Stefano Furlani (Author)
Rocco Gaudenzi (Author)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science
Volume: 93
Pages: 163-174
The debate around analogy in modern physics that focuses on its role as a logical inference often correspondingly overlooks its historical dimension and the other equally important functions and aspects that are intertwined with this dimension. Inspired by a close investigation of the primary sources and archival material of a few historical actors, this paper lays out a framework on analogy-making which preserves as much as possible its historical complexity. While not losing sight of the logical role, our framework puts a special emphasis on the heuristic process, and aims at offering to the historian and philosopher of science as well as the physicist some tools to capture the subtle functions of analogical reasoning involved in such a process. After having traced it out theoretically, we make use of this framework to interpret the growth of the ideas of two remarkable physicists dealing with the multifaceted notion of vacuum in 20th century physics. We first consider the trajectory followed by John A. Wheeler, between the 1960s and 1970s, towards (in his own words) a “geology of the vacuum”; and then examine, starting from the hitherto neglected Japanese reception of the idea of Dirac sea in the early 1930s, the pathway that led Yoichiro Nambu to the discovery of spontaneous symmetry breaking.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Odenwald, Sten F.;
(2002)
Patterns in the Void: Why Nothing is Important
(/isis/citation/CBB000201504/)
Article
Shelley, Cameron;
(2002)
Analogy Counterarguments and the Acceptability of Analogical Hypotheses
(/isis/citation/CBB000410708/)
Article
Carlos Alberto Cardona Suárez;
Juliana Gutiérrez Valderrama;
(2020)
The law of refraction and Kepler’s heuristics
(/isis/citation/CBB762043717/)
Article
Janiak, Andrew;
(2010)
Substance and Action in Descartes and Newton
(/isis/citation/CBB001221446/)
Book
Barrow, John D.;
(2000)
Book of Nothing: Vacuums, Voids, and the Latest Ideas about the Origins of the Universe
(/isis/citation/CBB000102094/)
Article
Kosso, Peter;
(2013)
Void Points, Rosettes, and a Brief History of Planetary Astronomy
(/isis/citation/CBB001320578/)
Article
Giglioni, Guido;
(2014)
From the Woods of Experience to the Open Fields of Metaphysics: Bacon's Notion of Silva
(/isis/citation/CBB001201350/)
Book
Hans Blumenberg;
(2022)
The Readability of the World
(/isis/citation/CBB409613183/)
Article
Miller, Sean;
(2011)
The Work of Imagining Subatomic Particles in Early Quantum Mechanics
(/isis/citation/CBB001252267/)
Article
Juliana Genevieve Souza André;
(2021)
O Ato de Pensar X Pensamento no contexto de David Bohm: O Despertar da Criatividade em Oposição à Arbitrariedade e Fragmentação do Conhecimento Científico
(/isis/citation/CBB985176137/)
Article
Juliana Genevieve Souza André;
(2021)
Thinking vs. Thought in the context of David Bohm: The Awakening of Creativity as Opposed to Arbitrariness and Fragmentation of Scientific Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB584036730/)
Book
Paul Halpern;
(2017)
The Quantum Labyrinth: How Richard Feynman and John Wheeler Revolutionized Time and Reality
(/isis/citation/CBB858107777/)
Thesis
Christensen, Terry M.;
(2009)
John Archibald Wheeler: A Study of Mentoring in Modern Physics
(/isis/citation/CBB001560756/)
Chapter
Joly, Bernard;
(2000)
Rhétorique de l'alchimie au XVIIe siècle: cacher l'échec et diffuser la doctrine
(/isis/citation/CBB000750961/)
Chapter
Antonino Drago;
(2009)
Rivisitando la storia del corpo nero: la falsa coscienza dei fisici
(/isis/citation/CBB281610621/)
Article
Manning, Gideon;
(2012)
Analogy and Falsification in Descartes' Physics
(/isis/citation/CBB001221698/)
Article
Francesco Nappo;
(2021)
The double nature of Maxwell's physical analogies
(/isis/citation/CBB554615043/)
Article
Cat, Jordi;
(2001)
On Understanding: Maxwell on the Methods of Illustration and Scientific Metaphor
(/isis/citation/CBB000100733/)
Chapter
Palmerino, Carla Rita;
(2007)
Bodies in Water like Planets in the Skies: Uses and Abuses of Analogical Reasoning in the Study of Planetary Motion
(/isis/citation/CBB001032045/)
Article
Andrea Sullivan-Clarke;
(2019)
Misled by Metaphor: The Problem of Ingrained Analogy
(/isis/citation/CBB181919885/)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science
Archive for History of Exact Sciences
British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
Configurations: A Journal of Literature, Science, and Technology
Monist: An International Quarterly Journal of General Philosophical Inquiry
Be the first to comment!