Norms of Testimony in Broad Interdisciplinarity: The Case of Quantum Mechanics in Critical Theory (2021)
While much interdisciplinarity brings together proximate fields, broad interdisciplinarity sees integration between disciplines that are perceived to be non-neighboring. This paper argues that the heterogeneity among disciplines in broad interdisciplinarity calls for stricter epistemic norms of testimony for experts that act as translators between the disciplines than those suggested for intra-scientific testimony. The paper is structured around two case studies: the affective turn in social theorizing and the use of quantum mechanics in critical theory as exemplified by Vicky Kirby’s use of work by Karen Barad. These are argued to be instances of broad interdisciplinary borrowing where few translators have joint expertise in both disciplines. For most, therefore, the engagement with for instance the integration between quantum mechanics and critical theory is possible only by the aid of translators. For those without sufficient interactional expertise, however, the epistemic credentials of the translations they inevitably rely upon are inscrutable. Furthermore, any comparison between translations is challenged since translations are argued to be few due to the cognitive divergence between disciplines in broad interdisciplinarity. Consequently, the epistemic integrity of broad interdisciplinarity can only be secured through additional norms of testimony for translators. The paper proposes that (a) all translator’s testimony in broad interdisciplinarity must aim to be neutral with respect to disputed issues within the relevant disciplines and (b) any deviation from (a) must be clearly highlighted.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Molly A. Wallace;
Concetta V. Principe;
(2022)
From Cogito to Covid: Rethinking Lacan’s “Science and Truth”
Article
Marina Gasnier;
(2019)
Réflexion épistémologique sur le patrimoine industriel: De la pluridisciplinarité à l’interdisciplinarité
Article
Alfonso-Goldfarb, Ana M.;
Waisse, Silvia;
Ferraz, Márcia H. M.;
(2013)
From Shelves to Cyberspace: Organization of Knowledge and the Complex Identity of History of Science
Article
Christophe Schinckus;
(2021)
The Santa Fe Institute and Econophysics: A Possible Genealogy?
Article
Pietro Daniel Omodeo;
(2022)
History of Science and History of the Earth in the Anthropocene
Book
Eric R. Scerri;
Elena Ghibaudi;
(2020)
What Is A Chemical Element? A Collection of Essays by Chemists, Philosophers, Historians, and Educators
Article
Seth C. Rasmussen;
(2022)
Moving Beyond the Intersection of Chemistry and History: Evolving Multidisciplinary Approaches to the Historical Study of Chemistry
Book
Sophie A. De Beaune;
Alessandro Guidi;
Oscar Moro Abadia;
Massimo Tarantini;
(2021)
New Advances in the History of Archaeology: Proceedings of the XVIII Uispp World Congress 4-9 June 2018, Paris, France Sessions Organised by the ... of the XVIII Uispp World Congress, 16)
Article
Evelyn Brister;
(2016)
Disciplinary capture and epistemological obstacles to interdisciplinary research: Lessons from central African conservation disputes
Article
Talia Dan-Cohen;
(September 2016)
Ignoring Complexity: Epistemic Wagers and Knowledge Practices among Synthetic Biologists
Book
Oliver Leistert;
Isabell Schrickel;
(2020)
Thinking the Problematic: Genealogies and Explorations between Philosophy and the Sciences
Article
Deborah R. Coen;
Fredrik Albritton Jonsson;
(2022)
Between History and Earth System Science
Article
Jürgen Renn;
(2022)
From the History of Science to Geoanthropology
Chapter
Evandro Agazzi;
(2024)
Filosofia e storia della scienza per la promozione di una cultura all'altezza del nostro tempo
Book
Fabio Minazzi;
(2024)
Storia e Filosofia della Scienza: una nuova alleanza?
Article
Daniela K. Helbig;
Maureen A. O’Malley;
(2022)
‘The border problems of science and philosophy’: Ilse Rosenthal-Schneider and post-World War 2 science in Australian academia and society
Chapter
Armitage, John;
(2020)
Critical Theory and the Singular Instant of Luxury: On Contemporary Conceptions of Luxury Customer Experience
Article
Justin Evans;
(2022)
Rahel Jaeggi’s theory of alienation
Article
Kudzai Matereke;
(March 2020)
Mobilizing Disability Studies: A Critical Perspective
Book
Kalervo N. Gulson;
Sam Sellar;
P. Taylor Webb;
(2022)
Algorithms of Education: How Datafication and Artificial Intelligence Shape Policy
Be the first to comment!