Shcheglov, Dmitry A. (Author)
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Volume: 107
Issue: 4
Pages: 687-706
This essay seeks to explain the most glaring error in Ptolemy’s geography: the greatly exaggerated longitudinal extent of the known world as shown on his map. The main focus is on a recent hypothesis that attributes all responsibility for this error to Ptolemy’s adoption of the wrong value for the circumference of the Earth. This explanation has challenging implications for our understanding of ancient geography: it presupposes that before Ptolemy there had been a tradition of high-accuracy geodesy and cartography based on Eratosthenes’ measurement of the Earth. The essay argues that this hypothesis does not stand up to scrutiny. The story proves to be much more complex than can be accounted for by a single-factor explanation. A more careful analysis of the evidence allows us to assess the individual contribution to Ptolemy’s error made by each character in this story: Eratosthenes, Ptolemy, ancient surveyors, and others. As a result, a more balanced and well-founded assessment is offered: Ptolemy’s reputation is rehabilitated in part, and the delusion of high-accuracy ancient cartography is dispelled.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Pascal Arnaud;
(2017)
Le traitement cartographique de l’information périplographique et diaplographique par Ptolémée: quelques exemples
(/isis/citation/CBB598591299/)
Book
Ariel, Avraham;
Berger, Nora Ariel;
(2006)
Plotting the Globe: Stories of Meridians, Parallels, and the International Date Line
(/isis/citation/CBB000720065/)
Article
Pietro Janni;
(2017)
Tolomeo, uno «sconfitto della storia»?
(/isis/citation/CBB034147992/)
Article
Dmitry A. Shcheglov;
(2017)
Eratosthenes’ Contribution to Ptolemy’s Map of the World
(/isis/citation/CBB350685006/)
Article
Didier Marcotte;
(2017)
Ptolémée ethnographe. Questions de tradition
(/isis/citation/CBB957748695/)
Article
Francesco Prontera;
(2017)
Da Strabone a Tolemeo: cartografia generale e regionale
(/isis/citation/CBB755353886/)
Article
Silvia Panichi;
(2017)
L’istmo della penisola anatolica
(/isis/citation/CBB011132737/)
Article
Arthur Haushalter;
(2017)
L’Ibérie de Ptolémée, entre géographie mathématique et procédés empiriques
(/isis/citation/CBB671783196/)
Article
Philippe Seubert;
(2017)
Délimitation et divisions de l’Arabie, d’Eratosthène à Ptolémée
(/isis/citation/CBB139661885/)
Article
Ekaterina Ilyushechkina;
(2012)
Zur Quellenfrage der "Erdbeschreibung" des Dionysios Periegetes: Die "Geographika" Strabons als eine der Quellen?
(/isis/citation/CBB018647695/)
Article
Francesco Prontera;
(2010)
Carta e testo nella geografia antica
(/isis/citation/CBB295904750/)
Article
Klaus Geus;
(2017)
Wer ist Marinos von Tyros? Zur Hauptquelle des Ptolemaios in seiner Geographie
(/isis/citation/CBB527586063/)
Article
Francesco Prontera;
(2018)
Le Alpi nelle tavole di Tolemeo
(/isis/citation/CBB145765288/)
Chapter
Jones, Alexander;
(2010)
Ancient Rejection and Adoption of Ptolemy's Frame of Reference for Longitudes
(/isis/citation/CBB001021796/)
Article
Marx, Christian;
(2012)
Investigations of the coordinates in Ptolemy's Geographike Hyphegesis Book 8
(/isis/citation/CBB001251103/)
Article
Christian Marx;
(2016)
The Western Coast of Africa in Ptolemy's Geography and the Location of his Prime Meridian
(/isis/citation/CBB116997130/)
Chapter
Stückelberger, Alfred;
(2008)
Das Europabild bei Ptolemaios
(/isis/citation/CBB001020363/)
Book
Talbert, Richard J. A.;
(2010)
Rome's World: The Peutinger Map Reconsidered
(/isis/citation/CBB001251942/)
Article
Edson, Evelyn;
Savage-Smith, Emilie;
(2000)
An Astrologer's Map: A Relic of Late Antiquity
(/isis/citation/CBB000671372/)
Article
Salway, Benet;
(2005)
The Nature and Genesis of the Peutinger Map
(/isis/citation/CBB000651793/)
Be the first to comment!