Charles Darwin and C. Lloyd Morgan forward two influential principles of cognitive ethological inference that yield conflicting results about the extent of continuity in the cognitive traits of humans and other animals. While these principles have been interpreted as reflecting commitments to different senses of parsimony, in fact, both principles result from the same vera causa inferential strategy, according to which “We ought to admit no more causes of natural things, than such as are both true and sufficient to explain their appearances”. Instead, the conflict stems from Darwin's and Morgan's views about the true causes of human psychology. Darwin holds a thoroughly Humean philosophy of the human mind, from which he infers significant continuity between human and animal minds. In contrast, Morgan argues that Humean cognitive mechanisms cannot account for a class of uniquely human behaviors, and therefore, he concludes that there is a significant discontinuity between human and animal cognition. This historical debate is informative for current controversies in comparative psychology.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Radick, Gregory;
(2000)
Morgan's canon, Garner's phonograph, and the evolutionary origins of language and reason
(/isis/citation/CBB000110654/)
Article
Martin Böhnert;
Christopher Hilbert;
(2018)
“Other Minds Than Ours”: A Controversial Discussion on the Limits and Possibilities of Comparative Psychology in the Light of C. Lloyd Morgan’s Work
(/isis/citation/CBB683159575/)
Article
Costall, Alan;
(1993)
How Lloyd Morgan's Canon backfired
(/isis/citation/CBB000031320/)
Article
Evan Arnet;
(2019)
Conwy Lloyd Morgan, Methodology, and the Origins of Comparative Psychology
(/isis/citation/CBB156167583/)
Article
Simon Fitzpatrick;
Grant Goodrich;
(2017)
Building a Science of Animal Minds: Lloyd Morgan, Experimentation, and Morgan’s Canon
(/isis/citation/CBB668591367/)
Article
Richards, Robert J.;
(1977)
Lloyd Morgan's theory of instinct: From Darwinism to neo-Darwinism
(/isis/citation/CBB000026082/)
Chapter
Sober, Elliott;
(2005)
Comparative Psychology Meets Evolutionary Biology: Morgan's Canon and Cladistic Parsimony
(/isis/citation/CBB000772880/)
Article
Wassmann, Claudia;
(2009)
Physiological Optics, Cognition and Emotion: A Novel Look at the Early Work of Wilhelm Wundt
(/isis/citation/CBB000930502/)
Thesis
Pajewski, Alessandro;
(2012)
The Face of Nature: Hume and Darwin on Analogy and Emotion
(/isis/citation/CBB001561023/)
Book
Michael Davis;
(2006)
George Eliot and Nineteenth-Century Psychology: Exploring the Unmapped Country
(/isis/citation/CBB890472950/)
Book
Darwin, Charles;
(1998)
The expression of the emotions in man and animals. Third edition. With an introduction, afterword and commentaries by Ekman, Paul. Essay on the history of the illustrations by Prodger, Phillip
(/isis/citation/CBB000079662/)
Article
Darwin, Charles;
(1984)
On instinct
(/isis/citation/CBB000014810/)
Article
Reed, Edward S.;
(1982)
Darwin's earthworms: A case study in evolutionary psychology
(/isis/citation/CBB000025742/)
Article
Gjerløff, Anne Katrine;
(2009)
Fra aber i ankedoter til katte i kasser---Evolutionsteoriens rolle i dyrepskologiens udvikling
(/isis/citation/CBB001022217/)
Book
Prodger, Phillip;
(2009)
Darwin's Camera: Art and Photography in the Theory of Evolution
(/isis/citation/CBB000952772/)
Chapter
Knoll, Elizabeth;
(1997)
Dogs, Darwinism, and English sensibilities
(/isis/citation/CBB000071849/)
Article
Armstrong, Patrick;
(1993)
An ethnologist aboard HMS Beagle: The young Darwin's observations on animal behavior
(/isis/citation/CBB000039602/)
Book
Mauro Antonelli;
(2019)
Vittorio Benussi in the History of Psychology: New Ideas of a Century Ago
(/isis/citation/CBB446831039/)
Book
Coleman, Deirdre;
Fraser, Hilary;
(2011)
Minds, Bodies, Machines, 1770--1930
(/isis/citation/CBB001201372/)
Thesis
Rossi, Michael Paul;
(2011)
The Rules of Perception: American Color Science, 1831--1931
(/isis/citation/CBB001567292/)
Be the first to comment!