergence: Critical, Ontological and Epistemological Approaches
Article
Lukas Engelmann;
(2023)
Coinfection, Comorbidity, and Syndemics: On the Edges of Epidemic Historiography
Article
Mark Honigsbaum;
(2023)
The “Spanish” Flu and the Pandemic Imaginary
Article
Dora Vargha;
Imogen Wilkins;
(2023)
Vaccination and Pandemics
Article
James Stark;
(2023)
Making Microbes: Theorizing the Invisible in Historical Scholarship
Article
Arnab Chakraborty;
(2023)
COVID-19 Response in South Asia: Case Studies from India, Sri Lanka, and Pakistan
Article
José Ragas;
(2023)
History of Pandemics in Latin America
Article
Rebecca Flemming;
(2023)
Pandemics in the Ancient Mediterranean World
Article
Valentina Parisi;
Kavita Sivaramakrishnan;
(2023)
The Limits of Linearity: Recasting Histories of Epidemics in the Global South
Article
Barbara C. Canavan;
(2023)
Historical Literature Related to Zoonoses and Pandemics
Article
Monica Green;
(2021)
Global Health in a Semi-Globalized World: History of Infectious Diseases in the Medieval Period
Article
Reiko Kanazawa;
(2023)
Pandemic Responses and the Strengths of Health Systems: A Review of Global AIDS Historiography in Light of COVID-19
Article
Robert Peckham;
Mei Li;
(2023)
Epidemic Histories in East Asia
Article
Nükhet Varlık;
(2023)
Plague in the Mediterranean and Islamicate World
Be the first to comment!