Article ID: CBB845303448

Pygmies, Bushmen, and savage numbers – a case study in a sequence of bad citations (2023)

unapi

There is a prevalent claim in the literature examining the history of numbers and the development of number words that some African group (“Bushmen” or “Pygmies”) counts in a particular way, where their numerals are of the form 1, 2, 3, 2+2, 2+2+1, etc. Numerous forms of this claim are traced back to their original sources through an extensive search of the available literature. The author argues that the different forms can be traced back to two early sources, which have been misquoted and bastardized along the way. Numeraalien historiaa ja kehitystä käsittelevässä kirjallisuudessa esiintyy usein väite, että jokin afrikkalainen kansa ("bushmanit" tai "pygmit") laskee siten, että heidän numeraalinsa ovat muotoa 1, 2, 3, 2+2, 2+2+1, jne. Monia väitteen eri muotoiluja jäljitetään alkuperäislähteisiin tutkimalla laajasti saatavilla olevaa kirjallisuutta. Kirjoittaja argumentoi, että väitteen eri muodot voidaan jäljittää kahteen varhaiseen alkuperäislähteeseen, joiden sanoma on matkalla vääristynyt.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB845303448/

Similar Citations

Article Armatte, Michel; (2006)
Les images de la Statistique à travers ses traités

Article Joaquim Berenguer Clarià; (2021)
Los cursos de cálculo diferencial de Rieger en el Colegio Imperial de Madrid

Article Anna Kiel Steensen; Mikkel Willum Johansen; Morten Misfeldt; (2022)
Textual materiality and abstraction in mathematics

Article Anuj Misra; (2022)
Sanskrit Recension of Persian Astronomy: The computation of true declination in Nityānanda's Sarvasiddhāntarāja

Article Emmylou Haffner; (2023)
Relectures et réécritures des textes de B. Riemann dans leur édition par R. Dedekind et H. Weber

Article Leonid Zhmud; (2023)
The Menaechmi

Article Dominique Raynaud; (2023)
Da Vinci's Codex Atlanticus, fols. 395r and 686r–686v, refers to Leonardo Pisano volgarizzato, not to Giorgio Valla

Article Joseph Louis Lagrange; Maria Teresa Borgato; (2013)
Solution d'un problème sur les rentes viagères

Article Stevens, Wesley M.; (2013)
A Small Circle in the Tabula Paschalis of Murbach, A.D. 814-820

Article Enrico Giusti; (2022)
The Sources of Leonardo Pisano and how he used them

Article Napolitani, Pier Daniele; (2009)
The «Edizione Nazionale» of Francesco Maurolico’s Mathematical Works

Article Elisabetta Ulivi; (2022)
L’intervento del matematico senese Dionigi Gori nella bonifica della Valdichiana, da lettere inedite dell’Archivio Barbolani da Montauto ad Anghiari

Article David Buckle; (2023)
How the estimate of √2 on YBC 7289 may have been calculated

Article Argante Ciocci; (2021)
Federico Commandino e le Spirali di Archimede

Article Beatrice Sisana; (2021)
Tempi, luoghi e contenuti della corrispondenza tra Federico Commandino e Francesco Maurolico

Article Enrico Giusti; (2022)
Un trattato trecentesco di geometria di ambito genovese e la sua traduzione in volgare

Article Riccardo Bellè; (2022)
Il processo compositivo del De sphaera et cylindro ex traditione Maurolyci

Article Maria Giulia Lugaresi; (2020)
Il carteggio Gianfrancesco Malfatti - Giordano Riccati: Il carteggio scientifico Malfatti-Riccati

Book Davide Pietrini; (2023)
Matematica antica, macchine e strumenti. L'umanesimo matematico a Urbino dal tardo Rinascimento alla rivoluzione galileiana

Article Paolo Freguglia; (2022)
Marinus Ghetaldus’s Supplementum Apollonij Galli. An Analysis

Authors & Contributors
Armatte, Michel
Bellé, Riccardo
Borgato, Maria Teresa
Ciocci, Argante
Freguglia, Paolo
Giusti, Enrico
Journals
Bollettino di Storia delle Scienze Matematiche
Historia Mathematica
Physis: Rivista Internazionale di Storia della Scienza
Almagest
Apeiron: Journal for Ancient Philosophy and Science
Journal Electronique d'Histoire des Probabilités et de la Statistique
Publishers
Mimesis
Concepts
Mathematics
Ecdotics; source study (methodology)
Manuscripts
Geometry
Critical editions
Translations
People
Commandino, Federico
Maurolico, Francesco
Archimedes
Lagrange, Joseph Louis
Apollonius, of Perga
Baldi, Bernardino
Time Periods
Renaissance
18th century
16th century
19th century
Medieval
17th century
Places
Italy
Paris (France)
Berlin (Germany)
Tuscany (Italy)
India
France
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment